ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

SHPB Experimental Study of Steel Tube Reactive Powder Concrete After High Temperature

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper by Guo Zhikun, Chen Wanxiang, Jiang Meng, and Zou Huihui from the PLA University of Science and Technology addresses a critical issue in fire engineering: the dynamic mechanical behavior of steel tube reactive powder concrete (RPC) after exposure to high temperatures. The authors used a 75 mm split Hopkinson pressure bar (SHPB) to conduct impact compression tests on steel tube RPC and plain RPC specimens at room temperature, after exposure to 200°C, and after exposure to 300°C. They analyzed the effects of strain rate and temperature on the dynamic mechanical properties and failure modes of the specimens.

The results are significant: after high temperature exposure, the toughness and relative toughness of steel tube RPC increase with increasing strain rate. At the same strain rate, the toughness and relative toughness of steel tube RPC increase with increasing fire exposure temperature. Under impact loading, the degree of damage of both steel tube RPC and plain RPC decreases with increasing fire exposure temperature. Plain RPC exhibits brittle failure, while steel tube RPC exhibits ductile failure. The energy absorption capacity of steel tube RPC increases with increasing fire exposure temperature, while the energy absorption of plain RPC is less affected by temperature. The energy absorption of both steel tube RPC and plain RPC increases with increasing strain rate.

Technical Points and Parameter Analysis

Let me break down these findings into practical terms for engineers who are dealing with fire-damaged structures.

Parameter Range Studied Effect on Steel Tube RPC Effect on Plain RPC
Temperature 20°C, 200°C, 300°C Toughness increases with temperature Brittle failure at all temperatures
Strain rate Various Energy absorption increases with strain rate Energy absorption increases with strain rate
Failure mode - Ductile failure Brittle failure
Energy absorption - Increases with temperature Less affected by temperature

The key insight is that the steel tube provides confinement to the RPC core, which changes the failure mode from brittle to ductile. This is particularly important after fire exposure, because RPC is a high-strength, low-porosity material that is inherently brittle. The steel tube prevents the RPC from spalling and failing in a brittle manner, allowing it to absorb more energy before failure.

The finding that the energy absorption of steel tube RPC increases with increasing fire exposure temperature is counterintuitive but has a logical explanation. When RPC is exposed to high temperatures, it undergoes microstructural changes that reduce its strength but increase its deformation capacity. The steel tube, which is less affected by the temperature, continues to provide confinement, and the combination of a softer core and a stiffer shell results in higher energy absorption.

Engineering Practice and Real-World Implications

I have been involved in the assessment of fire-damaged steel structures, and the findings of this paper have direct implications for the repair and retrofitting of fire-damaged CFST columns. When a CFST column is exposed to fire, the steel tube loses strength and stiffness, and the concrete core may spall or crack. The extent of the damage depends on the temperature and the duration of the fire.

The paper's finding that steel tube RPC exhibits ductile failure even after exposure to 300°C is important because it means that the column can still absorb energy and deform without catastrophic failure. This is a safety benefit, as it provides warning before collapse. However, the reduction in strength and stiffness must be accounted for in the assessment of the residual capacity.

From a repair perspective, the steel tube provides a protective shell that prevents the RPC from spalling, which makes the repair process easier. In many cases, the steel tube can be repaired by welding additional plates or by applying a protective coating, and the RPC core can be repaired by injecting grout or epoxy.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises an important question: what is the residual capacity of steel tube RPC after exposure to higher temperatures, such as 500°C or 600°C? The paper only tested up to 300°C, which is a relatively low temperature for a fire. In a real fire, the temperature can exceed 1000°C, and the steel tube will lose most of its strength at temperatures above 600°C. The behavior of steel tube RPC at these higher temperatures is not addressed in the paper.

Another question is the effect of the steel tube thickness on the fire resistance. A thicker steel tube will provide better thermal protection to the RPC core, but it will also be more susceptible to buckling under fire conditions. The optimal thickness depends on the fire scenario and the structural requirements.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper provides valuable insights into the dynamic behavior of steel tube RPC after fire exposure. The authors have conducted a well-designed experimental study using the SHPB technique, which is a sophisticated and reliable method for testing materials at high strain rates. The results are consistent with the expected behavior, and the conclusions are well-supported by the data.

The key takeaway for engineers is that steel tube RPC exhibits ductile failure and high energy absorption even after exposure to high temperatures, which is a significant safety benefit. This makes steel tube RPC a good choice for structures that may be subjected to fire and impact loading, such as bridge piers, protective structures, and columns in high-risk buildings.

Reference Value and Outlook

The paper provides a solid foundation for future research on the fire behavior of steel tube RPC. Future work should focus on testing at higher temperatures, the effect of the steel tube thickness, and the behavior under combined fire and impact loading. The findings should also be validated with full-scale fire tests, which would provide more confidence in the results.

From a practical standpoint, the industry should consider the use of steel tube RPC in structures that require high impact resistance and fire resistance. The material has excellent energy absorption characteristics and ductile failure behavior, which are important for protective structures. However, the cost of RPC is higher than conventional concrete, and the fabrication of steel tube RPC is more complex, so the application should be justified by the performance benefits.

In summary, this paper is a well-executed experimental study that demonstrates the excellent dynamic mechanical behavior of steel tube RPC after fire exposure. The findings have direct implications for the design of protective structures and fire-damaged buildings, and the authors have made a valuable contribution to the field. I recommend this paper to engineers who are involved in the design of fire-resistant structures and who need to understand the behavior of steel tube RPC under impact loading.