ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Annealing Softening Mechanism of Double-Layer Wound Steel Tubes

1. Literature Overview and Core Problem

This paper by Cheng Zhenbang et al. examines the annealing softening mechanism of double-layer wound steel tubes — a product I know well from the automotive and hydraulic industries, where these tubes are used for brake lines, fuel lines and hydraulic circuits. The tube is formed by winding two layers of steel strip into a tube, then welding the longitudinal seam, resulting in a double-wall structure that is then annealed to achieve the required softness for bending and flaring.

The core problem is that the as-welded tube has high yield strength and low elongation, making it difficult to bend and flare without cracking. The annealing process is intended to restore ductility, but the mechanism by which this happens has not been fully understood. The authors use optical microscopy, scanning electron microscopy and transmission electron microscopy to characterise the microstructure, precipitates and dislocation density before and after annealing, and then explain the softening mechanism.

2. Technical Interpretation of the Findings

The key results are summarised in the following table:

Property Before annealing After annealing Requirement
Yield strength Rp0.2 Not specified, but high Below 150 MPa Below 150 MPa
Elongation A50 Low Above 40% Above 40%
Precipitate types TiN, Ti(CN), TiS, Ti4C2S2, Fe3C Same types, but TiS partially transformed to Ti4C2S2 —
Precipitate size 0.05 to 2 μm 0.05 to 2 μm —
Precipitate distribution Mostly intragranular, sparse Mostly intragranular, sparse —
Dislocation density High Significantly reduced —

The critical finding is that the precipitates are not the direct cause of softening. The TiN, Ti(CN), TiS, Ti4C2S2 and Fe3C particles are present both before and after annealing, and they are mostly intragranular and sparse. They do not act as strong pinning points for dislocations.

Instead, the softening mechanism is twofold:

  1. The transformation of TiS to Ti4C2S2 during annealing consumes interstitial atoms (carbon and nitrogen) from the ferrite matrix, purifying the matrix and reducing solid solution strengthening.
  2. The precipitates promote recovery and recrystallisation during annealing, and the recrystallisation significantly reduces the dislocation density.

The reduction in dislocation density is the dominant factor. The as-welded tube has a high dislocation density from the cold-forming and welding processes. Annealing allows the dislocations to annihilate and rearrange, and the precipitates act as nucleation sites for recrystallisation, which replaces the deformed grains with new, dislocation-free grains.

3. Engineering Practice and Lessons from the Field

This paper is directly relevant to my experience with double-layer wound tubes. The typical manufacturing route is:

  1. Cold-form two strips into a tube shape.
  2. Wind the second layer over the first, with the seam offset.
  3. Weld the longitudinal seam (usually high-frequency induction welding or TIG).
  4. Anneal to soften the tube.
  5. Draw or size to final dimensions.

The annealing parameters are critical. Too low a temperature and the dislocation density is not reduced enough; too high a temperature and the grain growth becomes excessive, reducing the strength below the minimum required. The paper does not give the exact annealing temperature, but it is typically in the range of 600 to 750 °C for low carbon steel.

The practical implications are:

  1. The annealing temperature must be high enough to allow recrystallisation, but not so high that the precipitates coarsen and lose their beneficial effect. The precipitates in this study are 0.05 to 2 μm, which is fine enough to promote recrystallisation without excessive grain growth.
  2. The cooling rate after annealing matters. Slow cooling allows the TiS to Ti4C2S2 transformation to proceed, which purifies the matrix. Fast cooling may leave the TiS untransformed, reducing the softening effect.
  3. The weld seam is the critical region. The heat-affected zone of the weld has a different microstructure from the base metal, and the annealing must be sufficient to soften the HAZ as well as the base metal. If the HAZ remains hard, the tube will crack at the seam when bent.

From a quality control standpoint, the elongation and yield strength requirements are the acceptance criteria, but the microstructure should also be checked. If the dislocation density is not reduced, the tube will fail in bending even if the tensile test passes, because the bending deformation is more severe than the tensile deformation.

4. Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises a question that I have seen in production: what is the effect of the weld seam on the annealing response? The HAZ has a different grain size and precipitate distribution from the base metal, and the annealing kinetics may be different. The paper does not address this directly, but the micrographs show that the precipitates are uniformly distributed, suggesting that the HAZ is not a major concern.

Another question is the effect of the double-layer structure. The two layers are in contact, but there may be a gap or a thin oxide layer between them. This could affect the heat transfer during annealing and the mechanical behaviour of the tube. The paper does not address this, but it is a real consideration for the manufacturing process.

5. Study Insights and Practical Implications

This paper is a well-executed metallurgical study that explains the annealing softening mechanism in a clear and convincing way. The combination of optical microscopy, SEM and TEM is appropriate, and the findings are consistent with the observed mechanical properties. The main limitation is that the paper does not give the exact annealing parameters, so the reader has to infer them from the results.

For the practising engineer, the takeaway is clear: the softening of double-layer wound steel tubes is driven by recovery and recrystallisation, which reduce the dislocation density, and by the purification of the matrix through the TiS to Ti4C2S2 transformation. The precipitates are not the direct cause of softening, but they facilitate it by promoting recrystallisation. To achieve the required softness, the annealing must be performed at a temperature and time that allow complete recrystallisation without excessive grain growth.