Performance-Based Seismic Design of Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Frames
Overview of the Literature
This paper by Wang Wenda, Xia Xiuli and Shi Yanli, published in Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration in 2010, explores the application of performance-based seismic design (PBSD) to concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) frames. The authors review the background, concept and main content of PBSD, then systematically analyse the performance-based seismic philosophy and design methods for CFST structures. They discuss the application of displacement-based seismic design (DBSD) to CFST structures, including the determination of target displacement and the corresponding lateral displacement pattern. Using the SAP2000 software, they built a 12-storey CFST frame model and performed a static pushover analysis to evaluate the seismic performance indices of the structure under earthquake loading.
Core Technical Points and Interpretation
Performance-based seismic design represents a paradigm shift from traditional force-based design. Instead of designing a structure to resist a specified seismic force, PBSD designs the structure to achieve a specified performance level under a specified seismic hazard. The performance levels are typically defined in terms of damage states, such as immediate occupancy, life safety, and collapse prevention. The paper identifies the key steps in PBSD: establishing the performance objectives, selecting the seismic hazard levels, performing a nonlinear analysis to determine the structural response, and verifying that the response meets the performance objectives.
The application of PBSD to CFST frames is particularly relevant because CFST members exhibit excellent ductility and energy dissipation capacity, which makes them well-suited to performance-based design. The paper discusses the use of displacement-based design, where the design is based on the target displacement rather than the base shear. This approach is more direct for performance-based design because the displacement is directly related to the damage state. The paper also discusses the lateral displacement pattern, which is the distribution of lateral displacement over the height of the structure. For a CFST frame, the lateral displacement pattern is influenced by the flexural and shear deformations of the members, as well as the panel zone deformations in the beam-column connections.
The pushover analysis performed on the 12-storey model provides a practical demonstration of the method. The pushover curve, which plots base shear against roof displacement, shows the nonlinear behaviour of the structure as it progresses from elastic to inelastic response. The performance indices, such as the interstorey drift ratio and the plastic hinge rotation, are then evaluated at the target displacement to verify that the structure meets the performance objectives.
Integration with Engineering Practice
From a steel pipe perspective, the seismic performance of a CFST frame is directly influenced by the properties of the steel tube. The ductility of the CFST member is governed by the width-to-thickness ratio of the steel tube, the yield strength of the steel, and the confinement provided by the concrete core. In a high-seismic zone, the design code typically requires a compact section, which means a low width-to-thickness ratio, to ensure that the member can develop its full plastic moment capacity without local buckling. This requirement directly affects the wall thickness of the steel pipe, and therefore the cost and the manufacturing process.
I have supplied steel pipe for CFST frames in seismic zones, and the specification often requires a high-strength steel with a low yield-to-tensile ratio to ensure good ductility. The manufacturing process for such pipe must be carefully controlled to avoid any defects that could initiate a brittle fracture under cyclic loading. The welding of the longitudinal seam in LSAW pipe, for example, must be performed with a low heat input to minimise the width of the heat-affected zone and to reduce the residual stresses. The paper's discussion of the lateral displacement pattern is also relevant to the design of the beam-column connections. In a CFST frame, the beam is typically connected to the steel tube using a through-diaphragm or an external diaphragm, and the design of this connection must accommodate the expected rotation at the target displacement.
Key Questions and Reflections
One of the challenges in applying PBSD to CFST frames is the definition of the performance levels for the composite members. Unlike a reinforced concrete member, where the damage states are well-defined in terms of cracking and spalling, the damage states for a CFST member are less clear. The steel tube may yield, the concrete may crack, or the tube may locally buckle, and each of these damage states corresponds to a different performance level. The paper does not provide a definitive set of damage states for CFST members, which is a gap that needs to be addressed through further research.
Another practical issue is the modelling of the CFST member in a nonlinear analysis. The paper used SAP2000, which models the CFST member as a frame element with a plastic hinge at the ends. This approach does not capture the distributed plasticity that occurs in the member, nor does it capture the local buckling of the steel tube. For a more accurate analysis, a fibre element model or a shell element model would be required, but these are computationally intensive and not commonly used in practice.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper provides a comprehensive overview of the application of PBSD to CFST frames, and it serves as a useful reference for engineers who are designing CFST structures in seismic zones. The key takeaway is that the performance objectives must be clearly defined at the outset, and the design must be verified through a nonlinear analysis that captures the inelastic behaviour of the structure. The paper's demonstration of the pushover analysis on a 12-storey model provides a practical example of how the method can be applied, and it highlights the importance of selecting an appropriate lateral displacement pattern. For engineers involved in the design of CFST frames, this paper reinforces the need to consider the seismic performance of the structure from the perspective of the steel tube, which is a critical component of the composite system. The paper also highlights the need for further research on the definition of performance levels for CFST members, which is essential for the widespread application of PBSD to these structures.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd