Ultimate Bearing Capacity of Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Dumbbell-Shaped Eccentrically Loaded Long Columns
Literature Overview
This study by Chen Baochun and Sheng Ye from Fuzhou University and Fujian Agriculture and Forestry University presents the results of 16 tests on concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) dumbbell-shaped eccentrically loaded long columns. The parameters studied were slenderness ratio and eccentricity ratio. The authors analysed the load-deformation curves, failure modes and ultimate bearing capacity of the specimens, and they developed a finite element model to perform full-range analysis and parametric studies. The results show that the dumbbell-shaped eccentrically loaded long columns fail in a global buckling mode, and that the ultimate bearing capacity and tangential stiffness in the elastic-plastic stage decrease with increasing slenderness ratio and eccentricity ratio.
Key Technical Points
Experimental Program
The 16 specimens were designed with varying slenderness ratios and eccentricity ratios to cover the practical range of applications. The dumbbell shape consists of two circular steel tubes connected by a web plate, and the concrete is filled in both tubes and the web. This cross-section is commonly used in arch bridges and other structures where a large bending capacity is required.
| Parameter | Range Tested | Effect on Ultimate Bearing Capacity |
|---|---|---|
| Slenderness ratio | Varied across specimens | Decreases with increasing slenderness |
| Eccentricity ratio | Varied across specimens | Decreases with increasing eccentricity |
| Failure mode | Global buckling | N/A |
Failure Modes
The specimens failed in a global buckling mode, which is the expected failure mode for long columns under eccentric loading. The local buckling of the steel tube was not observed, which indicates that the concrete filling provided sufficient support to the steel tube to prevent local buckling. This is an important finding because it confirms that the dumbbell-shaped CFST section behaves as a composite member with good ductility and energy dissipation capacity.
Parametric Analysis and Design Formulas
The finite element analysis showed that the effects of slenderness ratio and eccentricity ratio on the ultimate bearing capacity are essentially independent, which means that the combined effect can be accounted for by multiplying the individual reduction factors. The stability coefficient can be calculated using the same formula as for dumbbell-shaped axially loaded long columns, and the eccentricity reduction factor can be calculated using a formula derived from regression analysis of the test data and finite element results.
Engineering Practice Insights
Fabrication of Dumbbell-Shaped CFST Sections
From a fabrication perspective, dumbbell-shaped CFST sections are challenging. The two circular tubes need to be connected by a web plate, which requires welding the web to both tubes. The weld quality is critical because the web-to-tube connections are subjected to high shear stresses. I would recommend using full penetration welds for these connections and verifying the weld quality with ultrasonic testing.
Concrete Filling of Dumbbell Sections
The concrete filling of the dumbbell section is more complex than a single circular tube because the concrete needs to flow through the web plate into both tubes. The web plate typically has openings to allow the concrete to flow, and these openings need to be designed to ensure complete filling without voids. I have seen problems with voids in the web plate of dumbbell sections, particularly when the web is thin and the concrete has to flow a long distance.
Quality Control and Inspection
The quality control for dumbbell-shaped CFST sections should include visual inspection of the welds, ultrasonic testing of the web-to-tube connections, and verification of the concrete filling quality. The concrete filling quality is particularly important because voids in the concrete can significantly reduce the load-bearing capacity of the section. I would recommend using self-compacting concrete and ultrasonic testing or core sampling to verify the filling quality.
Reflections and Lessons Learned
The Veteran's View
This paper is a valuable contribution to the design of dumbbell-shaped CFST columns, which are commonly used in arch bridges but are not as well studied as circular or rectangular CFST sections. The experimental data and the design formulas provide a solid basis for design, and the finite element analysis confirms the validity of the simplified approach.
What I Would Do Differently
If I were conducting this research, I would have included more specimens with different web plate thicknesses to study the effect of the web plate on the structural performance. I would also have measured the residual stresses in the steel tubes after fabrication, because residual stresses can affect the buckling behaviour of the section.
The Bottom Line
The ultimate bearing capacity of dumbbell-shaped CFST eccentrically loaded long columns decreases with increasing slenderness ratio and eccentricity ratio, and the effects of these two parameters are essentially independent. The design formulas proposed in this paper are practical and can be used for design. For fabricators, the key is to ensure that the web-to-tube connections are welded with full penetration welds and that the concrete filling is complete and void-free. This is a well-designed study that provides useful guidance for the design and fabrication of dumbbell-shaped CFST sections.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd