ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Theoretical Analysis and Experimental Study on Recycled Aggregate Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Stub Columns after High Temperature

Introduction and Background

The paper by Yang Youfu and Hou Rui from Dalian University of Technology addresses a topic that is becoming more relevant as the construction industry moves toward sustainability: the behaviour of concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) columns made with recycled aggregate concrete (RAC) after exposure to high temperature. The study combines experimental testing of stub columns after heating and cooling with a numerical analysis that develops a stress-strain model for the core recycled concrete, and then uses the model to study the effects of recycled coarse aggregate replacement ratio, peak temperature and confinement coefficient on the axial compressive strength.

From my perspective, this is a fire engineering problem with a sustainability twist. The steel tube provides confinement and fire protection to the concrete, and the concrete provides support and fire protection to the steel. When the concrete is made with recycled aggregate, its properties change, and the response to fire changes too. The paper quantifies those changes.

Experimental Program and Observed Behavior

The experimental program tested recycled aggregate concrete-filled steel tube stub columns under axial compression after exposure to high temperature. The variables were the recycled coarse aggregate replacement ratio and the peak temperature. The key observations were:

The last point is important and somewhat counterintuitive. A weaker core benefits more from confinement, so the steel tube is doing more work in a recycled aggregate CFST column than in a natural aggregate CFST column. This is a positive finding for the use of recycled aggregate in CFST.

Stress-Strain Model for Core Recycled Concrete after High Temperature

The paper proposes a stress-strain model for the core recycled concrete that accounts for the recycled coarse aggregate replacement ratio and the peak temperature. The model is based on the test results and is calibrated to the observed behaviour.

The model captures the key features of the concrete behaviour: the initial stiffness, the peak stress, the strain at peak stress, and the post-peak behaviour. The model shows that:

This is a useful model for engineers who need to assess the residual capacity of recycled aggregate CFST columns after a fire.

Numerical Analysis and Parametric Study

The numerical analysis used the proposed stress-strain model to calculate the load-deformation curves for the stub columns, and the results agreed well with the test results. The validated model was then used for a parametric study covering the recycled coarse aggregate replacement ratio, the peak temperature and the confinement coefficient.

The parametric study showed that:

Parameter Effect on Axial Compressive Strength Practical Implication
Recycled aggregate replacement ratio Higher ratio reduces strength The strength penalty is modest at low replacement ratios
Peak temperature Higher temperature reduces strength The strength loss is significant above 600°C
Confinement coefficient Higher coefficient increases strength The steel tube provides more confinement to a weaker core

The paper proposed a simplified formula for the axial compressive strength of recycled aggregate CFST stub columns after high temperature, and the simplified results agreed well with the test results. This is a practical contribution, because a simplified formula is what a design engineer needs.

Engineering Practice Insights and Lessons

From a practical standpoint, this research has implications for the fire design of CFST columns made with recycled aggregate concrete.

First, the strength loss after fire is significant, and it must be accounted for in the residual capacity assessment. A column that has been through a fire may have lost 20–40% of its capacity, depending on the peak temperature and the recycled aggregate content.

Second, the steel tube provides more confinement benefit to a recycled aggregate core than to a natural aggregate core. This means that a recycled aggregate CFST column is actually more robust in terms of confinement than a natural aggregate CFST column, even though its absolute strength is lower.

Third, the simplified formula proposed in the paper is useful for preliminary assessment, but it should be used with caution until it has been validated against a wider range of test data.

I have seen fire-damaged CFST columns in practice, and the assessment of residual capacity is always a challenge. The steel tube hides the concrete, so you cannot see the damage to the core. The approach in this paper, which develops a model for the core concrete behaviour based on the peak temperature, is the right approach. The practical challenge is knowing the peak temperature that the column actually experienced, which is not always easy to determine.

Summary and Study Reflection

This paper makes a valuable contribution to the understanding of recycled aggregate CFST columns after fire exposure. The experimental data are valuable, the stress-strain model is well-calibrated, and the simplified formula is practical. The key finding for me is that the steel tube provides more confinement benefit to a weaker recycled aggregate core, which means that recycled aggregate CFST columns are more robust than their natural aggregate counterparts in terms of confinement, even though their absolute strength is lower. The practical implication is that recycled aggregate can be used in CFST columns with a modest strength penalty, and the fire performance is not dramatically worse. The simplified formula is a useful tool for engineers, and I would recommend it for preliminary assessment while noting that more validation is needed.