Replacement of Brass Condenser Tubes with Stainless Steel Tubes at Tongling Power Plant
Literature Overview and Core Findings
The paper by Liang, Zhou, and colleagues from Shanghai Electric Power College and Tongling Power Plant documents the successful replacement of HSn70-1 brass tubes with 304 stainless steel tubes in the condenser of Unit 1 at Tongling Power Plant. The study involved extensive investigation, testing, and research before the replacement was approved and implemented.
The key findings are:
- Stainless steel tubes have superior corrosion resistance compared to brass tubes, particularly in cooling water with high chloride content or suspended solids.
- Stainless steel tubes have better mechanical properties, including higher yield strength and better impact resistance.
- The total heat transfer performance of stainless steel tubes is not inferior to brass tubes, despite the lower thermal conductivity of stainless steel.
- The economic performance of stainless steel tubes is favorable, considering the longer service life and reduced maintenance costs.
The paper concludes that the replacement was successful and achieved good results, including reduced tube leakage, improved condenser performance, and lower maintenance costs.
Technical Analysis and Material Selection
Why Replace Brass Tubes?
Brass tubes (HSn70-1) have been used in condensers for decades, but they are susceptible to several failure modes:
- Corrosion: Brass tubes are prone to dezincification, pitting corrosion, and stress corrosion cracking, particularly in cooling water with high chloride content or ammonia.
- Erosion-corrosion: The high water velocity in the condenser tubes can cause erosion-corrosion, especially at the tube inlet where the flow is turbulent.
- Tube leakage: Corrosion and erosion lead to tube wall thinning and eventual leakage, which contaminates the condensate and reduces the boiler feedwater quality.
Stainless steel tubes (304) offer several advantages:
- Superior corrosion resistance: The chromium and nickel content provides a passive oxide film that resists corrosion in a wide range of cooling water conditions.
- Higher mechanical strength: The yield strength of 304 stainless steel is approximately 205 MPa, compared to 100 to 150 MPa for HSn70-1 brass.
- Better erosion resistance: The higher hardness and strength of stainless steel provide better resistance to erosion-corrosion.
Heat Transfer Performance Comparison
The paper addresses the concern that stainless steel has a lower thermal conductivity (16 W/m·K) than brass (100 W/m·K), which could reduce the heat transfer performance. However, the total heat transfer coefficient depends on several factors:
| Parameter | Brass Tube | Stainless Steel Tube |
|---|---|---|
| Thermal conductivity (W/m·K) | 100 | 16 |
| Wall thickness (mm) | 1.0 | 0.7 |
| Fouling resistance (m²·K/W) | 0.0001 | 0.00005 |
| Overall heat transfer coefficient (W/m²·K) | 2500 | 2200 |
The stainless steel tube's lower thermal conductivity is partially offset by the thinner wall and the lower fouling resistance. The overall heat transfer coefficient is approximately 10 to 15 percent lower for stainless steel, but this can be compensated by increasing the tube surface area or the water flow rate.
Mechanical Properties and Fabrication
| Property | HSn70-1 Brass | 304 Stainless Steel |
|---|---|---|
| Yield strength (MPa) | 100 to 150 | 205 |
| Tensile strength (MPa) | 300 to 350 | 515 |
| Elongation (percent) | 30 to 40 | 40 |
| Hardness (HV) | 80 to 100 | 150 to 180 |
| Density (g/cm³) | 8.5 | 7.9 |
The stainless steel tubes have higher strength, which allows a thinner wall and a larger internal diameter for the same outer diameter. This increases the water flow area and partially compensates for the lower thermal conductivity.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
Case Study: The Tongling Power Plant Replacement
The replacement of the condenser tubes at Tongling Power Plant involved several critical steps:
- Investigation and testing: The existing brass tubes were inspected to identify the failure modes and the cause of the tube leakage. Water quality analysis was performed to determine the corrosion potential of the cooling water.
- Material selection: The 304 stainless steel was selected based on the water quality and the expected service conditions. The tube dimensions were determined to match the existing tube sheet holes.
- Tube removal: The old brass tubes were removed by cutting and pulling. The tube sheet holes were cleaned and inspected for damage.
- Tube installation: The new stainless steel tubes were installed using roller expansion to seal the tube-to-tube sheet joints. The expansion was carefully controlled to avoid over-expansion, which can cause tube cracking.
- Testing and commissioning: The new tubes were hydrostatically tested to verify the tube-to-tube sheet joints. The condenser was then commissioned and the performance was monitored.
Quality Control and Inspection
The quality control for the stainless steel tube installation is more demanding than for brass tubes:
- Tube surface condition: The stainless steel tubes must be free of scratches, dents, and surface contamination. Any contamination can lead to localized corrosion.
- Tube expansion: The roller expansion must be performed with the correct expansion ratio (typically 8 to 12 percent). Over-expansion can cause tube cracking, while under-expansion can cause leakage.
- Tube sheet preparation: The tube sheet holes must be clean and free of burrs. The hole diameter tolerance is typically +0.1 to +0.2 mm relative to the tube outer diameter.
- Hydrostatic testing: The condenser must be hydrostatically tested at 1.5 times the design pressure for at least 30 minutes. Any leakage must be identified and repaired.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper raises several questions that are relevant to condenser design and operation:
- What is the optimal material for condenser tubes? The answer depends on the cooling water quality, the operating conditions, and the economic considerations. Stainless steel is preferred for aggressive cooling water, while brass or titanium may be preferred for other conditions.
2.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd