Segmental Prefabricated Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Bridge Piers with External Arched Energy Dissipation Devices: Seismic Performance and Fabrication Considerations
The Design Concept and Motivation
The concept of segmental prefabricated bridge piers is driven by the need to accelerate construction, reduce traffic disruption, and improve quality control by casting concrete elements in a factory rather than on site. However, the joints between segments are the weak points in a seismic event. In a conventional monolithic pier, the plastic hinge forms at the base of the pier, where the reinforcement yields and the concrete crushes, dissipating energy. In a segmental pier, the joints tend to open and close, and the energy dissipation is much lower, which can lead to large residual displacements and damage that is difficult to repair. The paper by Wang Chengquan et al., published in the Journal of Central South University in 2024, proposes a solution: an external arched energy dissipation device that can be installed on the outside of the pier, which absorbs energy during a seismic event and can be replaced after the event.
The device is a steel plate that is bent into an arch shape and attached to the exterior of the pier segments. The concept is that during an earthquake, the pier rocks and the arched plate deforms, dissipating energy through plastic deformation. After the earthquake, the damaged plate can be unbolted and replaced with a new one, restoring the pier to its original capacity. This is a "damage-control" or "replaceable fuse" approach, which is increasingly popular in seismic design because it limits damage to a replaceable element and protects the main structure.
What the Finite Element Analysis Shows
The paper uses ABAQUS to model four configurations of a four-segment prefabricated CFST pier: (1) without any energy dissipation device, (2) with an external arched steel plate, (3) with an external vertical steel plate, and (4) with the proposed external arched energy dissipation device. The models are subjected to cyclic displacement loading, and the seismic performance is compared in terms of lateral bearing capacity, initial stiffness, and energy dissipation capacity.
The results are striking. The proposed arched energy dissipation device improves the lateral bearing capacity by 39.4% compared to the pier without any device, by 28.8% compared to the pier with an external arched steel plate, and by 11.9% compared to the pier with an external vertical steel plate. The initial stiffness is improved by 10.4%, 4.6%, and 2.5% respectively. The most dramatic improvement is in energy dissipation capacity: the proposed device dissipates 18.1 times more energy than the pier without any device, and 13 times more than the pier with an external arched steel plate. The residual displacement of the pier with the proposed device remains within 1 mm throughout the entire loading range, with a drift ratio of less than 1%, and the damage is concentrated in the arched energy dissipation device, allowing for rapid post-earthquake repair.
| Performance Metric | No Device | Arched Steel Plate | Vertical Steel Plate | Arched Energy Dissipation Device |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lateral bearing capacity (relative) | 1.00 | 1.08 | 1.25 | 1.39 |
| Initial stiffness (relative) | 1.00 | 1.06 | 1.08 | 1.10 |
| Energy dissipation (relative) | 1.00 | 1.40 | 14.00 | 18.10 |
| Residual displacement | > 5 mm | > 3 mm | ~ 2 mm | < 1 mm |
The paper's conclusion is that the arched energy dissipation device is superior to both the plain arched plate and the vertical plate, because the arch shape provides a more favourable stress distribution and a more stable plastic hinge, which results in a more efficient energy dissipation mechanism.
Fabrication and Welding Considerations
From a steel pipe fabrication perspective, this design introduces a new set of challenges. The arched energy dissipation device is a formed steel plate that must be welded to the exterior of the CFST pier segments. The welding of this device to the steel tube requires careful attention to the following points:
- The material of the energy dissipation device must have sufficient ductility and toughness to undergo large plastic deformations without fracture. Typically, a low-yield-strength steel such as LYP100 or LYP160 is used, which has a yield strength of 100–160 MPa and an elongation of over 50%. This is a very different material from the high-strength steel used for the main tube, and the welding procedure must be qualified separately.
- The welding of the device to the tube must be performed with a controlled heat input to avoid damaging the concrete inside the tube. If the tube is already filled with concrete, the welding heat can cause the concrete to crack or to lose its bond with the steel tube. In practice, the energy dissipation device should be welded to the tube before the concrete is placed, or the welding should be performed with a low heat input and with the concrete protected by a cooling medium.
- The fillet weld between the device and the tube must be designed to transfer the shear forces from the device to the tube without causing a stress concentration that could initiate a crack in the tube. The weld should be continuous, with a minimum throat thickness of 0.7 times the plate thickness, and the weld toe should be ground smooth to reduce the stress concentration.
- The arched shape of the device must be formed accurately. If the arch is not formed to the specified radius, the device will not contact the tube surface uniformly, and the weld will have gaps that reduce the effective load transfer. The forming process should be verified with a template, and the device should be trial-fitted to the tube before welding.
Reflection and Outlook
The paper is a valuable contribution to the field of seismic design of prefabricated bridge piers. The proposed arched energy dissipation device is a practical solution to the problem of low energy dissipation in segmental piers, and the finite element analysis provides a solid basis for further development. However, I would note that the paper is based on finite element analysis only; there are no experimental results to validate the model. In my experience, finite element models of welded steel structures often overestimate the energy dissipation capacity, because they do not account for the effect of welding residual stress, which can reduce the ductility of the steel and promote premature fracture. The next step should be a full-scale cyclic loading test of a pier with the proposed device, which would provide the experimental validation that the design needs.
From a practical standpoint, the replaceability of the energy dissipation device is its most attractive feature. In a real seismic event, the ability to unbolt a damaged device and bolt on a new one in a matter of hours, rather than demolishing and rebuilding the pier, is a huge economic advantage. This is the kind of design that should be encouraged in seismic zones. The steel pipe industry should be ready to supply the energy dissipation devices with the required material properties and fabrication tolerances, and the welding procedures should be qualified in advance so that the devices can be installed quickly and reliably when they are needed.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd