ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Axial Compression Performance and Bearing Capacity Calculation of Square Steel Tube UHPC Short Columns

Overview of the Research

This paper by Wang Qiuwei, Wang Fuxing and Liang Lin from Xi'an University of Architecture and Technology investigates the axial compression performance of square steel tube ultra-high performance concrete (UHPC) short columns. The research is funded by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Project No. 51878543) and is published in the Journal of Xi'an University of Architecture and Technology (Natural Science Edition) (2022, Vol. 54, No. 2). The classification number TU398 places it in the field of composite structures.

The authors used ABAQUS to build a finite element model of the square steel tube UHPC short column, and they validated the model against the failure modes and load-displacement curves of axial compression test specimens. They then analysed the effects of steel tube width-to-thickness ratio, steel tube strength, and UHPC strength on the load-displacement curve. Finally, they established a formula for calculating the axial compressive bearing capacity based on the limit equilibrium theory, and they verified the formula against experimental results.

UHPC is a relatively new material in structural engineering, and its combination with steel tubes is an innovative development. As someone who has supplied steel pipe for numerous composite structures, I find this research particularly interesting because it addresses a material system that is likely to become more common in the coming years.

Key Technical Findings and Interpretation

Failure Modes

The authors identify two distinct failure modes for the square steel tube UHPC short columns:

Failure Mode Description Characteristics
Barrel-shaped (腰鼓型) Local buckling of the steel tube at mid-height, with bulging outward Steel tube yields and buckles locally, concrete core is crushed
Shear-type (剪切型) Diagonal shear failure through the section A shear plane develops at approximately 45 degrees, with the steel tube sheared and the concrete crushed along the diagonal

Both failure modes are classified as strength failures, meaning that the column reaches its maximum load-carrying capacity due to material failure rather than instability. This is consistent with the short column behaviour expected for a member with a low slenderness ratio.

From a practical standpoint, the occurrence of a shear-type failure is concerning because it is more brittle than a barrel-shaped failure. A shear failure provides less warning before collapse, and it can be catastrophic if it occurs in a structure where brittle failure is not anticipated. The authors do not explicitly state which failure mode is more common or under what conditions each mode occurs, but this is an important question that deserves further investigation.

Parametric Effects

The parametric study reveals three key relationships:

  1. The bearing capacity decreases nonlinearly as the width-to-thickness ratio increases. This is expected because a higher width-to-thickness ratio means a thinner steel tube relative to its width, which reduces the confinement effect on the concrete core and increases the risk of local buckling. The nonlinearity of this relationship is important: it means that the capacity does not decrease linearly with increasing width-to-thickness ratio, and there may be a threshold beyond which the capacity drops sharply.
  2. The bearing capacity increases linearly with increasing UHPC strength. This is intuitive, but the linear relationship is worth noting. It means that for every unit increase in UHPC strength, there is a proportional increase in bearing capacity. This is in contrast to the bending behaviour discussed in Topic 1, where the flexural capacity was insensitive to concrete strength. The difference is that in axial compression, the concrete core is the primary load-bearing element, while in bending, the steel tube dominates.
  3. The bearing capacity increases linearly with increasing steel tube strength. This is also expected, but the linear relationship is significant. It means that the steel tube contributes directly to the axial capacity, not just through confinement. The steel tube carries a portion of the axial load, and it also provides lateral confinement to the concrete core, which enhances the concrete's strength.

Ductility Behaviour

The authors make a particularly interesting observation about ductility: the ductility of the column increases with increasing steel strength but decreases with increasing UHPC strength. This is a classic trade-off between strength and ductility. High-strength steel provides a higher yield point and more post-yield deformation capacity, which enhances ductility. High-strength UHPC, on the other hand, is more brittle, and it reduces the overall ductility of the composite member.

This finding has important implications for design. If a structure requires high ductility (e.g., in a seismic zone), then the designer should not specify too high a UHPC strength, because it will reduce the ductility of the column. Conversely, if the structure is in a non-seismic zone and ductility is not a primary concern, then higher UHPC strength can be used to increase the bearing capacity.

Bearing Capacity Calculation

The authors establish a formula for the axial compressive bearing capacity based on the limit equilibrium theory. They analyse the stress distribution in the UHPC confinement zone and derive a formula that accounts for the confinement effect of the steel tube on the concrete core. The calculated values agree well with the experimental results.

