ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Torsion Balance Design of Steel Pipe Umbilical Cables

Literature Overview and Research Objective

The paper by Niu Xuechao and his colleagues addresses a specialized but critical issue in the design of steel pipe umbilical cables used in offshore oil and gas production. Umbilical cables are complex assemblies that contain multiple functional elements, including steel tubes for hydraulic fluid transport, electrical cables for power and communication, and armor wires for structural support. These elements are helically wound around a central core, and under tensile load, the helical winding induces a torsional moment that causes the cable to twist. This twist is undesirable because it can lead to fatigue failure of the components and damage to the connectors at the ends. The research objective is to develop a method for designing the cable such that the torsional moment is balanced, resulting in a cable that does not twist under tensile load.

The paper uses the torsion balance theory, which states that the sum of the torsional moments induced by all the helical elements must be zero for the cable to be torsion-balanced. The torsional moment of each element is proportional to the tension in the element and the helical angle. However, the steel tubes in the umbilical cable have a high bending stiffness, which complicates the analysis, as they cannot be treated as simple wires. The authors employ a finite element method to model the cable, taking into account the material properties and friction between the elements. The control variable is the helical angle of the second layer of armor wires, and the optimal angle is determined by minimizing the torsional moment under a given tensile load.

Key Findings and Technical Analysis

The finite element analysis reveals that the cable core, which consists of the steel tubes and the central filler, cannot be treated as a solid cylinder. When a tensile load is applied to the core alone, it exhibits a significant twist, indicating that the helical arrangement of the steel tubes induces a torsional moment. This is a critical finding, as it shows that the core itself contributes to the torsional imbalance and must be included in the design analysis.

By varying the helical angle of the second layer of armor wires, the authors determine the optimal angle that results in zero torsional moment under a tensile load of 100 kN. The relationship between the helical angle and the torsional moment is found to be linear, allowing the optimal angle to be determined by interpolation. The optimal angle is found to be approximately 15 degrees, which is a typical value for armor wires in umbilical cables. The finite element model is then validated by comparing the predicted torsional moment with the experimental results from a prototype cable.

The experimental test involves applying a tensile load to a full-scale umbilical cable and measuring the twist at the ends. The results show that the twist is very small, indicating that the cable is torsion-balanced. The measured twist is within the acceptable range specified by the industry standards, confirming the effectiveness of the design method. The paper also discusses the importance of the friction between the elements, which affects the torsional moment and must be accurately modeled. The friction coefficient is found to have a significant effect on the torsional moment, with a higher friction coefficient resulting in a higher torsional moment for a given helical angle.

Integration with Manufacturing and Testing Practice

From a manufacturing perspective, the production of a torsion-balanced umbilical cable requires precise control of the helical angles of all the layers. The helical angle is determined by the pitch of the winding, which is set on the cabling machine. A small error in the pitch can result in a significant torsional imbalance, leading to a cable that twists under load. In practice, the pitch of each layer must be controlled within a tolerance of ±1%, and the tension of each element must be controlled to ensure that the elements are wound uniformly.

The steel tubes in the umbilical cable are typically made of stainless steel or duplex stainless steel, with a diameter of 6-12 mm and a wall thickness of 1-2 mm. These tubes are welded using a high-frequency induction welding process, which produces a seam that is nearly invisible. The weld quality is critical, as a defect in the weld can lead to a leak in the hydraulic system. The tubes are pressure-tested before being wound into the cable, and the test pressure is typically 1.5 times the maximum working pressure.

The testing of the torsion balance is performed on a full-scale prototype, as described in the paper. The test involves applying a tensile load to the cable and measuring the twist at the ends. The twist is measured using a rotary encoder, and the results are compared to the design values. A cable is considered torsion-balanced if the twist is less than 1 degree per meter of length under the maximum working tension. The test is repeated at different tension levels to ensure that the cable remains balanced over the entire operating range.

In my experience, the torsion balance of an umbilical cable is a critical parameter that is often overlooked by designers. A cable that is not torsion-balanced will twist under load, which can cause the connectors at the ends to fail or the cable to become entangled. I recall a project where an umbilical cable was installed in a deepwater field, and the cable twisted during installation, causing the connectors to be damaged. The investigation revealed that the cable was not torsion-balanced, and the helical angles of the armor wires were not optimized. The cable had to be replaced, resulting in a significant cost overrun and schedule delay.

Study Insights and Practical Lessons

The paper's approach of using a finite element model to optimize the helical angle is a significant advancement over the traditional analytical methods. The finite element model allows for a more accurate representation of the complex geometry and the interaction between the elements. However, the model requires accurate input data, including the material properties, the friction coefficients, and the geometry of the elements. The friction coefficient is particularly difficult to determine, as it depends on the surface finish of the elements and the presence of lubricants.

One of the key insights from this study is that the cable core cannot be treated as a solid cylinder. This is a common assumption in the design of cables, but it is not valid for umbilical cables with steel tubes, as the tubes have a high bending stiffness that affects the torsional behavior. The finite element model captures this effect, and the results show that the core contributes significantly to the torsional imbalance.

Another insight is the importance of the friction between the elements. The friction affects the torsional moment, but it also affects the distribution of tension among the elements. In a torsion-balanced cable, the tension is distributed evenly among the armor wires, but if the friction is high, the tension may be concentrated in the outer layers, leading to a higher torsional moment. The finite element model accounts for this, and the optimal helical angle is determined considering the friction.

Recommendations for Engineering Practice

Based on my experience and the findings of this paper, I would offer the following recommendations for the design and manufacture of steel pipe umbilical cables:

  1. The design should include a detailed finite element analysis of the cable, taking into account the geometry of all the elements and the friction between them. The cable core should be modeled as a multi-layer structure, not as a solid cylinder.
  2. The helical angles of all the layers should be optimized to achieve torsion balance, with the second layer of armor wires being the primary control variable. The optimal angle should be determined by minimizing the torsional moment under the maximum working tension.
  3. The manufacturing process should be controlled to ensure that the helical angles are within a tolerance of ±1%, and the tension of each element should be controlled to ensure uniform winding. The steel tubes should be pressure-tested before winding to ensure that there are no leaks.
  4. A full-scale prototype should be tested to verify the torsion balance, with the twist measured at different tension levels. The twist should be less than 1 degree per meter of length under the maximum working tension.
  5. The friction between the elements should be minimized by using a suitable lubricant, but the friction coefficient should be accurately determined for the design analysis. A friction coefficient of 0.2-0.3 is typical for steel-on-steel contact with a lubricant.

The paper by Niu Xuechao et al. provides a valuable contribution to the design of torsion-balanced steel pipe umbilical cables. The finite element method is an effective tool for optimizing the helical angles, and the experimental validation confirms the accuracy of the method. As the offshore oil and gas industry moves into deeper waters, the demand for reliable umbilical cables will increase, and the principles outlined in this paper will become increasingly important for ensuring the safe and efficient operation of subsea production systems.