Pit-Bottom Steel Pipe Static Pressure Pile Foundation Underpinning Technology for a Coal Mine Gas Pump House
Introduction and Background
The paper by Zhang Tinghui and colleagues addresses a problem I have seen more than once on soft ground: a machine foundation settling because the bearing stratum was never reached, or because the soil beneath it was collapsible loess that lost strength the moment water got in. The case here is a coal mine gas pump house fan foundation in Shaanxi, where the original shallow foundation sat on weak collapsible loess and the fan had started to settle and crack. The solution chosen was pit-bottom steel pipe static pressure pile underpinning, and the paper reports the design, the construction sequence and the quality control measures that made it work.
What I want to draw out for fellow engineers is not just the method, but the practical logic of why a steel pipe pile was chosen over a concrete pile, what the jacking force and penetration depth actually mean on site, and where the real risk lies in this kind of underpinning work.
Technical Principle of Pit-Bottom Static Pressure Pile Underpinning
The underpinning principle is straightforward: the existing foundation is being carried by soil that is no longer good enough, so you transfer the load down to a deeper, competent stratum using piles installed from inside the pit beneath the foundation. The steel pipe pile is jacked into the ground in short sections, each section welded to the previous one, until the pile tip reaches the required depth and the jacking force reaches the specified value.
The reason steel pipe works so well here is that it is light, strong, easy to splice by welding, and it can be jacked without vibration. Vibration is the enemy when you are underpinning a live foundation, because you do not want to disturb the very soil you are trying to improve. A driven concrete pile would hammer the ground; a bored pile would need drilling rigs and slurry; a static pressure steel pipe pile just pushes quietly. On a collapsible loess site, that quiet push is worth a lot.
The steel pipe also has a closed end plate, which means the pile behaves as a displacement pile, densifying the soil around it as it penetrates. That densification is itself a benefit, because it improves the soil around the pile and helps to carry load by skin friction.
Design Scheme and Key Parameters
The design scheme for this project was based on the geological conditions and the load from the fan foundation. The paper gives the pile tip penetration depth and the jacking force as the two controlling parameters. Let me lay out the typical design logic in a table.
| Parameter | Typical Value / Basis | Practical Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Pile diameter | 100–200 mm for underpinning | Small enough to jack by hand or light rig, strong enough for the load |
| Pipe wall thickness | 4–8 mm | Must be checked for buckling during jacking and for corrosion in service |
| Pile tip penetration depth | Determined by bearing stratum depth | The pile must reach a competent layer, not just a set depth |
| Jacking force | Determined by design load and safety factor | Must be verified against pile capacity |
| Pile section length | 1.0–2.0 m | Short sections allow jacking inside a confined pit |
| End plate | Closed, welded to pipe bottom | Converts pile into a displacement pile and protects the tip |
| Steel grade | Q235 or Q345 | Q345 preferred where jacking force is high |
The paper reports that the pile tip penetration depth and the jacking force were analysed together, which is the right approach. A pile that reaches the required depth but does not develop the required jacking force has not proven its capacity; a pile that reaches the jacking force too early may have hit a boulder or a hard lens and is not necessarily at the right depth. The two criteria must be satisfied together.
Construction Process and Quality Control Points
The construction sequence for pit-bottom steel pipe static pressure piles is a discipline, not an improvisation. The steps are:
- Excavate the pit beneath the foundation to the working level.
- Set up the jacking frame and reaction system against the existing foundation.
- Place the first pile section, check verticality, and begin jacking.
- When the section is nearly fully driven, weld the next section on, maintaining alignment.
- Continue jacking and welding until the design penetration depth and jacking force are both achieved.
- Grout or fill the pile interior if required for corrosion protection or additional capacity.
- Connect the pile head to the existing foundation with a cap beam or anchorage.
The quality control points that matter are verticality, weld quality at the splices, and the recording of jacking force versus depth. Verticality is critical because a leaning pile loses capacity and introduces eccentric loading. The welds at the splices must be full penetration and sound, because a defective weld at a splice is a hidden defect that you cannot inspect after the pile is driven. The jacking force versus depth record is the real quality document, because it tells you whether the pile is behaving as expected.
The paper emphasises process control over final inspection, and that is exactly right. You cannot test a static pressure pile after it is installed the way you can test a driven pile with a dynamic load test. The proof is in the jacking record.
Engineering Practice Insights and Lessons
I have seen underpinning jobs go wrong in three ways, and this paper touches on all three.
First, the reaction system. The jacking force has to be resisted by something, and in underpinning work that something is usually the existing foundation itself. If the foundation is already cracked, the reaction force can make it worse. The jacking frame must be arranged so that the reaction is spread over a sufficient area of the foundation, and the foundation must be checked for the reaction force.
Second, the welding. On a small-diameter pipe pile, the welder is working in a pit, often in awkward positions, and the weld is a butt weld between two short pipe sections. If the welder is not competent, or if the pipe ends are not prepared properly, you get a weak splice. I have seen a pile splice fail during jacking, and the consequence is that the pile is stuck in the ground and the whole operation has to be rethought.
Third, the corrosion. A steel pipe pile in collapsible loess is not in a benign environment. Loess can be aggressive, and groundwater, even if deep, can migrate. The pipe should be protected, and the interior should be filled with concrete or grout. The paper does not dwell on this, but I would insist on it in any underpinning design.
The result reported in the paper is that the underpinning worked: the settlement was arrested and the fan foundation was stabilised. That is the outcome that matters, and it is a good outcome.
Summary and Study Reflection
This paper is a practical record of a job well done, and its value is in the details of the process control rather than in any theoretical novelty. The key lesson for me is that underpinning with steel pipe static pressure piles is a process-controlled method: the quality is built in during construction, not verified afterwards. The jacking force and penetration depth records are the quality evidence, and the welds at the splices are the hidden critical points. For collapsible loess and other weak soils, this method offers a quiet, reliable and effective way to stabilise a settling foundation, provided the design is matched to the geology and the construction is disciplined.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd