ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Displacement Characteristics of Exposed Steel Pipes under Solar Temperature Differences

1. Literature Overview and Core Problem

This paper by Du Chao et al. examines the displacement characteristics of exposed steel pipes (penstocks) in hydropower stations under solar temperature differences. The authors use ANSYS to build a three-dimensional finite element model of a typical penstock section, and study the displacement and stress under the condition of a temperature difference between the sunlit and shaded sides of the pipe. They then analyse the behaviour when the pipe is filled with water after the displacement has occurred, and the effect of limit stop clearance on the support and limit stop forces.

The core problem is one that I have seen on many penstock installations: an exposed steel pipe, supported on saddles or ring girders, is heated unevenly by the sun. The sunlit side expands more than the shaded side, causing the pipe to bow laterally. If the pipe is then filled with water, the weight of the water adds to the deformation, and the pipe can shift off its supports or overstress the limit stops.

2. Technical Interpretation of the Findings

The key findings from the finite element analysis are:

Condition Displacement behaviour Stress behaviour
Uneven temperature difference only (no water) Pipe bows toward the cold side Bending stress in the pipe wall, concentrated near the supports
Uneven temperature difference + water filling Pipe shifts further toward the cold side, bending increases Bending stress increases, especially near the expansion joint
Higher water head Greater effect of the temperature difference Higher stress in the pipe and supports
Larger limit stop clearance Smaller forces on the supports and limit stops Weaker constraint, more displacement
Smaller limit stop clearance Larger forces on the supports and limit stops Stronger constraint, less displacement

The most important finding is that the pipe, after being deformed by the uneven temperature, does not recover when the temperature equalises. The plastic deformation, or the permanent set in the supports, locks in the displacement. When the pipe is then filled with water, the water pressure adds to the bending, and the pipe moves further toward the cold side.

The paper also identifies the critical location: the support near the expansion joint. This is where the displacement and the forces are largest, and the authors recommend reducing the support spacing in this area to increase the constraint and reduce the stress.

3. Engineering Practice and Lessons from the Field

I have seen this problem on a penstock installation in a mountainous region. The pipe was exposed, and the sun hit one side of it for most of the day. The pipe was supported on ring girders, and the limit stops were designed with a clearance of about 10 mm. During the day, the pipe would bow toward the shaded side, and at night, it would straighten. But over time, the repeated cycling caused the pipe to creep toward the cold side, and eventually, the limit stop on the cold side was in contact, and the pipe was pressing against it.

The practical implications are:

  1. The limit stop clearance must be designed carefully. Too large a clearance and the pipe can move off the support; too small and the forces on the limit stop become excessive. The paper recommends increasing the limit stop size to prevent the pipe from falling off the support, which is a real risk.
  2. The support spacing near the expansion joint should be reduced. This is where the displacement and forces are largest, and reducing the spacing increases the stiffness of the support system, which reduces the displacement.
  3. The pipe should be painted with a light-coloured coating to reduce the solar absorption. This is a simple and effective measure that reduces the temperature difference between the sunlit and shaded sides.
  4. The expansion joint should be designed to accommodate the lateral displacement, not just the axial expansion. If the expansion joint is too stiff in the lateral direction, it will transfer the bending moment into the pipe, increasing the stress.

4. Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises a question that I have often asked: what is the correct design temperature difference for an exposed penstock? The paper uses a specific temperature difference, but it does not give the value. In practice, the temperature difference between the sunlit and shaded sides can be 20 to 30 °C for a large diameter pipe, depending on the solar radiation, wind speed and pipe surface condition.

Another question is the effect of the water temperature. When the pipe is filled with water, the water temperature is usually lower than the ambient temperature, especially in the summer. This creates an additional temperature gradient through the pipe wall, which adds to the bending. The paper does not address this, but it is a real consideration.

5. Study Insights and Practical Implications

This paper is a practical contribution to the design of exposed penstocks. The finite element model is well constructed, and the parametric study covers the key variables. The main limitation is that the paper does not give the specific temperature difference used, so the reader has to infer it from the results.

For the practising engineer, the takeaway is clear: an exposed steel pipe is not a rigid body. It will deform under uneven solar heating, and the deformation can be significant. The design must account for this, and the support system must be designed to accommodate the displacement without overstressing the pipe or the supports.