ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Axial Compression Performance of Steel Fiber Recycled Concrete-Filled Square Steel Tube Short Columns

Literature Overview and Test Program

This paper by Zhang Zhaoqiang, Zhao Junhai and Deng Yongjun from Chang'an University and Southwest University of Science and Technology presents an experimental study on the axial compression behaviour of square steel tube columns filled with steel fiber reinforced recycled concrete. The test program included 23 specimens with steel fiber volume fractions ranging from 0% to 2.5% and section steel ratios from 5% to 12%, plus 2 control specimens without steel fibers.

The recycled concrete was produced using recycled coarse aggregate from demolished concrete, with a replacement ratio of 100%. The steel fibers were hooked-end type with a length of 35 mm and an aspect ratio of 60. The test setup applied monotonic axial compression, with load-displacement and load-strain curves recorded throughout the loading process.

Test Results and Failure Modes

The failure modes of the steel fiber recycled concrete-filled square steel tube (SFRCFST) short columns were similar to those of conventional concrete-filled steel tube columns. The typical failure sequence was:

  1. Initial elastic behaviour with linear load-displacement relationship.
  2. Concrete micro-cracking at approximately 30-40% of the ultimate load, accompanied by a slight reduction in stiffness.
  3. Steel tube yielding at approximately 60-70% of the ultimate load, with visible local buckling of the tube wall.
  4. Ultimate load reached when the concrete crushed and the steel tube buckled locally.
  5. Post-peak behaviour showed a gradual load decay, with the steel fiber reinforced specimens exhibiting more ductile response.

The steel fiber volume fraction had a negligible effect on the failure mode. All specimens failed by concrete crushing and steel tube local buckling, regardless of the fiber content. This is consistent with the observation that steel fibers primarily affect the post-cracking behaviour of concrete, not the pre-cracking behaviour.

Influence of Steel Fiber Volume Fraction

The axial compression capacity showed a non-monotonic relationship with the steel fiber volume fraction:

Steel Fiber Volume Fraction (%) Capacity Change vs. Control Ductility Index Change vs. Control
0.5 +3% +10%
1.0 +6% +25%
1.5 +5% +40%
2.0 -2% +55%
2.5 -8% +65%

The capacity increased slightly for fiber fractions up to 1.5%, but decreased for fractions above 2%. The decrease at high fiber fractions is attributed to the agglomeration of fibers, which creates weak zones in the concrete and increases the number of interfacial defects. The ductility, however, increased monotonically with the fiber fraction, with the displacement ductility coefficient improving by up to 65% at 2.5% fiber content.

The recommended steel fiber volume fraction is 1.0-1.5%, which provides a balance between capacity enhancement and ductility improvement. This is a practical recommendation that balances the conflicting requirements of strength and deformability.

Influence of Section Steel Ratio

The section steel ratio, defined as the ratio of the steel tube cross-sectional area to the total cross-sectional area, had a significant influence on both capacity and ductility:

Section Steel Ratio (%) Capacity Increase vs. Minimum Ratio Ductility Increase vs. Minimum Ratio
5 Baseline Baseline
8 +18% +22%
12 +35% +40%

Both capacity and ductility increased with the section steel ratio, as expected. The steel tube provides confinement to the concrete core, which enhances both the compressive strength and the deformability. Higher section steel ratios also reduce the risk of local buckling, as the tube wall is thicker relative to the diameter.

Design Formula and Unified Strength Theory

The authors propose a design formula based on the unified strength theory, which accounts for the interaction between the steel tube and the concrete core. The formula incorporates the steel fiber volume fraction through an equivalent concrete strength enhancement factor.

The proposed formula is:

N_u = f_c' A_c (1 + alpha rho_s) (1 + beta * V_f)

where f_c' is the concrete cylinder strength, A_c is the concrete cross-sectional area, rho_s is the section steel ratio, V_f is the steel fiber volume fraction, and alpha and beta are coefficients determined from the test data.

The formula predictions agreed well with the test results, with a maximum deviation of approximately 10%. This is acceptable for design purposes, particularly when combined with appropriate safety factors.

Engineering Practice Implications and Material Supply Considerations

From a steel pipe supply perspective, this paper raises important questions about the compatibility between the steel tube and the concrete infill. The recycled concrete has a lower elastic modulus and higher shrinkage than conventional concrete, which affects the composite action.

Key considerations for the steel tube manufacturer:

  1. The steel tube must provide adequate confinement to the recycled concrete core. This requires a minimum wall thickness to diameter ratio, typically 1/50 to 1/40 for square tubes.
  2. The tube surface condition affects the bond between the steel and the concrete. A roughened surface, achieved by shot blasting or wire brushing, improves the bond and enhances the composite action.
  3. The tube must be sufficiently stiff to resist local buckling during the concrete casting process, particularly when the concrete is pumped from the bottom.
  4. The welding of the tube must be of high quality, as any weld defects can initiate local buckling or cracking.

The steel fibers in the concrete also affect the casting process. The fibers increase the viscosity of the concrete, making it more difficult to pump and compact. This is particularly problematic in square tubes, where the corners create flow restrictions. Self-consolidating concrete with a high fiber content is recommended, but the fiber content should not exceed 1.5% to avoid agglomeration.

Study Insights and Practical Recommendations

This paper provides valuable data on the behaviour of steel fiber recycled concrete-filled square steel tube columns. The key takeaways are:

  1. Steel fibers improve ductility significantly, with up to 65% improvement in the displacement ductility coefficient.
  2. The optimal steel fiber volume fraction is 1.0-1.5%, balancing capacity and ductility.
  3. The section steel ratio has a more significant effect on capacity than the steel fiber content.
  4. The proposed design formula based on unified strength theory provides accurate predictions within 10% deviation.

For our industry, this research supports the use of recycled concrete in CFST structures, which is an important sustainability initiative. The use of steel fibers mitigates the brittleness of recycled concrete, making it a viable alternative to conventional concrete in structural applications.

The practical recommendations for fabricators and contractors are:

  1. Use steel fiber volume fractions of 1.0-1.5% for optimal performance.
  2. Ensure proper mixing to avoid fiber agglomeration.
  3. Use self-consolidating concrete to ensure complete filling of the tube.
  4. Maintain adequate section steel ratios, typically above 8%, for reliable performance.
  5. Apply the proposed design formula with appropriate safety factors.

The research also highlights the importance of full-scale testing in evaluating the performance of composite structures. Small-scale specimens and numerical models cannot capture the effects of fiber agglomeration, concrete shrinkage and interface bond, which are critical to the actual behaviour. The 23 specimens tested in this study provide a robust database for design and future research.