Grouted Chord Square Steel Tube Truss-Concrete Composite Beams: Flexural Capacity and Practical Grouting Considerations
Research Overview and Test Setup
This paper by Wang Kun, Zha Zhiyuan, Hu Pengfei and Zhong Zhenpeng, published in Journal of Yangzhou University (Natural Science Edition) in 2020, investigates the flexural capacity of square steel tube truss-concrete composite beams where both the top and bottom chords are grouted with concrete. The authors conducted static loading tests on simply supported beams and developed finite element models using Abaqus. They compared the experimental and numerical load-midspan deflection curves and steel tube strain curves, analysed the load transfer mechanism, and proposed a calculation formula for the flexural capacity of the normal section.
This is a topic that resonates with my experience in bridge construction, where truss girders with concrete-filled chords are increasingly used for their high stiffness-to-weight ratio and excellent durability.
Load-Deflection Behaviour and Failure Mechanism
The test results show that the grouted chord truss-concrete composite beam exhibits:
- High bearing capacity. The concrete infill in the chords significantly increases the flexural capacity compared to a conventional steel truss with hollow chords. The concrete infill increases the axial stiffness of the chords, which in turn increases the flexural stiffness of the truss.
- Good ductility. The load-deflection curve shows a long, stable plateau after yielding, indicating that the beam can sustain significant deformation without losing its load-carrying capacity. This is attributed to the ductile behaviour of the concrete infill and the steel tube.
- The failure mechanism is governed by the yielding of the bottom chord. The bottom chord is in tension, and the concrete infill in the bottom chord cracks in tension. However, the steel tube provides the primary tensile resistance. The top chord is in compression, and the concrete infill in the top chord is in compression, providing additional compressive resistance.
The strain measurements show that the steel tube and the concrete infill act compositely, with the strain distribution being approximately linear across the section. This confirms that the composite action is effective, and the beam can be analysed using the transformed section method.
Parametric Study and Capacity Formula
The parametric study, conducted using the validated finite element model, reveals the following:
| Parameter | Effect on Flexural Capacity |
|---|---|
| Bottom chord cross-sectional area | Significant positive effect — capacity increases with bottom chord area |
| Top chord cross-sectional area | Negligible effect — capacity is insensitive to top chord area |
| Joint spacing | Negligible effect — capacity is insensitive to joint spacing |
The insensitivity of the flexural capacity to the top chord area and joint spacing is an important finding. It suggests that the design of the top chord and the joints can be optimised for other considerations, such as stability and constructability, without compromising the flexural capacity.
The proposed calculation formula for the flexural capacity of the normal section is based on the equilibrium of forces and the compatibility of strains. The formula considers the contributions of the steel tube, the concrete infill, and the concrete slab. The calculated values agree well with the test results.
Engineering Practice and Grouting Quality Control
From a practical standpoint, the grouting of the chords is the most critical construction operation. The following considerations are essential:
- Grout mix design. The grout must be flowable enough to fill the entire tube cross-section, including the corners and the joints. We typically use a self-compacting concrete with a slump flow of 600-700 mm, a maximum aggregate size of 10 mm, and a water-cement ratio of 0.35-0.40. The grout must also have low shrinkage to avoid gaps between the grout and the tube wall.
- Grouting procedure. The grout is typically pumped from one end of the chord to the other, with vent holes at the highest points to allow air to escape. The pumping pressure must be carefully controlled to avoid bursting the tube. For long chords, the grouting may need to be done in stages, with intermediate vents.
- Quality control. The grouting quality must be verified by non-destructive testing. We use a combination of ultrasonic testing and impact-echo testing to detect voids in the grout. If voids are detected, they must be repaired by drilling and injecting grout.
- The grouting of the bottom chord is particularly critical. The bottom chord is in tension, and any voids in the grout will reduce the composite action and the flexural capacity. We require a minimum grout fill of 95% for the bottom chord, verified by ultrasonic testing.
Field Observations and Lessons Learned
I have been involved in several projects where the grouting of steel tube chords was performed. In one project, the grouting of the bottom chord was performed without proper venting, resulting in a large void at the highest point of the chord. The void was detected by ultrasonic testing, and it had to be repaired by drilling and injecting grout. The repair was successful, but it added cost and delay to the project.
The lesson is clear: the grouting procedure must be carefully planned, with proper venting and quality control. The grouting of the bottom chord should be performed from the lowest point to the highest point, with vents at all high points. The pumping pressure should be monitored, and the grout should be sampled and tested for flow and strength.
Another lesson relates to the joint spacing. The paper shows that the flexural capacity is insensitive to joint spacing, but this does not mean that the joint spacing can be arbitrarily large. The joints must be designed to transfer the shear forces between the chords and the web members. The joint spacing should be determined based on the shear force distribution and the joint capacity.
Concluding Reflections
This paper provides a solid basis for the design of grouted chord square steel tube truss-concrete composite beams. The key findings are: the concrete infill in the chords significantly increases the flexural capacity, the flexural capacity is primarily governed by the bottom chord area, and the flexural capacity is insensitive to the top chord area and joint spacing.
For practising engineers, the practical takeaways are: use the proposed calculation formula for the flexural capacity of the normal section, ensure proper grouting of the chords with adequate quality control, and optimise the top chord and joint spacing based on other considerations such as stability and constructability.
The system offers significant advantages over conventional steel trusses in terms of stiffness, capacity and durability. However, it requires careful attention to grouting quality and joint design. I would like to see further research on the behaviour of the joints under combined axial and shear loading, as well as the fatigue behaviour of the grouted chords under repeated loading.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd