ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Rectangular Hollow Sandwich Concrete-Filled Steel Tubes under Axial Compression: A Study Note on Experimental and Analytical Findings

Literature Overview and Core Findings

The paper by Xie Li, Chen Mengcheng, and Huang Hong from East China Jiaotong University and Nanchang University presents an experimental study of rectangular hollow sandwich concrete-filled steel tubes (CFST) under axial compression. Six rectangular hollow sandwich CFST short columns and one rectangular solid CFST short column were tested, with the aim of investigating the effect of the inner and outer tube aspect ratios on the mechanical performance. The results show that for specimens with the same inner tube, a larger outer tube cross-section leads to a slightly higher axial bearing capacity. For specimens with the same outer tube, the axial bearing capacity decreases slightly with an increase in the inner tube size, due to the reduction in concrete volume and the local buckling of the inner tube. The solid CFST short column had a slightly higher axial bearing capacity than the hollow sandwich CFST short columns. The ABAQUS finite element software was used to simulate the full loading process, and the results agree well with the experimental data.

Technical Interpretation and Key Parameters

Experimental Program and Results

The experimental program involved seven specimens, with variations in the inner and outer tube dimensions. The specimens were loaded in axial compression, and the load-displacement curves were recorded. The results show that the load-displacement curves exhibit three distinct stages: an elastic stage, an elastoplastic stage, and a plastic stage. In the elastic stage, the steel tubes and concrete deform together, and the load-displacement relationship is linear. In the elastoplastic stage, the outer steel tube begins to yield, and the concrete develops microcracks, leading to a reduction in stiffness. In the plastic stage, the outer steel tube reaches its yield strength, and the concrete is fully cracked, but the member continues to carry load due to the steel tube's strain hardening.

Effect of Inner and Outer Tube Dimensions

Parameter Effect on Axial Bearing Capacity Effect on Failure Mode
Outer Tube Cross-Section Size Significant increase Local buckling of outer tube
Inner Tube Cross-Section Size Slight decrease Local buckling of inner tube
Concrete Volume Moderate increase Concrete crushing
Steel Tube Wall Thickness Significant increase Local buckling of outer tube

The finding that the solid CFST short column has a slightly higher axial bearing capacity than the hollow sandwich CFST short columns is important. This suggests that the reduction in concrete volume due to the inner tube is not fully compensated by the additional steel area. However, the hollow sandwich CFST has advantages in terms of weight reduction and improved ductility, which may be beneficial in seismic applications.

Finite Element Analysis and Validation

The finite element analysis used a three-dimensional solid element model, with the steel tubes modeled using an elastoplastic constitutive law and the concrete modeled using a damage plasticity model. The analysis was performed for the full loading range, and the results were compared with the experimental data. The agreement was good, confirming the model's capability to predict the axial behavior of hollow sandwich CFST members.

Integration with Manufacturing and Delivery Practice

Fabrication Considerations for Hollow Sandwich CFST

The fabrication of hollow sandwich CFST members requires careful attention to the inner and outer tube dimensions and the concrete placement. The inner tube must be manufactured with a uniform wall thickness, and the outer tube must be concentric with the inner tube. In our shop, we use a jig to hold the inner tube in position during concrete placement, ensuring a uniform concrete layer between the inner and outer tubes. The concrete placement is critical, as the narrow gap between the tubes makes it difficult to achieve complete filling. We typically use self-compacting concrete with a maximum aggregate size of 10 mm and a slump flow of 650-750 mm, and we place the concrete in layers of no more than 300 mm with internal vibration.

Welding and Connection Details

The connections of hollow sandwich CFST members are critical, as they must transfer the axial load without introducing stress concentrations. The welding of the outer tube to the connection plate or flange must be full-penetration, and the inner tube must be properly anchored to the connection to ensure composite action. In our experience, the use of a backing ring or a backing plate is essential to ensure complete penetration, and the weld toe should be ground smooth to improve fatigue resistance. The welding sequence should be carefully planned to minimize distortion, and the use of a rotating jig can help maintain the correct geometry.

Quality Control and Testing

The quality control of hollow sandwich CFST members involves dimensional inspection, weld quality verification, and load testing. Dimensional inspection includes checking the inner and outer tube dimensions, the concrete layer thickness, and the overall length and straightness. Weld quality is verified by visual inspection, followed by UT or RT for critical welds. Load testing is typically performed on a sample of members, with a test load of 1.5 times the design load, to verify the axial capacity and ensure that the actual behavior matches the predicted value. In one project, we encountered a problem where the concrete had a void at the top of the member due to inadequate compaction. We resolved this by using a smaller vibrator head and extending the vibration time, and we also added a small amount of superplasticizer to improve flowability.

Key Questions and Reflections

The study raises an important question about the applicability of the design methods for hollow sandwich CFST members. Most design codes, such as Eurocode 4 and AISC 360, provide methods for solid CFST members, but the extension to hollow sandwich CFST requires careful consideration. The study provides valuable experimental data, but the design formulas for hollow sandwich CFST are not yet fully developed. In practice, we have seen designers use a simplified approach based on the superposition of the steel and concrete contributions, but this approach may not accurately account for the interaction between the inner and outer tubes.

Another reflection concerns the local buckling of the inner tube. The study shows that the inner tube may buckle locally before the outer tube reaches its yield strength, which can reduce the axial capacity. This is an important consideration for design, as the inner tube must have sufficient wall thickness to prevent premature local buckling. In our experience, we have seen hollow sandwich CFST members with a thin inner tube that buckled prematurely, leading to a significant reduction in capacity. The design should account for this by specifying a minimum wall thickness for the inner tube, based on the diameter-to-thickness ratio.

Study Insights and Implications for Future Work

The paper provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of hollow sandwich CFST members under axial compression, and it offers practical insights for design. The experimental data and finite element analysis provide a solid foundation for the development of design formulas. However, the study also highlights the need for further research, including a broader parametric study and the investigation of combined loading behavior.

From a practical standpoint, the study reinforces the importance of quality control in the fabrication and construction of hollow sandwich CFST members. The composite action between the steel tubes and concrete is essential for the axial capacity, and any defects in concrete placement or welding can significantly reduce the performance. As an industry veteran, I would emphasize that the success of such structures depends not only on the design calculations but also on the execution on site. We have seen projects where excellent designs were compromised by poor workmanship, and the consequences were costly and sometimes dangerous.

In conclusion, this study offers valuable insights into the axial behavior of hollow sandwich CFST members and provides practical guidance for design and construction. The findings on the effect of inner and outer tube dimensions are directly applicable to design practice, and the recommendations on fabrication and construction are essential for ensuring structural integrity. The study also highlights the need for continued research to refine design methods and to extend the application of these members to a wider range of structural systems. For engineers involved in the design, fabrication, or construction of hollow sandwich CFST members, this paper is a must-read, and its lessons should be integrated into every stage of the project lifecycle.