ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Three-Dimensional Finite Element Simulation of Cross-Shaped Steel Tube Drawing

1. Introduction and Process Context

The paper by Hu Longfei and colleagues from Hefei University of Technology, published in Forging & Stamping Technology in 2006, addresses the three-dimensional finite element simulation of the drawing process for cross-shaped steel tubes. This is a topic that sits squarely in the world of special section tube manufacturing, a niche but demanding segment of our industry. I have spent time in plants that produce square, rectangular, hexagonal, and other special section tubes, and I can tell you that the drawing process is both an art and a science. The art lies in the design of the die and the selection of process parameters; the science lies in understanding the stress and strain distributions that govern whether the tube will fill the die cavity completely, whether it will tear, or whether it will develop internal defects.

Cross-shaped tubes, also known as cruciform sections, are used in applications ranging from structural members in lightweight frames to heat exchanger cores and even to the production of certain types of electrical busbars. The drawing process for such sections is challenging because the material flow is complex, with significant deformation in multiple directions simultaneously. The paper uses finite element simulation to investigate the deformation behavior during drawing, and it identifies the critical regions where stress concentrations occur. This is exactly the kind of analysis that I wish had been available when I was first learning the trade, because it would have saved us from many trial-and-error runs on the drawing bench.

The drawing process itself is a cold forming operation in which a tube is pulled through a die that reduces its cross-sectional area and shapes it to the desired profile. The tube is usually pre-formed to a round or slightly shaped section, and then drawn through one or more passes to achieve the final cross-section. The process is characterized by high productivity, excellent surface finish, and good dimensional accuracy, which is why it is preferred over other methods such as roll forming for many applications. However, the process is limited by the ductility of the material and by the complexity of the die design. The paper's use of finite element simulation to study the process is a practical approach that can reduce the number of experimental trials and help to optimize the die geometry and process parameters.

2. Stress and Strain Distributions During Drawing

2.1 Stress Distribution

The paper reports that the axial, circumferential, and radial stresses all increase as the tube moves through the die, and that the maximum values of all three stress components occur at the junction between the reducing zone and the sizing zone of the die. This is a critical finding because it identifies the location where the material is subjected to the highest combination of stresses, and where failure is most likely to initiate. The junction between the reducing and sizing zones is where the material transitions from being plastically deformed to being elastically constrained, and the stress state there is complex, with significant components in all three directions.

The paper also reports that the stress distribution through the wall thickness is relatively uniform in the center layer, which is consistent with the assumption of plane strain deformation that is often used in simplified analytical models. However, the stress distribution is not uniform near the inner and outer surfaces, where the material is subjected to different boundary conditions. The outer surface is in contact with the die, and the friction between the tube and the die creates a shear stress that is superimposed on the normal stresses. The inner surface is free, but it is subjected to the radial stress that is transmitted through the wall thickness.

In practice, the stress concentration at the reducing-sizing junction is the location where I have seen the most problems. If the die is not properly designed, or if the reduction is too severe, the material will tear at this location, or it will develop a defect known as "luders lines" or "stretcher strains" on the surface. The paper's finding that the maximum stresses occur at this junction is a useful reminder that the die design must be optimized to minimize the stress concentration, typically by using a smooth transition between the reducing and sizing zones.

2.2 Strain Distribution

The paper reports that the plastic deformation occurs primarily in two regions: the initial contact region between the tube and the die, and the junction between the reducing and sizing zones. This is consistent with the stress distribution, and it indicates that the material is being deformed most intensely in these two regions. The circumferential strain varies significantly along the axial direction, with negative values at the die entry and positive values at the die exit. This is an interesting finding because it suggests that the material is initially compressed circumferentially as it enters the die, and then expanded as it exits the sizing zone. The transition from compression to tension in the circumferential direction is a key feature of the drawing process, and it is responsible for the characteristic "springback" that occurs after the tube exits the die.

The strain distribution through the wall thickness is also non-uniform, with the highest strains occurring at the outer surface, where the material is in contact with the die, and the lowest strains occurring at the inner surface. This is because the outer surface is subjected to the additional shear strain from friction, while the inner surface is free to deform. The non-uniform strain distribution can lead to residual stresses in the finished tube, which can affect its dimensional stability and its performance in service. The paper does not explicitly address residual stresses, but the strain distribution it reports is a precursor to the residual stress state.

In my experience, the non-uniform strain distribution is the root cause of many dimensional problems in drawn tubes. If the strain is not uniform, the tube will have a tendency to twist or bow after drawing, and it may be difficult to achieve the required tolerances. The solution is to optimize the die design to promote more uniform deformation, typically by using a multi-pass drawing schedule with intermediate annealing, or by using a die with a more gradual reduction angle.

3. Effect of Process Parameters

3.1 Circumferential Compression Coefficient

The paper introduces a parameter called the circumferential compression coefficient, denoted as eta, which is defined as the ratio of the circumferential compression to the radial reduction. The paper reports that when eta is in the range of 1.05 to 1.14, the drawing process is stable and the stress-strain curves are smooth. When eta is outside this range, the process becomes unstable, with fluctuations in the drawing force and the potential for defects such as tearing or wrinkling.

This is a valuable finding because it provides a practical window for the process parameter. In my experience, the circumferential compression coefficient is a parameter that is often overlooked in production, and many operators simply set the die geometry based on experience without considering the ratio of circumferential to radial deformation. The paper's finding that there is an optimal range for eta is a useful guide for die design and process optimization.

The physical explanation for the optimal range is that the material must be able to flow in both the circumferential and radial directions to fill the die cavity. If the circumferential compression is too low, the material will not fill the corners of the cross-section, resulting in an incomplete profile. If the circumferential compression is too high, the material will be over-stressed and may tear or develop wrinkles. The optimal range represents a balance between these two failure modes.

3.2 Drawing Speed

The paper reports that the drawing stress reaches a minimum when the drawing speed is 250 mm/s. This is an interesting finding because it suggests that there is an optimal drawing speed that minimizes the drawing force. The physical explanation is that at low speeds, the friction between the tube and the die is high, because the lubricant is not fully effective at low sliding velocities. At high speeds, the strain rate increases, and the material exhibits strain rate hardening, which increases the flow stress. The optimal speed represents a balance between these two effects.

In practice, the drawing speed is often limited by the capacity of the drawing machine and by the need to maintain dimensional accuracy. The paper's finding that 250 mm/s is the optimal speed for the specific conditions studied is a useful reference, but it should be noted that the optimal speed will depend on the material, the lubricant, and the die geometry. In my experience, the drawing speed is typically in the range of 100 to 500 mm/s for most applications, and the optimal speed must be determined experimentally for each specific case.

3.3 Friction Coefficient

The paper reports that the drawing stress increases with an increase in the friction coefficient. This is expected, as the friction between the tube and the die adds to the drawing force. The paper does not provide specific values for the friction coefficient, but it is well known that the friction coefficient in cold drawing is typically in the range of 0.05 to 0.15, depending on the lubricant and the surface condition of the die and the tube. The use of a good lubricant is essential to minimize the drawing force and to prevent galling and surface damage.

In my experience, the choice of lubricant is one of the most important factors in the drawing process. A poor lubricant will lead to high friction, high drawing forces, and surface defects such as scratches and galling. A good lubricant will reduce the drawing force by as much as 30 percent and will produce a smooth surface finish. The paper's finding that the drawing stress increases with the friction coefficient is a reminder that the lubricant must be carefully selected and applied consistently.

4. Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

4.1 Die Design and Manufacturing

The die design is critical to the success of the drawing process. The paper's finding that the maximum stresses occur at the junction between the reducing and sizing zones is a key consideration for die design. The die should have a smooth transition between the reducing and sizing zones to minimize the stress concentration. The die angle, which is the angle of the reducing zone, should be optimized to balance the drawing force and the deformation uniformity. A smaller die angle will reduce the drawing force but will increase the length of the reducing zone, while a larger die angle will increase the drawing force but will reduce the length of the reducing zone.

The die material is also important. The die must be made of a hard, wear-resistant material, such as tungsten carbide or tool steel, and it must be polished to a high surface finish to minimize friction. In my experience, the die surface finish should be better than 0.2 micrometers Ra to achieve a good surface finish on the drawn tube. The die must also be designed with proper lubrication channels to ensure that the lubricant is distributed evenly over the contact surface.

4.2 Material Selection and Preparation

The material for the tube must have sufficient ductility to withstand the deformation without tearing. The paper does not specify the material, but it is likely a low-carbon steel or a stainless steel. In my experience, the material should have a uniform microstructure and a low inclusion content to minimize the risk of tearing. The tube must be properly annealed before drawing to ensure that it is in a soft, ductile condition. The surface of the tube must be clean and free of oxide and scale, as these can cause surface defects and increase friction.

The tube is typically pre-formed to a round section before drawing. The pre-forming process can be done by rolling, extrusion, or a combination of these methods. The pre-formed tube should have a diameter that is slightly larger than the inscribed circle of the cross-shaped section, so that the material can flow into the corners of the die. The paper does not discuss the pre-forming process, but it is an important consideration in the overall production sequence.

4.3 Quality Control and Inspection

The quality of the drawn cross-shaped tube must be verified by dimensional inspection, surface inspection, and mechanical testing. The dimensional inspection should verify the cross-sectional dimensions, the wall thickness, and the straightness. The surface inspection should verify that there are no scratches, galling, or other surface defects. The mechanical testing should verify the tensile strength, yield strength, and elongation.

In my experience, the most common defect in drawn cross-shaped tubes is incomplete filling of the corners. This is caused by insufficient circumferential compression or by an improper die design. The defect can be detected by visual inspection or by dimensional measurement. Another common defect is tearing, which is caused by excessive reduction or by a material with insufficient ductility. Tearing can be detected by visual inspection or by ultrasonic testing.

5. Conclusions and Outlook

The paper by Hu Longfei and colleagues provides a valuable three-dimensional finite element analysis of the drawing process for cross-shaped steel tubes. The findings on the stress and strain distributions, and the effects of the circumferential compression coefficient, drawing speed, and friction coefficient, provide a solid foundation for understanding the process and for optimizing the die design and process parameters. The identification of the junction between the reducing and sizing zones as the location of maximum stress is a key finding that should guide die design.

In my view, the paper's most practical contribution is the identification of the optimal range for the circumferential compression coefficient (1.05 to 1.14) and the optimal drawing speed (250 mm/s). These parameters provide a starting point for process optimization, but they must be verified experimentally for each specific application. The paper also highlights the importance of the friction coefficient, which is a reminder that the lubricant must be carefully selected and applied.

The future of cross-shaped tube drawing lies in the development of more sophisticated simulation models that can account for the effects of material anisotropy, temperature, and strain rate. The use of finite element simulation is already well-established in the industry, and it will continue to play an increasingly important role in die design and process optimization. For now, the paper provides a useful reference for anyone who needs to understand the deformation behavior of cross-shaped tubes during drawing, and it is a reminder that the drawing process is a delicate balance between material flow, stress, and strain.