ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Seismic Fragility Analysis of Buried Steel Pipes in Liquefiable Sites

1. The Problem and Why It Matters

The paper by Liang Zetian, Zheng Shansuo, Liu Xiaohang, Wu Xingxia and Yang Feng addresses a critical issue for the design of buried steel pipelines in seismic zones. Buried pipelines are the lifelines of modern infrastructure, and their failure during an earthquake can have severe consequences, including loss of water supply, gas supply, and communication services. In liquefiable sites, the problem is compounded by the fact that the soil loses its strength and stiffness during the earthquake, and the pipeline can be subjected to additional loads from the liquefaction-induced ground deformation and the buoyancy force from the liquefied soil. The paper focuses on the seismic fragility analysis of buried steel pipelines in liquefiable sites, which is a topic that has received relatively little attention compared to the seismic analysis of above-ground structures. The use of a nonlinear constitutive model for the soil, combined with a pore pressure increment model, is a significant step forward in capturing the complex behaviour of liquefiable soils. The development of a user-defined material subroutine (UMAT) for the ABAQUS finite element platform is a valuable contribution, because it allows the soil behaviour to be modelled more accurately than with conventional models. The validation of the model against shaking table test results is particularly important, because it gives confidence that the numerical model can be used for parametric studies.

2. The UMAT Model and Its Validation

The paper uses the Matasović nonlinear constitutive model, which is a well-established model for describing the nonlinear stress-strain behaviour of soils, and couples it with the Byrne-modified Martin pore pressure increment model to capture the liquefaction behaviour. The UMAT subroutine is developed for ABAQUS, which is a widely used finite element platform in both research and industry. The validation against shaking table test results is a critical step, because it demonstrates that the numerical model can reproduce the observed behaviour of the soil-pipeline system. The paper reports that the numerical results are in good agreement with the experimental results, which gives confidence in the model's ability to predict the seismic response of buried pipelines in liquefiable sites. From a practical standpoint, the UMAT model is a useful tool for engineers who need to assess the seismic vulnerability of existing pipelines or design new pipelines in liquefiable sites. However, the model is complex, and it requires careful calibration of the input parameters. In practice, this means that the use of such a model is limited to projects where the soil properties are well characterised and where the design team has the expertise to run such analyses. The paper also discusses the creation of a pipe-soil contact model that combines the features of a solid nonlinear contact model and a shell-equivalent soil spring model. This hybrid approach is a practical compromise that allows the soil-pipeline interaction to be captured without the computational cost of a fully nonlinear solid model. The use of this model for incremental dynamic analysis is a significant step forward, because it allows the seismic response of the pipeline to be evaluated over a range of ground motion intensities.

3. Fragility Analysis and Key Findings

The paper presents the results of seismic fragility analysis for buried steel pipelines in liquefiable sites, considering different liquefaction zone lengths and different burial depths. The fragility curves are developed for three limit states, which are defined based on the pipeline damage criteria. The key finding is that the probability of exceeding a given limit state increases with the length of the liquefaction zone and with the burial depth. This is a significant finding, because it suggests that pipelines in liquefiable sites are more vulnerable when the liquefaction zone is longer and when the pipeline is buried deeper. The physical explanation is that a longer liquefaction zone results in a larger length of the pipeline being subjected to the liquefaction-induced ground deformation, and a deeper burial depth results in a larger overburden pressure and a larger buoyancy force. The finding that the burial depth has a significant effect on the fragility is particularly important, because it suggests that the common practice of burying pipelines deeper to protect them from surface loads may actually increase their vulnerability to liquefaction-induced damage. This is a counterintuitive result that should be carefully considered in the design of pipelines in liquefiable sites. The paper also provides an analytical fragility model that relates the pipeline damage index to the ground motion intensity, which can be used for rapid seismic risk assessment.

4. Practical Lessons for Manufacturing and Delivery

From a manufacturing and delivery perspective, this paper highlights several important points. The first is that the pipeline material properties are critical to the seismic performance. The steel pipe must have sufficient ductility and toughness to accommodate the large deformations that can occur during liquefaction. In our plants, we use a combination of chemical composition control and mechanical testing to ensure that the pipe meets the required ductility and toughness. The Charpy impact test is particularly important, because it provides a measure of the material's ability to absorb energy without fracture. The second point is that the pipe wall thickness and diameter must be selected based on the expected seismic loads, not just the internal pressure. In liquefiable sites, the pipe may be subjected to significant bending and axial loads, and the wall thickness must be sufficient to prevent buckling and to accommodate the expected strains. The third point is that the pipe coating and corrosion protection must be designed to withstand the soil conditions, including the potential for liquefaction-induced soil movement. In our projects, we have seen cases where the pipe coating was damaged by soil movement, leading to corrosion and premature failure. The fourth point is that the pipe joints must be designed to accommodate the expected deformations. In liquefiable sites, the use of flexible joints or expansion joints may be necessary to prevent the pipe from being overstressed. This is a design decision that should be made early in the project, because it affects the pipe manufacturing and the joint fabrication.

5. Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises several questions that we should consider in our own work. What is the effect of the pipe material grade on the seismic fragility? The paper appears to use a single material grade, but in practice, pipelines are manufactured in a range of grades, and the material properties can significantly affect the seismic performance. A higher grade pipe may have a higher yield strength but a lower ductility, which could make it more vulnerable to brittle fracture. This is a trade-off that needs to be carefully considered. What is the effect of the pipe diameter on the seismic fragility? The paper does not appear to address this, but in practice, large-diameter pipes are more vulnerable to buckling and to the effects of soil movement than small-diameter pipes. This is because the moment of inertia of the pipe increases with the fourth power of the diameter, but the soil resistance also increases, and the net effect is not always clear. What is the effect of the pipeline internal pressure on the seismic fragility? The paper does not appear to address this, but in practice, pipelines are often operated at high internal pressures, and the internal pressure can affect the pipe's ability to accommodate external loads. A high internal pressure can increase the pipe's stiffness and reduce its ability to deform, which could increase the risk of failure. These are important questions that need to be addressed in future research.

6. Study Insights and Outlook

This paper provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of the seismic fragility of buried steel pipelines in liquefiable sites. The development of the UMAT model and its validation against shaking table test results is a significant achievement, and the fragility analysis provides practical insights into the effects of liquefaction zone length and burial depth on the seismic vulnerability. The key finding that a longer liquefaction zone and a deeper burial depth increase the vulnerability is important for the design of pipelines in liquefiable sites. The paper also provides an analytical fragility model that can be used for rapid seismic risk assessment. From a practical standpoint, the paper reinforces the importance of material selection, pipe design, and joint design in ensuring the seismic performance of buried pipelines. The next time we design a pipeline in a liquefiable site, we will have a better understanding of the factors that affect its seismic vulnerability, and we will be more careful in our material selection and design decisions. The paper is a useful reference for engineers who work in this field, and it should be included in our internal design guidelines. The industry needs more research like this, and we need to work with the research community to develop comprehensive design methods that can be incorporated into national and international codes. The ultimate goal is to ensure that our pipelines are safe and reliable, even in the most challenging seismic environments.