Spatial Stability Analysis of Long-Span Concrete-Filled Steel Tubular Arch Bridges
The Analytical Framework and Its Significance
This paper by Yang Meiliang, Li Chuanxi, Zhao Bing, and Zuo Xindai from Changsha University of Science and Technology presents a spatial stability analysis method for long-span CFST arch bridges. The authors use finite element theory, considering both geometric nonlinearity and material nonlinearity, to establish a computational model for a half-through CFST arch bridge. They use ANSYS software to simulate the stability of the bridge during both the construction process and the service stage, providing theoretical basis for the design and construction of the bridge.
The significance of this paper lies in its recognition that stability analysis of CFST arch bridges is not a linear elastic problem. For long-span arches, the geometric nonlinearity caused by large deformations and the material nonlinearity caused by concrete cracking and steel yielding can significantly reduce the stability safety factor compared to a linear elastic analysis. The paper's approach of considering both nonlinearities is the correct way to analyze these structures, and it is a lesson that many designers and fabricators overlook.
For the steel pipe fabricator, the stability analysis has direct implications for the manufacturing tolerances and erection procedures of the arch ribs. The stability safety factor is sensitive to initial geometric imperfections, such as out-of-roundness of the pipe sections, misalignment of the rib segments, and deviations from the designed arch shape. These imperfections can be introduced during manufacturing, transportation, or erection, and they can reduce the stability safety factor by 10% to 20% or more.
Steel Tube Fabrication and Arch Rib Construction
The arch ribs of a CFST bridge are typically fabricated from large-diameter steel pipe, either LSAW or spiral welded. For long-span bridges, the pipe diameter can range from 800 mm to 1500 mm, and the wall thickness can range from 16 mm to 40 mm or more. The steel grade is typically Q345, Q370, or Q420.
The fabrication of these ribs involves several steps that directly affect the stability of the bridge:
- Pipe manufacturing: The pipe must be manufactured to tight dimensional tolerances. The out-of-roundness should be within 1% of the outside diameter, and the wall thickness tolerance should be within ±5% of the nominal wall thickness. If the pipe is out-of-round, the rib section has a reduced moment of inertia, which reduces the bending stiffness and the stability safety factor.
- Rib segment fabrication: The arch rib is typically divided into segments for fabrication and erection. Each segment is a curved pipe section, formed by cold or hot bending. The curvature must match the designed arch shape within a tight tolerance. If the curvature deviates from the design, the rib will have initial geometric imperfections that reduce the stability safety factor.
- Segment assembly: The segments are assembled on the ground or on a fabrication platform, and the circumferential butt welds are made. The misalignment between segments must be controlled to within 1 mm or 10% of the wall thickness, whichever is smaller. If the misalignment is excessive, the rib will have a kink at the joint, which is a geometric imperfection that reduces stability.
- Weld quality: The longitudinal seams and circumferential butt welds must be 100% UT inspected. The weld profile should be smooth, with no undercut or excessive reinforcement. Undercut is a stress concentration that can initiate fatigue cracks under service loading, and excessive reinforcement increases the local stress at the weld toe.
- Surface treatment: The external surface of the pipe should be free from rust, scale, and weld spatter. The internal surface should be clean and dry before concrete filling. If the internal surface has rust or scale, the bond between the steel and the concrete is reduced, and the composite action is compromised.
Construction Sequence and Its Effect on Stability
The paper's focus on the construction process is particularly important. For a CFST arch bridge, the construction sequence is typically:
- Erect the arch ribs as steel tubes (empty or partially filled).
- Pump concrete into the arch ribs from the springing to the crown.
- Erect the deck and hangers.
- Install the deck pavement and other dead loads.
During each stage, the stability of the structure changes. The most critical stage is often during concrete filling, when the arch ribs are partially filled and the structure is at its most flexible. The concrete filling sequence must be carefully planned to avoid excessive deformation or instability.
In my experience, the following construction issues can affect stability:
- Concrete filling sequence: The concrete should be pumped from both springings simultaneously, progressing toward the crown. If one side is filled before the other, the arch will have an asymmetric load, which can cause lateral deformation and reduce stability.
- Concrete filling pressure: The pumping pressure should be controlled to avoid excessive expansion of the steel tube. If the pressure is too high, the tube can bulge, causing local buckling or out-of-roundness. The maximum pumping pressure should be limited to prevent the hoop stress in the tube from exceeding the yield strength.
- Temperature effects: The concrete filling generates heat of hydration, which can cause thermal expansion of the steel tube. If the temperature rise is excessive, the tube can deform, and the residual stresses can reduce the stability safety factor. The concrete mix should be designed to minimize the heat of hydration, and the filling should be done in cool weather if possible.
- Erection sequence: The arch rib segments should be erected in a sequence that maintains the stability of the partial structure. If the segments are erected in the wrong order, the partial structure can become unstable, and the rib can collapse.
Lessons for Fabricators and Erection Teams
The paper's emphasis on both geometric and material nonlinearity is a reminder that stability analysis is not just about the final structure - it is about every stage of construction. For the fabricator, this means that the manufacturing tolerances must be tight enough to ensure that the initial geometric imperfections are within the limits assumed in the stability analysis.
In my experience, the following practical lessons are important:
- Initial imperfection control: The initial geometric imperfections of the arch rib should be measured and recorded after fabrication. The maximum deviation from the designed shape should be within L/5000, where L is the span of the arch. If the deviation exceeds this limit, the stability safety factor can be reduced by more than 10%.
- Weld shrinkage compensation: The circumferential butt welds between rib segments cause shrinkage, which can change the arch shape. The fabricator should compensate for this shrinkage by making the segments slightly longer than the design length. The amount of compensation should be determined by trial and error or by finite element analysis.
- Concrete filling monitoring: During concrete filling, the deformation of the arch rib should be monitored using total stations or strain gauges. If the deformation exceeds the predicted value, the filling should be stopped, and the cause should be investigated.
- Stability safety factor verification: After the bridge is completed, the stability safety factor should be verified by load testing. The measured deformation and stress should be compared with the predicted values from the finite element analysis. If the measured values exceed the predicted values by more than 10%, the stability safety factor should be re-evaluated.
In summary, this paper provides a comprehensive framework for the spatial stability analysis of long-span CFST arch bridges. The consideration of both geometric and material nonlinearity is essential for accurate stability prediction. For the steel pipe fabricator, the key takeaways are: control the dimensional tolerances of the pipe sections, compensate for weld shrinkage, monitor the concrete filling process, and verify the stability safety factor by load testing. These are the practical steps that ensure the bridge is stable during construction and service.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd