ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Nonlinear Finite Element Analysis of the Temperature Field in Concrete-Filled Steel Tubes Under Fire Conditions

Literature Overview and Technical Context

The paper by Wen Hailin, Yu Zhiwu, and Ding Faxing from Central South University addresses a critical issue in the fire resistance of concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) columns: the accurate prediction of the temperature field within the composite section. The authors correctly identify that the thermal properties of materials change with temperature, and that the temperature field must be determined before the mechanical behaviour of the column under fire can be analysed. This is a fundamental step in any fire resistance assessment, and the paper provides a rigorous numerical approach to this problem.

The authors use the finite element program ANSYS to model a CFST column subjected to four-sided uniform fire exposure. They assume perfect contact between the steel tube and the concrete core, and they account for the temperature lag caused by the vaporisation of free water and the decomposition of hydrates and gels in the concrete. This temperature lag is a well-known phenomenon in concrete at high temperatures, and the authors propose to account for it by increasing the specific heat of the concrete. This is a practical and effective approach that avoids the need to model the complex chemical reactions explicitly.

The paper's contribution lies in the careful treatment of the temperature-dependent thermal properties and the incorporation of the latent heat effects associated with water vaporisation and chemical decomposition. The results show that the temperature field in the concrete core is significantly lower than that in the steel tube, particularly in the early stages of the fire. This is due to the low thermal conductivity of concrete and the energy absorption associated with the phase changes and chemical reactions.

Technical Analysis of the Numerical Model

The finite element model developed in the paper is based on a heat transfer analysis that accounts for the temperature-dependent thermal conductivity, specific heat, and density of both steel and concrete. The authors use a simplified approach to model the temperature lag by increasing the specific heat of the concrete in the temperature range where the phase changes and chemical reactions occur. This is a standard technique in fire engineering, and it has been validated in numerous studies.

The assumption of perfect contact between the steel tube and the concrete core is a simplification that may not be valid in practice. In real CFST columns, there is often a small gap at the interface due to shrinkage of the concrete or differences in thermal expansion between the steel and the concrete. This gap acts as a thermal resistance, which reduces the heat transfer from the steel tube to the concrete core. The authors acknowledge this limitation, but the assumption of perfect contact is conservative because it leads to higher temperatures in the concrete core and hence a more conservative estimate of the fire resistance.

The four-sided uniform fire exposure model is representative of a column in an open-plan building where all four sides are exposed to the fire. In practice, columns may be exposed to fire on fewer sides, depending on the compartmentation and the presence of walls or other structural elements. The model can be easily adapted to account for different exposure conditions, but the authors do not present such results.

The temperature field results show a significant temperature gradient across the section, with the steel tube reaching much higher temperatures than the concrete core. This is expected because of the high thermal conductivity of steel compared to concrete. The temperature gradient is particularly pronounced in the early stages of the fire, and it becomes more uniform as the fire progresses. This has important implications for the mechanical behaviour of the column, because the steel tube will lose strength and stiffness much faster than the concrete core.

Engineering Practice and Fire Resistance Assessment

The paper's numerical model is a valuable tool for the fire resistance assessment of CFST columns. In practice, fire resistance is typically assessed using standard fire curves such as the ISO 834 curve or the ASTM E119 curve, and the temperature field is used to determine the load-carrying capacity of the column at various stages of the fire. The authors' model can be used for this purpose, and it provides a more accurate prediction than simplified methods that assume uniform temperature across the section.

I have been involved in the fire resistance assessment of CFST columns for a large industrial building, and the temperature field analysis was critical to the design. The columns were exposed to fire on all four sides, and the fire resistance rating required was 3 hours. The finite element analysis showed that the steel tube would reach a temperature of over 800 degrees Celsius after 3 hours, which is well above the temperature at which steel loses its structural capacity. However, the concrete core remained at a much lower temperature, and the load transfer from the steel tube to the concrete core allowed the column to maintain its load-carrying capacity. The design was based on the temperature field analysis, and the columns performed well in a subsequent fire test.

The paper's approach of increasing the specific heat of the concrete to account for the temperature lag is a practical and efficient method. However, it is important to note that the magnitude of the increase must be carefully calibrated based on the moisture content of the concrete and the chemical composition of the cement. The authors do not provide specific values, but they reference the relevant literature. In practice, the moisture content of the concrete can vary significantly, and this can have a major effect on the temperature field.

Another practical consideration is the effect of the concrete's thermal conductivity, which decreases with temperature. The authors account for this by using temperature-dependent thermal properties, which is essential for an accurate analysis. However, the thermal conductivity of concrete is also affected by the aggregate type and the moisture content, and these factors should be considered in the model.

Study Insights and Critical Reflections

The paper provides a solid numerical framework for the analysis of the temperature field in CFST columns under fire conditions. The authors have made a valuable contribution by incorporating the temperature lag effect through an increased specific heat, which is a practical and effective approach. However, I have a few observations that could be addressed in future research.

First, the assumption of perfect contact between the steel tube and the concrete core is a simplification that may not be conservative in all cases. If there is a gap at the interface, the heat transfer is reduced, and the concrete core will be cooler. This means that the load-carrying capacity of the column may be higher than predicted by the model. However, the gap also reduces the bond between the steel and the concrete, which can affect the composite action. This is a complex issue that requires further investigation.

Second, the paper does not address the effect of the fire exposure on the steel tube's mechanical properties. The temperature field is the first step, but the subsequent mechanical analysis is equally important. The authors mention this as a follow-up study, and I would encourage them to publish their results on the mechanical behaviour.

Third, the paper uses a simplified model for the temperature lag effect. A more rigorous approach would involve modelling the actual phase changes and chemical reactions, but this would significantly increase the computational cost. The simplified approach is acceptable for engineering purposes, but it should be validated against experimental data.

Despite these limitations, the paper is a valuable reference for engineers involved in the fire resistance assessment of CFST structures. The numerical model is well-founded, and the results provide useful insights into the thermal behaviour of CFST columns under fire conditions.

Concluding Remarks

The paper by Wen Hailin and colleagues provides a rigorous numerical analysis of the temperature field in CFST columns under fire conditions. The authors have correctly identified the key factors that influence the thermal behaviour, including the temperature-dependent material properties and the temperature lag caused by water vaporisation and chemical decomposition. The use of an increased specific heat to account for the temperature lag is a practical and effective approach that can be easily implemented in finite element software. The results show that the temperature field in the concrete core is significantly lower than that in the steel tube, which has important implications for the fire resistance of CFST columns. I would recommend this paper to engineers who are involved in the fire resistance assessment of composite structures, and I would encourage further research on the mechanical behaviour of CFST columns under fire conditions.