Large Aspect Ratio Rectangular CFST Columns Under Compression-Bending: Code Applicability and Design Insights
Overview of the Research
Chen Anying and colleagues at Hefei University of Technology present a combined experimental and numerical study of rectangular concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) columns with large aspect ratios under eccentric compression. The experimental programme includes large aspect ratio short columns tested under eccentric loading, supplemented by four additional finite element models to cover a wider range of parameters including eccentricity, aspect ratio, wall thickness, and cross-section size. The study then evaluates the applicability of four commonly used design codes for calculating the bearing capacity of such columns, including the Chinese code JGJ 138-2016.
Interpretation of Key Technical Points
The test results show that the failure mode of all specimens is outward bulging of the long side of the rectangular section. When the applied load is below 80 percent of the ultimate capacity, the strain distribution across the section height follows the plane section assumption, which validates the use of conventional section analysis for the elastic range. The parametric study reveals a complex relationship between the variables and the ductility of the column. As the eccentricity increases, the ductility initially improves but then declines after the eccentricity exceeds 0.205. Similarly, as the wall thickness increases, the ductility improves up to a wall thickness of 8 mm, after which it declines. Increasing the aspect ratio reduces ductility, and increasing the cross-section size reduces ductility when the wall thickness is held constant but has little effect when the wall thickness is increased proportionally.
Engineering Practice Implications
The finding that the plane section assumption holds up to 80 percent of the ultimate load is a significant practical result. It means that the design of large aspect ratio rectangular CFST columns can proceed using the same strain compatibility approach that is used for conventional reinforced concrete sections, provided the serviceability limit state is kept below 80 percent of the ultimate capacity. This is a useful simplification for the design office. The ductility behaviour is more nuanced and requires careful interpretation. The decline in ductility beyond a wall thickness of 8 mm is counterintuitive at first glance, but it can be explained by the fact that a thicker wall increases the flexural stiffness of the section, which makes it more susceptible to a sudden loss of capacity once local buckling initiates.
Key Questions and Reflections
The comparison of the four design codes shows that JGJ 138-2016 provides the most accurate calculation for the eccentric compression capacity of large aspect ratio rectangular CFST columns. This is an important finding because it validates the Chinese code for a geometry that is becoming increasingly common in modern high-rise buildings. The other codes, which include international standards, tend to be either too conservative or too unconservative for this specific geometry. The practical implication is that engineers designing large aspect ratio rectangular CFST columns should not blindly apply a code that was developed for square or moderately rectangular sections. The aspect ratio has a first-order effect on the failure mechanism, and the code must reflect that.
Study Insights and Outlook
The paper makes a valuable contribution by filling a gap in the literature on large aspect ratio rectangular CFST columns. For the steel pipe industry, the findings reinforce the importance of controlling wall thickness uniformity and cross-section dimensions. A rectangular CFST column made from formed and welded steel plate requires precise control of the corner radius, the flatness of the faces, and the weld quality at the corners. Any deviation from the specified geometry will affect the confinement of the concrete core and the local buckling behaviour of the steel tube. The study also highlights the need for the pipe manufacturer to provide accurate stress-strain data for the steel, including the strain hardening behaviour, because the post-yield response of the steel determines the ductility of the composite column. The paper is a solid reference for structural engineers and a useful guide for the steel fabrication industry in understanding the performance requirements of large aspect ratio rectangular CFST columns.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd