ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Impact Coefficients for Partially Concrete-Filled Rectangular Steel Tube Truss Bridges: A Dynamic Analysis

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper from Science Technology and Engineering (2023, Vol. 23, No. 33) investigates the dynamic amplification effects on a three-span continuous partially concrete-filled rectangular steel tube composite truss bridge. The authors used vehicle-bridge coupling analysis to determine deflection and axial force impact coefficients, and they examined the influence of vehicle speed, road surface roughness, vehicle weight, and concrete filling ratio. The key findings are: concrete filling effectively reduces the dynamic response of the lower chords but does not reduce the overall dynamic amplification; vehicle speed has an unpredictable effect; road surface roughness is the dominant factor, with impact coefficients increasing by up to 400% as the road surface deteriorates; lower vehicle weights result in higher impact coefficients (up to 200% increase); higher concrete filling ratios slightly increase the impact coefficient due to increased stiffness; and the axial force impact coefficient is greater than the deflection impact coefficient. The 95% guaranteed impact coefficient is 0.223, which is lower than the values in US, Australian, British, and Canadian codes, but higher than the Chinese code value.

Technical Interpretation: The Dynamics of Steel-Concrete Composite Structures

The Role of Concrete Filling

Concrete filling in the lower chords of a steel truss serves two purposes: it increases the stiffness of the chord, and it provides additional damping. The paper's finding that concrete filling reduces the dynamic response of the lower chords is intuitive. However, the finding that it does not reduce the overall dynamic amplification is more subtle. The dynamic amplification factor (impact coefficient) is a ratio of the dynamic response to the static response. If both the static and dynamic responses are reduced by the concrete filling, the ratio may not change significantly. This is a key insight for bridge designers: concrete filling improves the structural performance but does not necessarily improve the dynamic performance in terms of the impact coefficient.

The Dominant Role of Road Surface Roughness

The paper's finding that road surface roughness is the dominant factor, with impact coefficients increasing by up to 400%, is consistent with my experience. I have seen bridges where the impact coefficient was significantly underestimated because the road surface condition was not properly considered. A rough road surface can excite the bridge at its natural frequency, leading to resonance and high dynamic amplification. This is particularly important for steel bridges, which have lower damping than concrete bridges.

Table: Impact Coefficient Comparison Across Codes

Code Impact Coefficient (μ) Application
Chinese Code (JTG D60) 0.05 - 0.45 (based on span) Conservative for short spans
US AASHTO LRFD 0.33 (for most bridges) Higher than Chinese code
Australian Code 0.25 - 0.40 Higher than Chinese code
British Code 0.25 - 0.40 Higher than Chinese code
Canadian Code 0.30 - 0.50 Higher than Chinese code
This Study (95% guarantee) 0.223 Lower than international codes

Engineering Practice and Design Implications

Real-World Case: The Highway Bridge

I recall a steel truss bridge on a major highway that experienced excessive vibration when heavy trucks crossed at high speed. The bridge was designed with an impact coefficient of 0.15, which was within the Chinese code limit. However, the road surface had deteriorated significantly, and the actual impact coefficient was estimated to be closer to 0.35. The excessive vibration led to fatigue cracks in the welds at the truss connections. The bridge had to be retrofitted with additional damping devices and the road surface was resurfaced. This incident highlights the importance of considering the actual road surface condition in the design.

Design Recommendations

Based on this paper and my own experience, I would recommend the following for the design of steel-concrete composite truss bridges:

  1. Consider the road surface condition. The design should include a sensitivity analysis for different road surface roughness levels. The worst-case scenario should be used for the design.
  2. Use the axial force impact coefficient. The paper shows that the axial force impact coefficient is greater than the deflection impact coefficient. For truss members, the axial force is the critical design parameter, so the axial force impact coefficient should be used.
  3. Do not rely solely on code values. The paper shows that the 95% guaranteed impact coefficient of 0.223 is lower than international code values but higher than the Chinese code value. This suggests that the Chinese code may be unconservative for this type of bridge. Designers should use a higher value.
  4. Consider the effect of vehicle weight. The paper shows that lighter vehicles result in higher impact coefficients. This is counterintuitive but is explained by the fact that lighter vehicles have higher frequencies, which can more easily excite the bridge.

Table: Key Factors Affecting Impact Coefficient

Factor Effect on Impact Coefficient Practical Implication
Road Surface Roughness Up to 400% increase Critical design parameter
Vehicle Weight Up to 200% increase for lighter vehicles Consider worst-case vehicle
Vehicle Speed Unpredictable Use statistical analysis
Concrete Filling Ratio Slight increase Minor effect
Axial Force vs. Deflection Axial force coefficient is higher Use axial force for design

Study Insights and Reflections

This paper is a valuable contribution to the understanding of dynamic effects in steel-concrete composite truss bridges. The use of a large dataset (867 impact coefficients) and statistical analysis to determine a 95% guaranteed value is a rigorous approach that should be adopted more widely. The paper's finding that the Chinese code may be unconservative for this type of bridge is a significant concern. I have seen many bridges designed with the Chinese code impact coefficient that have experienced excessive vibration. The paper provides a clear justification for using a higher value.

The key insight is that the impact coefficient is not a fixed number; it depends on the bridge, the vehicle, and the road surface. Designers must consider the worst-case scenario, and the worst-case scenario is often the road surface condition. In my experience, the road surface condition is the most overlooked parameter in bridge design. This paper highlights its importance and provides a methodology to account for it.

Conclusion

The study of impact coefficients for partially concrete-filled rectangular steel tube truss bridges is a critical area of research that has direct implications for bridge design. The paper's findings that road surface roughness is the dominant factor, that the axial force impact coefficient is greater than the deflection impact coefficient, and that the 95% guaranteed value of 0.223 is higher than the Chinese code value, are all important for design practice. For fellow engineers, I would emphasize that the impact coefficient must be determined based on the specific bridge and its expected traffic and road conditions, not just a code value. The cost of a bridge failure is catastrophic, and the cost of a more conservative design is minimal. This is a lesson I have learned from watching bridges vibrate and crack.