ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Experimental Study on Axial Compressive Behavior of Square Concrete-Filled High-Strength Steel Tube Short Columns After High Temperature

Core Technical Content

The paper by Chen Zongping, Zhou Wenxiang, and Xu Jinjun from Guangxi University presents an experimental investigation into the axial compressive behavior of square concrete-filled high-strength steel tube (CFHST) short columns after exposure to high temperatures. The study involved 15 test specimens, with temperature and concrete strength as the varying parameters. The specimens were subjected to static loading tests after being heated to various temperatures, and their load-axial displacement curves were recorded.

The experimental results reveal two distinct failure modes: shear failure and waist drum failure. Shear failure is more likely to occur at lower temperatures, while waist drum failure becomes more prevalent at higher temperatures. The waist drum failure mode is characterized by outward bulging of the steel tube walls in the mid-height region, typically accompanied by crushing of the concrete core.

The study found that the bearing capacity and axial stiffness of the specimens change little when the temperature is below 400°C. However, above 400°C, both the bearing capacity and axial stiffness decrease rapidly. Specifically, when the temperature increases from room temperature to 200°C, 400°C, 600°C, and 800°C, the bearing capacity of the specimens is 101%, 105%, 76%, and 54% of that of the room-temperature specimens, respectively. The axial stiffness is 97%, 96%, 62%, and 51% of the room-temperature values, respectively.

The ultimate bearing capacity increases with the concrete strength grade. When the concrete grade is increased from C60 to C70 and C80, the average ultimate bearing capacity increases by 7% and 12%, respectively. The ductility coefficient, which is a measure of the specimen's ability to undergo inelastic deformation before failure, exhibits a non-monotonic relationship with temperature. It first decreases and then increases as the temperature rises. At 400°C, the ductility coefficient is 92% of the room-temperature value, while at 800°C, it is 123% of the room-temperature value. The effect of concrete strength on the ductility coefficient is not significant.

Engineering Practice Implications

The behavior of concrete-filled steel tube columns after exposure to high temperatures is a critical concern in fire safety engineering. When a structure is subjected to a fire, the steel tube and the concrete core are heated to different temperatures, leading to a complex interaction between the two components. The steel tube, being a good conductor of heat, reaches high temperatures quickly, while the concrete core, being a poor conductor, heats up more slowly. This differential heating can lead to a reduction in the bond strength between the steel tube and the concrete core, and to the development of thermal stresses that can cause cracking in the concrete.

From my experience in the steel pipe industry, I can attest that the selection of steel grade and concrete strength for CFST columns in fire-prone areas is a critical design decision. The paper's finding that the bearing capacity and axial stiffness decrease significantly above 400°C is consistent with the known behavior of both steel and concrete at elevated temperatures. The yield strength of structural steel decreases rapidly above 400°C, while the compressive strength of concrete also degrades, although at a slower rate.

The paper's observation that the failure mode changes from shear failure to waist drum failure as the temperature increases is particularly interesting. This shift can be attributed to the reduction in the steel tube's yield strength at high temperatures, which makes it more susceptible to local buckling. The concrete core, which has a lower thermal conductivity, retains more of its strength at elevated temperatures, but it is unable to prevent the local buckling of the steel tube once the tube's yield strength is significantly reduced.

Lessons and Reflections

The paper's finding that the bearing capacity and axial stiffness of the specimens change little below 400°C is reassuring, as it suggests that CFST columns can maintain their structural integrity in moderate fires. However, the rapid degradation above 400°C is a serious concern, and it highlights the need for adequate fire protection measures, such as the application of fire-resistant coatings or the use of fire-resistant concrete.

The paper also evaluates the applicability of existing design codes, including the Chinese code DBJ 13-51-2003 and the Japanese code AIJ (1997), by introducing material strength reduction factors. The results show that the calculated values from these codes agree well with the experimental values, indicating that these codes can be used for the design of CFST columns after fire exposure, provided that appropriate reduction factors are applied.

In my experience, the most common mistakes in the fire design of CFST columns include: (1) neglecting the effects of the concrete core on the temperature distribution in the steel tube; (2) using overly conservative material properties that do not reflect the actual behavior of the materials at elevated temperatures; and (3) failing to consider the effects of the fire scenario, such as the duration and intensity of the fire, on the structural response.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper provides valuable experimental data on the behavior of square CFHST short columns after exposure to high temperatures. The test results and the proposed design methodology are useful for engineers designing such columns in fire-prone areas. The paper also highlights the importance of considering the effects of temperature on the mechanical properties of both the steel and the concrete.

Looking ahead, I believe that further research is needed to: (1) extend the experimental database to include columns with different cross-sectional shapes, such as circular and rectangular; (2) investigate the behavior of CFST columns under combined axial and lateral loading after fire exposure; (3) study the effects of fire on the long-term behavior of CFST columns, including the effects of creep and shrinkage of the concrete core; and (4) develop more refined analytical models that can capture the complex interactions between the steel tube and the concrete core at elevated temperatures.

For engineers in the field, I recommend using this paper as a reference for understanding the fundamental behavior of CFST columns after fire exposure. However, I would emphasize that the design of such columns should always be based on a thorough understanding of the fire scenario and the structural behavior, and that the design should be verified through detailed analysis and, where possible, experimental testing.