ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Thermal Stress in Concrete Hardening Inside Steel Tube Arches Based on Equivalent Age Method

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper by Sun Jianyuan and Xie Jinbao from Tongji University investigates the thermal stress development during the hardening process of concrete inside large-diameter steel tube arches. The study uses finite element analysis to simulate the hydration heat conduction process in the concrete, validates the model against measured temperature field data, and then applies the equivalent age method to account for the temperature dependence of the concrete's elastic modulus growth. The thermal-mechanical coupling is analyzed using thermoelasticity theory.

The key finding is that the hydration heat temperature field accelerates the growth of the concrete's elastic modulus during hardening, which leads to a significant increase in thermal stress. The radial, circumferential, and longitudinal thermal stresses increase by factors of 1.3, 1.3, and 1.4, respectively, compared to calculations that ignore the temperature dependence of the elastic modulus. However, the effect on the steel tube stress is negligible. The authors conclude that the influence of the hydration heat temperature field on the elastic modulus growth must be considered when analyzing thermal-mechanical effects during concrete hardening in large-diameter steel tube arches.

Technical Interpretation and Engineering Significance

The Equivalent Age Method Explained

The equivalent age method is a mature approach for accounting for the temperature dependence of concrete strength and stiffness development. The concept is that concrete cured at different temperatures will have different maturity, and the equivalent age is a way to convert the actual curing history into an equivalent time at a reference temperature. This allows the engineer to predict the concrete's properties at any point in time based on its temperature history.

In the context of steel tube arches, this is particularly important because the concrete is placed inside a closed steel tube, and the hydration heat cannot dissipate easily. This leads to elevated temperatures within the concrete, which accelerate the hydration reaction and increase the rate of elastic modulus growth. However, the elevated temperature also causes thermal expansion, which creates thermal stress in the concrete and the steel tube.

Thermal Stress Development Mechanism

The thermal stress in the concrete during hardening is a result of the combined effects of:

  1. Thermal expansion due to the temperature rise from hydration heat.
  2. Restraint from the steel tube, which has a different coefficient of thermal expansion and a different stiffness.
  3. The development of the concrete's elastic modulus, which determines how much stress is generated for a given strain.

The paper's finding that the temperature-dependent elastic modulus growth increases the thermal stress by 30-40% is significant. This means that if you ignore this effect, you will underestimate the thermal stress in the concrete, which could lead to cracking or other damage.

Practical Implications for Large-Diameter Steel Tube Arches

For large-diameter steel tube arches, the concrete is typically placed in segments, and the hydration heat can be substantial. The temperature rise can be significant, especially in the center of the concrete mass where heat dissipation is slowest. This creates a temperature gradient between the center and the outer surface, which can lead to differential thermal expansion and cracking.

The paper's finding that the effect on the steel tube stress is negligible is interesting but not surprising. The steel tube has a much higher thermal conductivity than concrete, so it tends to follow the temperature of the surrounding environment more closely. Additionally, the steel tube's stiffness is much higher than the concrete's, so the concrete's thermal expansion is largely restrained by the tube, but the tube itself does not experience significant stress from this restraint.

Practical Engineering Insights and Lessons Learned

Design Considerations

  1. Temperature Control is Critical: The hydration heat in large-diameter steel tube arches can be significant, and the temperature rise must be controlled to avoid cracking. This can be achieved by using low-heat cement, adding pozzolanic materials, or using cooling pipes in the concrete.
  2. Elastic Modulus Development Must Be Considered: The paper's key finding is that the temperature-dependent elastic modulus growth must be considered in the analysis. This means that the analysis should be performed in a time-dependent manner, with the concrete's elastic modulus updated at each time step based on the equivalent age.
  3. Thermal Stress is a Design Load: The thermal stress generated during hardening is a significant load that must be considered in the design. This is particularly important for the concrete, which is weak in tension and prone to cracking.

Construction Considerations

  1. Concrete Placement: The concrete must be placed in a way that minimizes the temperature rise and ensures uniform temperature distribution. This may involve placing the concrete in multiple lifts, using low-heat concrete, or using post-cooling methods.
  2. Monitoring: Temperature monitoring during the hardening process is essential to verify that the temperature rise is within acceptable limits and to validate the analysis. This is particularly important for large-diameter arches where the temperature rise can be significant.
  3. Curing: The curing process must be carefully controlled to ensure that the concrete develops adequate strength and stiffness. The steel tube provides some protection, but the concrete at the ends of the tube may be exposed and require additional curing.

Quality Control and Inspection

The quality of the concrete in the steel tube is critical to the performance of the structure. The concrete must be placed without voids, and the bond between the concrete and the steel tube must be adequate. This can be verified by ultrasonic testing, which can detect voids and poor bond.

Concluding Reflections

This paper provides valuable insight into the thermal-mechanical behavior of concrete hardening inside steel tube arches. The key finding that the temperature-dependent elastic modulus growth increases thermal stress by 30-40% is significant and should be incorporated into design practice. For engineers involved in the design and construction of large-diameter steel tube arches, this paper reinforces the importance of considering the hydration heat temperature field in the analysis, controlling the temperature rise during construction, and monitoring the concrete temperature to verify the analysis. The paper also highlights the need for careful attention to the concrete mix design and placement procedures to minimize the temperature rise and ensure adequate strength development.