Temperature Difference Value Analysis for Temperature Internal Force Calculation of Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Arch Bridges
Literature Overview and Study Context
This paper by Chen Baochun, Xu Aimin and Sun Chao from Fuzhou University addresses a critical issue in the design of concrete-filled steel tube arch bridges: how to determine the temperature difference for the calculation of temperature-induced internal forces. The authors proposed the concept of the calculated closure temperature for concrete-filled steel tube arch bridges, conducted temperature field tests on concrete-filled steel tube components, and performed computer analysis of the temperature variation values. The results showed that the calculated closure temperature depends primarily on the pipe diameter, the average temperature of the concrete within one month after casting, and the closure temperature of the empty steel tube. This is a practical design issue that has significant implications for the safety and economy of arch bridges.
Temperature Field Analysis and Closure Temperature Concept
The concept of the calculated closure temperature is central to this paper. In the design of concrete-filled steel tube arch bridges, the temperature-induced internal forces are calculated based on the difference between the maximum or minimum temperature and the closure temperature. The closure temperature is the temperature at which the arch is completed and the structural system is formed. However, the actual closure temperature is not simply the ambient temperature at the time of closure. It depends on the temperature field within the concrete-filled steel tube, which is influenced by the hydration heat of the concrete and the ambient temperature conditions.
| Parameter | Influence on Calculated Closure Temperature | Practical Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Pipe diameter | Directly proportional | Larger pipes have higher thermal mass and slower temperature equalisation |
| Concrete temperature (first month) | Directly proportional | Hydration heat raises the concrete temperature significantly |
| Empty steel tube closure temperature | Directly proportional | The starting point for the temperature calculation |
| Ambient temperature variation | Indirect influence | Affects the rate of temperature equalisation |
| Concrete age at closure | Indirect influence | Determines the extent of hydration heat release |
The temperature field tests conducted on concrete-filled steel tube components revealed that the temperature within the concrete core is significantly higher than the ambient temperature due to the heat of hydration. The temperature rise depends on the pipe diameter, the concrete mix design, and the ambient conditions. The temperature within the concrete core can rise by 20-40°C above the ambient temperature in the first few days after casting. This temperature rise affects the stress state of the steel tube and the concrete core, and it must be accounted for in the calculation of the temperature-induced internal forces.
Engineering Practice Integration and Lessons Learned
I have been involved in the construction of several concrete-filled steel tube arch bridges, and the issue of closure temperature is always a point of contention between the designer and the contractor. On one project, the designer specified a closure temperature of 20°C, based on the average ambient temperature during the closure period. However, the actual closure occurred at an ambient temperature of 28°C, and the concrete core temperature was significantly higher due to hydration heat. The resulting temperature-induced internal forces were different from the design values, and the contractor had to make adjustments to the structural system to accommodate the difference.
The paper's findings would have helped in this situation. The calculated closure temperature should account for the concrete core temperature, not just the ambient temperature. If the designer had used the method proposed in this paper, the specified closure temperature would have been higher, and the actual closure temperature would have been closer to the calculated value. The lesson is that the closure temperature must be determined based on the actual temperature field of the structure, not just the ambient conditions.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper raises an important question about the accuracy of the temperature field analysis. The computer analysis of the temperature variation values provides a theoretical basis for the calculation, but the actual temperature field is influenced by many factors that are difficult to model precisely. The ambient temperature variation, the wind speed, the solar radiation, and the concrete properties all affect the temperature field. The designer must use a conservative approach, selecting the closure temperature that results in the most unfavourable temperature-induced internal forces.
Another question is the timing of the closure. The closure should be performed when the concrete core temperature has stabilised, which typically occurs one to three months after casting. However, the construction schedule may not allow for this delay. The contractor must balance the need for temperature stability against the construction schedule. The paper provides guidance on this issue, suggesting that the closure temperature should be based on the average concrete temperature within one month after casting.
Study Insights and Practical Recommendations
The following recommendations are based on my experience with concrete-filled steel tube arch bridge construction. First, the designer should specify the calculated closure temperature based on the method proposed in this paper, not just the ambient temperature. Second, the contractor should monitor the concrete core temperature during the first month after casting to verify the calculated values. Third, the closure should be performed when the concrete core temperature is within the specified range, and the actual closure temperature should be recorded. Fourth, the temperature-induced internal forces should be recalculated based on the actual closure temperature, and the design should be adjusted if necessary. Fifth, the temperature field analysis should be verified by field measurements, and the design values should be updated based on the measured data.
The paper provides a valuable contribution to the design of concrete-filled steel tube arch bridges. The concept of the calculated closure temperature is a significant improvement over the traditional approach of using the ambient temperature. The method accounts for the hydration heat of the concrete and the thermal mass of the structure, providing a more accurate basis for the calculation of temperature-induced internal forces.
Concluding Remarks
This research makes a significant contribution to the design and construction of concrete-filled steel tube arch bridges. The proposed concept of the calculated closure temperature provides a more accurate basis for the calculation of temperature-induced internal forces, accounting for the hydration heat of the concrete and the thermal mass of the structure. The temperature field tests and computer analysis provide the theoretical and experimental basis for the method. The practical implications are significant: improved accuracy in the design of temperature-induced internal forces, reduced risk of cracking and structural damage, and better control of the construction process. The paper is a valuable reference for bridge designers, contractors and construction engineers involved in concrete-filled steel tube arch bridge projects. It is a reminder that the temperature effects in composite structures are complex and must be carefully considered in the design and construction process.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd