Creep Behaviour of Concrete-Filled Steel Tubes under Strength Grade and Temperature Variations: A Shop-Floor Reading
Literature Overview
This paper by Ma Jiaojiao, Zhang Rongling and colleagues at Lanzhou Jiaotong University addresses a question I have seen come up again and again on composite structure projects: what actually drives the long-term creep of a concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) column, and how much do the concrete grade and the service temperature really matter. The work is published in Concrete (2019, No. 3, pp. 23-26) and is supported by several national and provincial programmes. The authors ran a controlled experimental programme on short CFST specimens, 140 mm in outside diameter, 350 mm long, with a 3.0 mm wall thickness, under a sustained axial load of 235.3 kN, and they varied the concrete strength grade (C45, C80, C120) and the temperature regime (room at 15±2 °C, high at 60±2 °C, and variable cycling between 10 and 50 °C). The expansion agent dosage was fixed at 8%. The measured parameter was the creep degree, which is the creep strain per unit stress.
For a man who has spent decades signing off on composite columns for high-rise towers, bridge piers and industrial structures, this is exactly the kind of data you want before you commit to a section size and a concrete mix. The test matrix is modest but well conceived, and the findings are directly usable.
Key Findings and Their Engineering Meaning
The authors report four main results. First, the higher the concrete strength grade, the lower the creep degree, but the reduction is not proportional to the strength increase. Second, the influence of temperature on creep ranks, from largest to smallest, as variable temperature, high temperature, and room temperature. Third, the dominant factors behind both the strength-grade effect and the temperature effect are the water-to-binder ratio and the elastic modulus of the concrete. Fourth, the authors propose a fitted calculation formula for creep degree and verify it against the test data with acceptable error.
Let me unpack each of these in the way I would brief a young engineer on site.
Strength Grade and Creep Degree
The trend is intuitive: a higher-grade concrete has a lower water-to-binder ratio, a denser microstructure, and a higher elastic modulus, so it deforms less under sustained load. But the non-proportionality is the practical point. Going from C45 to C80 gives a large drop in creep, but going from C80 to C120 gives a much smaller additional drop. This tells us that for a given structural demand, there is an economic ceiling to chasing creep performance by raising the concrete grade. Beyond a certain point you are paying for cement and admixtures that buy you very little in terms of long-term deformation control. In my experience, this is the kind of insight that saves a project real money, because the temptation is always to specify a high-grade concrete to be safe, and the cost difference between C80 and C120 in a large volume placement is not trivial.
Temperature Regime and Creep Degree
The ranking of variable temperature > high temperature > room temperature is the result that should make every structural engineer pause. A constant high temperature of 60 °C increases creep relative to room temperature, but a cycling temperature between 10 and 50 °C produces the largest creep of all. This is the classic thermal-mechanical coupling effect: repeated temperature swings cause internal microcracking and moisture migration in the concrete, which accelerates the time-dependent deformation. In a real structure, a bridge pier in a continental climate or an industrial column near a furnace is not sitting at a constant temperature; it is cycling daily and seasonally. If you design against a constant high temperature, you will underestimate the creep. The paper gives you the ranking, and the ranking tells you where to spend your design margin.
Water-to-Binder Ratio and Elastic Modulus
The authors identify these two parameters as the root causes. This is consistent with what I have seen in practice. The water-to-binder ratio controls the porosity and the amount of unhydrated cement, and the elastic modulus controls the instantaneous stiffness that the concrete contributes to the composite section. A lower water-to-binder ratio and a higher elastic modulus both reduce the creep strain. For the steel tube itself, the creep of the concrete is what drives the long-term redistribution of stress between the steel and the concrete, and that redistribution affects the serviceability limit state and, in some cases, the ultimate capacity of slender columns.
The Fitted Formula
The authors propose a calculation formula for creep degree and validate it against their own test data. The validation shows acceptable agreement, but I would caution against applying it directly to a different steel grade, a different expansion agent dosage, or a different tube diameter-to-wall-thickness ratio. The formula is calibrated on a specific geometry and a specific load level. It is a useful starting point, but for a real design you should either run your own creep tests on the actual mix and section, or use a more general model such as the ACI 209 or CEB-FIP approach with the appropriate correction factors.
Practical Implications for Design and Construction
This is where I want to draw on my own experience. In composite column design, the creep of the concrete core is not just an academic concern; it directly affects the serviceability limit state, the long-term deflection of the structure, and the stress distribution between the steel tube and the concrete. If you ignore creep, you will overestimate the stiffness of the column and underestimate the long-term shortening. In a tall building, that can mean the difference between a floor that is level and a floor that is visibly sagging after five years.
What I Would Do Differently
If I were specifying a CFST column for a project with a significant temperature variation, I would do three things. First, I would not rely solely on the concrete grade to control creep; I would also look at the aggregate type and the cement type, because a low-heat cement or a well-graded aggregate can reduce creep more than an extra 20 MPa of strength. Second, I would design the section so that the steel tube carries a larger share of the sustained load, because the steel does not creep in the same way and a higher steel ratio reduces the overall time-dependent deformation. Third, I would specify a creep test on the actual mix, not just a compressive strength test, because the correlation between strength and creep is not tight enough to rely on for a serviceability-critical member.
What the Paper Does Not Tell You
The paper does not cover the effect of the tube diameter-to-wall-thickness ratio, the loading age of the concrete, or the shrinkage of the concrete before loading. In a real project, the concrete is loaded at different ages, and the creep is very sensitive to the age at first loading. A column that is loaded at 7 days will creep much more than one loaded at 28 days. The paper also does not address the effect of the expansion agent beyond the fixed 8% dosage, and the interaction between the expansion agent and the creep behaviour is not fully explored. These are gaps that a designer should be aware of.
Study Insights and Reflection
The real value of this paper, in my view, is not the specific numbers but the confirmation of a principle that I have seen borne out on site many times: the long-term behaviour of a composite member is governed by the concrete, and the concrete is governed by its mix design and its environment. The steel tube is a very effective confinement device, but it cannot stop the concrete from creeping. What it does is redistribute the stress and, in many cases, hide the creep from the naked eye, which is dangerous because the structure can be deforming slowly and nobody notices until the finishes crack.
The finding that variable temperature is worse than constant high temperature is the one I would highlight in a design review. It is a counterintuitive result that most engineers would not expect, and it has direct consequences for structures in climates with large diurnal or seasonal temperature swings. I have seen composite columns in industrial plants near furnaces and in cold regions, and the creep behaviour is noticeably different. This paper gives a quantitative basis for that observation.
Concluding Remarks
This is a well-executed experimental study that provides useful data on the creep of concrete-filled steel tubes under combined strength-grade and temperature variations. The key takeaways for a practising engineer are: higher concrete grade reduces creep but with diminishing returns; variable temperature is the most severe thermal condition for creep; and the water-to-binder ratio and elastic modulus are the controlling parameters. The fitted formula is a convenient tool for preliminary estimates, but it should be validated against the specific mix and geometry of the actual project. For any serviceability-critical composite column, I would recommend a dedicated creep test on the production mix and a design that does not rely on a single conservative assumption about temperature. The paper is a solid contribution to the literature and a useful reference for anyone designing composite structures in demanding thermal environments.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd