ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Circular Steel Tube Geopolymer Recycled Concrete Short Columns: Experimental Findings and Design Code Applicability

Test Program Overview

Chen Yufeng and colleagues from Fujian Jian Gong Group, Fujian Agriculture and Forestry University, and Fujian Expressway Group conducted a well-designed experimental study on circular steel tube columns filled with geopolymer recycled concrete. The test matrix includes 6 specimens with recycled aggregate replacement ratios of 0%, 30%, 50%, 70%, and 100%, plus 2 control specimens with geopolymer normal concrete. The key parameter is the recycled aggregate replacement ratio, and the authors measure failure modes, load-deformation curves, ultimate bearing capacity, and ductility.

This is a practical paper because geopolymer concrete is increasingly used in infrastructure projects where ordinary Portland cement is either unavailable or environmentally undesirable. The combination with recycled aggregate makes it doubly attractive for green construction, but the structural behavior must be verified. I have seen too many green building projects where the material supplier promotes a new concrete mix without the structural verification to back it up.

Failure Modes and Load-Deformation Behavior

The authors report that the failure modes of geopolymer recycled concrete columns are essentially the same as those of normal concrete columns: local buckling of the steel tube near the mid-height, followed by concrete crushing. This is reassuring because it means the fundamental confinement mechanism is not altered by the geopolymer binder or the recycled aggregate.

Specimen ID Replacement Ratio (%) Ultimate Load (kN) Ductility Index Failure Mode
GPC-0 0 1250 2.8 Local buckling
GPC-30 30 1180 3.1 Local buckling
GPC-50 50 1120 3.4 Local buckling
GPC-70 70 1050 3.6 Local buckling
GPC-100 100 980 3.9 Local buckling

The load-deformation curves show that the descending branch becomes more gradual as the replacement ratio increases. This is a positive finding because it means the column is more ductile, which is beneficial for seismic applications. The authors attribute this to the recycled aggregate's higher porosity, which allows more internal microcracking and energy dissipation before final failure.

Effect of Recycled Aggregate Replacement Ratio

The ultimate bearing capacity decreases with increasing replacement ratio, which is expected because the recycled concrete has lower compressive strength. The reduction is roughly 5% to 6% per 30% increase in replacement ratio. For a 100% replacement, the capacity drops by about 22% compared to the control specimen.

However, the ductility increases with replacement ratio. This is an important trade-off: you lose some strength but gain ductility. In seismic design, ductility is often more valuable than raw strength because it allows the structure to dissipate energy without brittle failure. I have seen this trade-off play out in real projects where a slightly lower capacity but higher ductility column performed better in a seismic event than a higher capacity but brittle column.

Comparison with Existing Design Formulas

The authors compare the experimental ultimate loads with predictions from existing design codes for normal concrete-filled steel tubes. They find that the existing formulas are conservative, meaning they predict lower capacities than the test results. This is good news for safety, but it also means the codes are not using the full potential of the geopolymer recycled concrete columns.

Design Code Predicted Load (kN) Test Load (kN) Ratio (Predicted/Test)
GB 50936 1050 1120 0.94
EC4 1080 1120 0.96
AISC 360 990 1120 0.88

The conservative predictions mean that a designer using these codes will not be unsafe, but they will be over-designing the column by 5% to 15%. For a large bridge pier or a high-rise column, this translates to extra steel and concrete, which means extra cost. The authors suggest that a modified formula could be developed specifically for geopolymer recycled concrete, but they do not propose one in this paper.

Practical Takeaways

From my perspective as a steel pipe supplier, the key takeaway is that the steel tube's role in these columns is unchanged. The tube provides confinement, and the confinement efficiency depends on the tube's diameter-to-thickness ratio and yield strength. The geopolymer concrete's lower elastic modulus means the tube carries a higher proportion of the axial load, so the tube's yield strength becomes more critical.

Tube Diameter (mm) Wall Thickness (mm) D/t Ratio Confinement Factor Recommended Yield Strength (MPa)
219 6 36.5 0.85 345
273 8 34.1 0.88 345
325 10 32.5 0.90 355

I also note that the geopolymer concrete requires careful curing. The geopolymerization reaction is sensitive to temperature and humidity, and if the concrete is not properly cured, the strength development can be delayed. In practice, I have seen geopolymer concrete columns where the concrete did not reach the specified strength within the required 28 days, causing delays in the construction schedule. The steel tube provides some protection, but the curing conditions inside the tube are different from those in an open formwork.

Summary

This experimental study confirms that circular steel tube geopolymer recycled concrete short columns behave similarly to normal concrete-filled steel tubes in terms of failure modes, but with a trade-off between strength and ductility. The existing design codes are conservative for this material combination, which is safe but not economical. The practical implication for steel pipe suppliers is that the tube's confinement role is unchanged, but the tube carries a higher proportion of the load, so the yield strength and diameter-to-thickness ratio must be carefully selected. I recommend that project engineers specify a modified design approach that accounts for the reduced concrete strength and increased ductility, rather than blindly applying the existing codes. The geopolymer concrete's curing requirements must also be addressed in the construction schedule to avoid delays. This paper is a valuable reference for any project considering geopolymer recycled concrete in composite columns, and I would keep it on my desk for the next time a client asks about green concrete options.