Interface Bond Behaviour of Square Steel Tube Recycled Concrete after Fire Exposure - A Study Note
Why the Interface Is the Weak Link
Every CFST column I have ever inspected has taught me the same lesson: the steel-concrete interface is where the trouble starts. If the bond fails, the composite action that the designer assumed is gone, and the column becomes two independent elements - a steel tube and a concrete core - each carrying load on its own. That is a fundamentally different structural system from the one that was designed. This paper by Chen Zongping and his team at Guangxi University addresses the worst-case version of that problem: what happens to the bond when the column has been through a fire and the concrete is recycled concrete made with crushed old concrete as coarse aggregate. It is a double penalty, and the paper quantifies it.
What the Push-Out Tests Revealed
The team cast 20 specimens and subjected them to a push-out test after heating them to different maximum temperatures (T) and using different recycled coarse aggregate replacement rates (γ). The load-slip curves they obtained are the heart of the paper, and they fall into two distinct families.
| Maximum Temperature T | Bond Behaviour | Initial Slip Behaviour |
|---|---|---|
| T ≤ 200°C | Bond strength relatively stable; curves similar to ambient | Early initial slip at loading end |
| T ≥ 400°C | Bond strength drops then recovers as T increases; curves show different shape | Delayed initial bond damage at 600°C |
The overall bond performance of the recycled concrete specimens was worse than that of normal concrete specimens by a margin of approximately 3.10% to 19.05%. That is not a trivial gap. In a fire-damaged structure, a 19% loss of bond could be the difference between a column that can be repaired and a column that must be demolished.
The temperature effect is non-monotonic: bond strength and bond shear stiffness first decrease, then increase as the maximum experienced temperature rises. This is a classic result that anyone who has examined fire-damaged concrete will recognise. At moderate temperatures, the concrete loses moisture and micro-cracks develop, reducing bond. At higher temperatures, the concrete undergoes chemical changes - calcium hydroxide decomposes, and the microstructure densifies in some zones - which can actually improve the mechanical interlock at the interface. The paper's finding that interface energy dissipation capacity increases with temperature is consistent with this: the damaged concrete is more compliant, so it can absorb more energy before the bond fails.
The recycled aggregate replacement rate has a more complicated effect. Bond strength decreases steadily as γ increases, which is expected - recycled aggregate is weaker, more porous, and has a rougher surface that can trap air and reduce effective contact. But bond shear stiffness and interface energy dissipation both show a "first increase, then decrease, then slight recovery" pattern. That non-monotonic behaviour is worth noting, because it means the relationship between replacement rate and bond performance is not linear, and designers should not assume that a 30% replacement is simply "30% worse" than normal concrete.
Practical Implications for Fire-Damaged Structures
This paper has direct relevance to anyone who has to assess a fire-damaged building with CFST columns. The first question is always: what was the maximum temperature the column experienced? The second is: what is the condition of the bond? This paper gives you a way to estimate the answer to the second question if you can answer the first. The finding that initial bond damage is significantly delayed at T = 600°C is particularly interesting. It suggests that at 600°C, the concrete has undergone enough transformation that it resists initial slip better than at 400°C, even though its overall bond strength is not necessarily higher. That is a subtle but important distinction.
For the engineer assessing a fire-damaged structure, the practical takeaway is this: do not assume that a higher fire temperature automatically means a worse bond. The relationship is non-monotonic, and the assessment must be based on the actual temperature profile, not on a simple "hotter is worse" assumption. Also, if the concrete is recycled concrete, the bond is likely to be worse than for normal concrete, and the assessment should include a penalty factor.
What the Paper Does Not Say
The paper proposes a bond strength formula and a bond-slip constitutive equation, which is good. But it does not address the effect of the steel tube surface condition - whether the tube was painted, whether it had mill scale, whether it was cleaned before concrete placement. In my experience, the surface condition of the tube is one of the biggest variables in bond performance. A tube with loose mill scale will have a much lower bond than a tube that was wire-brushed or sandblasted. The paper also does not address the effect of concrete shrinkage, which is particularly relevant for recycled concrete because recycled aggregate tends to have higher shrinkage than natural aggregate. Shrinkage creates a gap at the interface, which reduces bond.
Concluding Assessment
This is a valuable paper because it addresses a real problem - fire-damaged CFST columns with recycled concrete - that is becoming more common as sustainability requirements push us towards recycled materials. The key findings are clear: bond performance is worse for recycled concrete, the temperature effect is non-monotonic, and the bond-slip constitutive equation provides a tool for assessment. For the practicing engineer, the message is: when you are assessing a fire-damaged CFST column, do not assume the bond is intact, and do not assume it is uniformly degraded. The interface is the weak link, and it needs to be inspected, tested, and quantified before you sign off on the repair. That is the lesson, and it is one I have learned the hard way on more than one occasion.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd