ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Tied Arch Bridges: Trial Design of Inclined Hangers

Literature Overview and Core Findings

Peng Guihan, Dong Jucan, and Chen Baochun from Fuzhou University published this study in the Journal of Fuzhou University (Natural Science Edition) in 2009. The work uses the Zhengzhou Yellow River Second Bridge, a concrete-filled steel tube tied arch bridge, as the background project for a trial design of inclined hangers. The finite element analysis method is used to study the changes in internal forces and deflections of the arch bridge structure under different hanger arrangement forms.

The analysis results show that the inclination angle of the hangers has a significant influence on the internal forces of the bridge. The selection of the hanger inclination angle is an important issue in design. Using inclined hangers instead of vertical hangers can reduce the bending moment in the arch rib and the tie beam, and reduce the deck deflection. Among the three inclined hanger arrangements studied, the radial hanger arrangement has the best performance.

Technical Points That Matter on the Shop Floor

The Arch Rib and Its Steel Tube

This is where my experience with steel pipe comes directly into play. The arch rib of a concrete-filled steel tube arch bridge is typically made from large-diameter steel tubes, often 500 to 1200 mm in diameter, filled with high-strength concrete. The tubes are bent to the arch shape, which is not a simple process.

Parameter Typical Range Manufacturing Challenge
Tube diameter 500-1200 mm Requires large-diameter pipe mill
Wall thickness 12-30 mm Bending causes thinning at extrados
Steel grade Q345-Q460 Higher strength reduces wall thickness
Bending radius 20-100 m Requires induction bending or cold bending
Concrete strength C40-C80 High-strength concrete is difficult to place

The bending of the steel tube to form the arch rib is a critical manufacturing step. In our shop, we use induction bending for large-diameter tubes. The tube is heated locally and bent to the required radius. This process creates a heat-affected zone where the mechanical properties are altered. The wall thickness at the extrados (outer side of the bend) is reduced, while the intrados (inner side) is thickened. This must be accounted for in the design.

The Hanger Connections

The hangers in a tied arch bridge connect the arch rib to the tie beam or the deck. In a concrete-filled steel tube arch bridge, the hangers are typically steel cables or rods that pass through the steel tube or are anchored to the tube surface. The connection detail is critical.

When the hanger is inclined, the connection to the arch rib is subjected to both axial and shear forces. The connection detail must be designed to accommodate these forces without causing local buckling of the steel tube or crushing of the concrete core. In our experience, the connection is often the weakest point in the structure.

The Tie Beam and Deck

The tie beam in a tied arch bridge is a critical element that resists the horizontal thrust from the arch. In a concrete-filled steel tube arch bridge, the tie beam is typically a steel box girder or a concrete-filled steel tube. The inclined hangers reduce the bending moment in the tie beam, which is beneficial, but they also introduce horizontal forces that must be resisted.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

The Zhengzhou Yellow River Second Bridge

The background project, the Zhengzhou Yellow River Second Bridge, is a major bridge over the Yellow River. It is a concrete-filled steel tube tied arch bridge with a span of over 300 meters. The bridge was completed in the early 2000s and has performed well.

In the trial design, the authors studied three inclined hanger arrangements:

  1. Radial hangers, where the hangers are arranged radially from the arch rib to the tie beam.
  2. Parallel inclined hangers, where the hangers are all inclined at the same angle.
  3. Fan-shaped hangers, where the hanger inclination angle varies along the span.

The radial hanger arrangement performed best, with the smallest bending moments in the arch rib and tie beam, and the smallest deck deflection. This is an important finding for design.

Practical Considerations for Hanger Installation

In practice, installing inclined hangers is more difficult than installing vertical hangers. The hanger anchorages must be precisely positioned to achieve the correct inclination angle. This requires:

  1. Accurate survey and setting out of the hanger positions.
  2. Adjustable anchorages to allow for tolerances.
  3. Careful tensioning to ensure the hanger forces are as designed.

In one project I was involved in, the contractor had difficulty achieving the specified hanger inclination angles because of accumulated tolerances in the arch rib and tie beam construction. The hangers had to be adjusted by using shims at the anchorages, which introduced additional stresses that were not accounted for in the design.

The Effect of Hanger Inclination on Bridge Performance

The paper shows that the hanger inclination angle has a significant influence on the bridge internal forces. A small change in the inclination angle can change the bending moment in the arch rib by 10 to 20 percent. This means that the design must be robust to variations in the inclination angle that may occur during construction.

From a practical standpoint, this means:

Key Questions and Reflections

One question that this paper raises is: what is the optimal hanger inclination angle? The paper compares three arrangements but does not provide a detailed parametric study. The optimal angle depends on the span, the arch rise, the stiffness of the arch rib and tie beam, and the loading. A more detailed parametric study would be valuable.

Another reflection: the paper uses linear elastic finite element analysis. In reality, the bridge behavior is nonlinear, especially under ultimate loads. The concrete in the arch rib may crack, the steel may yield, and the hangers may lose stiffness. A nonlinear analysis would provide a more accurate picture of the bridge performance.

From a manufacturing perspective, the inclined hangers create additional challenges for the steel tube connections. The hanger anchorages must be welded to the steel tube at an angle, which requires careful welding procedure qualification. The weld between the anchorage and the tube is subjected to combined axial and shear loads, and the quality of this weld is critical.

Study Insights and Practical Recommendations

From my perspective in the steel pipe and bridge construction industry, this paper highlights several important points:

  1. The hanger arrangement is a critical design decision in tied arch bridges. The radial arrangement performs best, but it is not always the most practical to construct.
  2. The inclination angle of the hangers has a significant effect on the bridge internal forces. The design must be robust to variations in this angle.
  3. The connection between the hanger and the arch rib is critical. The connection detail must be designed to accommodate the inclined hanger forces without causing local failures.
  4. The manufacturing of the arch rib tubes is challenging. The bending process creates residual stresses and wall thickness variations that must be accounted for in the design.
  5. The construction of a tied arch bridge with inclined hangers requires careful coordination between the steel tube fabrication, the concrete placement, and the hanger installation.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper provides a useful reference for the design of concrete-filled steel tube tied arch bridges with inclined hangers. The comparison of three hanger arrangements is valuable, and the finding that the radial arrangement performs best is important.

For future research, I would like to see:

Concluding Summary

Peng Guihan and colleagues have provided a valuable contribution to the design of concrete-filled steel tube tied arch bridges with inclined hangers. The study shows that the hanger arrangement has a significant influence on the bridge internal forces and deflections, and that the radial hanger arrangement performs best. For those of us in the steel pipe industry, this paper underscores the importance of the arch rib tube manufacturing quality and the hanger connection details. When we supply steel tubes for a tied arch bridge, we are not just supplying pipe; we are supplying a critical structural element whose performance depends on the tube dimensions, the steel grade, the bending quality, and the connection details. The paper gives us a framework for understanding the interaction between the hangers and the arch rib, and by extension, the importance of getting the details right. The tied arch bridge is a beautiful and efficient structural form, but it demands precision in design, manufacturing, and construction.