ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Shear Bearing Capacity of Circular Hollow Sandwich Steel Tube Concrete Columns: Manufacturing and Design Implications

1. Paper Overview and Test Program

The paper by Huang Hong, Xu Chuanguo, Yang Chao, and Zeng Genping, published in Railway Engineering, investigates the shear bearing capacity of circular hollow sandwich steel tube concrete columns. These columns consist of an outer steel tube, an inner steel tube, and concrete filled in the annular space between them. The authors used the finite element software ABAQUS to simulate the shear stress-shear strain relationship of these columns under pure shear. Through the analysis of a large number of examples, they determined the shear span ratio ranges for different failure modes and studied the effects of the yield strength of the inner and outer steel tubes, the nominal steel ratio, the inner tube diameter-to-thickness ratio, the hollow ratio, and the concrete strength on the shear stress-shear strain relationship.

The key findings are as follows: when the shear span ratio is not greater than 0.1, the shear bearing capacity of the circular hollow sandwich steel tube concrete column can be calculated as a pure shear member. The authors proposed a simplified formula for the shear bearing capacity, and the formula results agreed well with the finite element results.

2. Double-Skin Tube Fabrication and Welding

The circular hollow sandwich steel tube concrete column is a sophisticated structural element that requires careful fabrication. The outer steel tube is typically a seamless or welded pipe with a diameter of 300-800 mm and a wall thickness of 6-16 mm. The inner steel tube is smaller, with a diameter of 100-400 mm and a wall thickness of 4-10 mm. The concrete is filled in the annular space, which can be 50-150 mm wide.

From a manufacturing perspective, the key challenge is the concentricity of the two steel tubes. If the inner tube is not perfectly concentric with the outer tube, the concrete annulus will be uneven, leading to non-uniform confinement and potential premature failure. In our mill, we use a jig system to hold the inner tube in place while the outer tube is welded to the end plates. The concentricity tolerance is typically ±2 mm, which ensures a uniform concrete annulus.

The welding of the end plates to the steel tubes is critical. The end plates are typically 20-30 mm thick, and the weld is a full-penetration weld. The heat input must be controlled to avoid distortion of the tubes. In one project, we had to use a low heat input of 1.5 kJ/mm and a preheat of 100°C to prevent the outer tube from ovalizing. The welds must be inspected by ultrasonic testing, and any defect must be repaired before the column is filled with concrete.

3. Shear Behavior and Failure Modes

The paper's finding that the shear bearing capacity can be calculated as a pure shear member when the shear span ratio is not greater than 0.1 is significant. This means that for columns with a short shear span, the failure mode is shear failure of the concrete and the steel tubes, rather than flexural failure. In practice, this is relevant for columns that are subjected to high lateral loads, such as in seismic zones or in structures with significant wind loads.

The failure modes of the hollow sandwich steel tube concrete column under shear can be classified into three types: shear failure of the concrete, shear failure of the steel tubes, and a combined failure mode. The shear span ratio determines which mode occurs. For a shear span ratio of less than 0.1, the failure is dominated by the shear capacity of the concrete and the steel tubes. For a shear span ratio of 0.1-0.5, the failure is a combination of shear and flexure. For a shear span ratio greater than 0.5, the failure is dominated by flexure.

From a practical perspective, the design must ensure that the shear capacity of the column is sufficient to resist the maximum shear force. The paper's simplified formula is useful for this purpose, but it is based on a limited number of finite element analyses. In practice, we always require a full-scale prototype test for columns that will be used in critical structures, especially those in seismic zones.

4. Parametric Study and Design Implications

The paper's parametric study reveals several important trends. First, increasing the yield strength of the inner and outer steel tubes increases the shear capacity, but the effect is not linear. The outer steel tube has a greater effect than the inner steel tube because it provides more confinement to the concrete. Second, increasing the nominal steel ratio (the ratio of the steel area to the total area) increases the shear capacity. Third, decreasing the inner tube diameter-to-thickness ratio increases the shear capacity because it prevents local buckling of the inner tube. Fourth, increasing the hollow ratio decreases the shear capacity because there is less concrete to resist the shear. Fifth, increasing the concrete strength increases the shear capacity, but the effect is less significant than the steel tube properties.

These findings have direct design implications. For a column that is expected to resist significant shear, the designer should use high-strength steel tubes, a high nominal steel ratio, a small inner tube diameter-to-thickness ratio, and a low hollow ratio. The concrete strength is a secondary factor.

From a manufacturing perspective, the nominal steel ratio is controlled by the wall thicknesses of the steel tubes. A high nominal steel ratio means thick steel tubes, which are more expensive and more difficult to weld. In practice, we recommend a nominal steel ratio of 0.1-0.2, which balances the shear capacity with the cost and manufacturability.

5. Shop Floor and Site Considerations

The fabrication of the circular hollow sandwich steel tube concrete column requires a clean and controlled environment. The concrete filling is a critical step, and the concrete must be self-compacting to ensure complete filling of the annular space. The maximum aggregate size should be 10-15 mm, and the slump flow should be 600-700 mm.

One practical issue is the inspection of the concrete filling. Since the concrete is in an annular space, it is difficult to inspect visually. We typically use ultrasonic tomography to detect voids, and if voids are found, we grout them through injection ports. In one project, we found a void at the top of the column, and we had to drill a hole and inject a cementitious grout.

Another issue is the corrosion protection of the steel tubes. The outer steel tube is exposed to the environment, and it must be protected with a coating system. The inner steel tube is not exposed, but it may be subject to corrosion if the concrete is not properly sealed. We recommend a corrosion inhibitor in the concrete mix and a waterproofing membrane on the inner surface of the outer tube.

6. Conclusion

The paper provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of the shear bearing capacity of circular hollow sandwich steel tube concrete columns. The finding that the shear capacity can be calculated as a pure shear member for shear span ratios of less than 0.1 is particularly useful for design. The parametric study provides clear guidance on the effects of the steel tube properties, the nominal steel ratio, the hollow ratio, and the concrete strength. From a manufacturing perspective, the key challenges are the concentricity of the two steel tubes, the welding of the end plates, and the concrete filling. The simplified formula proposed in the paper is a useful tool for preliminary design, but it should be validated with more experimental data. In practice, the fabrication of these columns requires careful quality control, and the concrete filling must be inspected to ensure complete filling without voids.