This is a significant contribution because it provides a design method that is specifically tailored to square steel tube UHPC columns. Existing design codes for CFST members were developed for normal-strength concrete, and they may not be directly applicable to UHPC, which has different stress-strain behaviour and a different confinement mechanism.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

Manufacturing Considerations for Square Steel Tube UHPC Columns

From a manufacturing perspective, the square steel tube used in this application is typically a cold-formed or welded square hollow section. The width-to-thickness ratio is a critical parameter, and it must be controlled within tight tolerances. If the wall thickness is too thin relative to the width, local buckling will occur prematurely, and the column will not achieve its design capacity.

The manufacturing of square steel tube requires careful control of the welding process. For welded square sections, the weld seam is typically located at the corner, and it must be of high quality to ensure that the tube behaves as a monolithic section. In my experience, the most common defect in welded square tube is lack of fusion at the weld root, which can lead to premature failure under compression.

The UHPC also presents challenges. UHPC has a very low water-to-binder ratio, typically below 0.2, and it requires the use of superplasticizers and steel fibres to achieve the desired workability and ductility. The placement of UHPC in a steel tube requires careful attention to the mix design and the placement procedure. If the UHPC is too stiff, it will not flow properly around the steel fibres, and there may be voids or segregation. If it is too fluid, it may bleed and lose its strength.

Construction and Site Practice

On site, the placement of UHPC in a square steel tube is more challenging than for normal concrete. The low water-to-binder ratio means that the UHPC has a very short workability time, and it must be placed quickly after mixing. The use of steel fibres also makes the UHPC more difficult to pump, and the fibres can clog the pump lines if the mix design is not properly optimised.

I recall a project where UHPC was used in a steel tube column, and the contractor experienced significant difficulties with the placement. The UHPC was too stiff, and it did not flow properly around the steel fibres. The contractor had to add more superplasticizer, which improved the workability but reduced the strength. The final column met the design requirements, but the strength was lower than intended, and the contractor had to compensate by increasing the wall thickness of the steel tube.

This experience highlights the importance of proper mix design and placement procedures for UHPC. The contractor must work closely with the UHPC supplier to ensure that the mix is optimised for the specific application, and the placement procedure must be carefully planned and executed.

Lessons from Real Projects

Another lesson relates to the weld quality of the square steel tube. In one case, a contractor used a welded square tube that had a lack of fusion at the weld root. The column was subjected to axial compression, and the weld failed prematurely, causing a sudden loss of capacity. The failure was catastrophic, and it resulted in significant damage to the structure.

This incident highlighted the importance of non-destructive testing for welded square tubes. The weld seam must be inspected using ultrasonic testing or radiography to ensure that there is no lack of fusion, porosity, or other defects. The inspection should be carried out on a sample basis, but if any defects are found, the inspection frequency should be increased.

Reflections and Study Insights

This paper makes a valuable contribution to the understanding of square steel tube UHPC short columns, but there are several issues that deserve further attention.

First, the authors do not provide a clear criterion for distinguishing between the barrel-shaped and shear-type failure modes. This is important because the two modes have different implications for design. A shear-type failure is more brittle and provides less warning, so it should be avoided in design. Future research should develop a criterion based on the width-to-thickness ratio, the steel strength, and the UHPC strength.

Second, the authors' formula for the bearing capacity is based on the limit equilibrium theory, but it does not account for the effect of the steel fibres in the UHPC. The steel fibres contribute to the tensile strength and ductility of the UHPC, and they may also affect the confinement mechanism. Future research should incorporate the effect of steel fibres into the bearing capacity formula.

Third, the authors do not address the long-term behaviour of the column. UHPC has a higher shrinkage and creep than normal concrete, and the long-term behaviour of a steel tube UHPC column may differ from the short-term behaviour. This is particularly important for columns in high-rise buildings, where the sustained load can be significant.

Conclusion

The axial compression performance of square steel tube UHPC short columns is a topic of growing importance as UHPC becomes more widely used in structural engineering. This paper provides valuable experimental and analytical evidence that the column exhibits two distinct failure modes, that the bearing capacity is influenced by the width-to-thickness ratio, the steel strength, and the UHPC strength, and that the ductility is a trade-off between steel strength and UHPC strength. The authors' formula for the bearing capacity is a useful design tool, but it should be validated against a broader range of experimental data before it is adopted in design codes. For practising engineers, the key takeaways are: control the width-to-thickness ratio carefully, ensure proper weld quality in the square steel tube, and be aware that high UHPC strength reduces ductility. These lessons are essential for the safe and efficient design of square steel tube UHPC columns.