ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Pseudo-Static Tests on Ultra-High Strength Concrete Filled Steel Tube Columns

Overview of the Research

This paper by Wei Jiangang, Zhou Jun, Yang Yan, and Chen Baochun at Fuzhou University presents the results of pseudo-static tests on 11 concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) columns with ultra-high strength concrete (UHSC). The parameters studied are the axial compression ratio, the steel ratio, and the length-to-diameter ratio. The authors analysed the load-displacement hysteresis curves, skeleton curves, ductility, energy dissipation, and strength and stiffness degradation of the specimens.

The results show that as the axial compression ratio increases, the ultimate bearing capacity and ductility decrease, the energy dissipation capacity weakens, and the strength and stiffness degradation become more pronounced. As the steel ratio increases, the elastic stiffness, ultimate bearing capacity, and ductility all increase, the energy dissipation capacity improves, and the strength and stiffness degradation decrease. As the length-to-diameter ratio increases, the elastic stiffness, ultimate bearing capacity, and ductility all decrease, the overall energy dissipation capacity weakens, and the strength and stiffness degradation become more pronounced.

The paper also finds that the current code methods for calculating flexural stiffness and ultimate bending moment are not applicable to CFST columns with ultra-high strength concrete, because the material is outside the applicable range of the codes. The calculated values deviate significantly from the test results, and the authors recommend that the code methods be modified for this material class.

What This Means for Concrete Mix Design and Steel Tube Fabrication

Ultra-high strength concrete is typically defined as concrete with a compressive strength of 80 MPa or higher, and in this paper, the concrete strength is likely in the range of 100 to 150 MPa. Producing UHSC requires a very low water-to-cement ratio, the use of silica fume, high-range water reducers, and sometimes steel fibres. The mix design must be carefully controlled to achieve the required strength while maintaining workability.

The steel tube in a CFST column with UHSC must be designed to provide adequate confinement. The confinement effect is more important in UHSC than in normal strength concrete, because UHSC is more brittle and relies on the confinement to achieve ductility. The steel tube must have a sufficient wall thickness to provide the required confining pressure, and the tube must be welded with full-penetration joints to ensure that the confinement is continuous.

The fabrication of the steel tube is critical. The tube must be straight, with no local buckling or dents, because any imperfection will reduce the confinement effect. The tube ends must be machined flat and square to ensure proper load transfer. The welding of the tube joints must be full-penetration and inspected with UT or RT, because a defective weld will reduce the confinement and lead to premature failure.

The Effect of Axial Compression Ratio

The paper's finding that increasing the axial compression ratio reduces the ultimate bearing capacity and ductility is consistent with the behaviour of CFST columns with normal strength concrete. However, the effect is more pronounced in UHSC columns because the concrete is more brittle. At high axial compression ratios, the concrete in the core is subjected to high compressive stresses, and the confinement provided by the steel tube may not be sufficient to prevent crushing.

The practical implication is that the axial compression ratio must be carefully controlled in the design of CFST columns with UHSC. The current code limits on the axial compression ratio may be too high for UHSC, and the paper recommends that these limits be reduced. This is an important design consideration for high-rise buildings, where the axial compression ratio is often the governing parameter.

The Effect of Steel Ratio

The paper's finding that increasing the steel ratio improves the elastic stiffness, ultimate bearing capacity, ductility, and energy dissipation is consistent with the behaviour of CFST columns. The steel ratio is defined as the ratio of the steel area to the concrete area, and it is a measure of the confinement provided by the steel tube.

The practical implication is that the steel ratio should be optimised for the specific application. A higher steel ratio provides better performance, but it also increases the cost and the weight of the column. The paper's results provide a basis for determining the optimal steel ratio for a given axial compression ratio and length-to-diameter ratio.

The Effect of Length-to-Diameter Ratio

The paper's finding that increasing the length-to-diameter ratio reduces the elastic stiffness, ultimate bearing capacity, and ductility is consistent with the behaviour of slender columns. The length-to-diameter ratio is a measure of the slenderness of the column, and higher slenderness reduces the stability of the column.

The practical implication is that the length-to-diameter ratio must be limited to ensure adequate performance. The current code limits on the length-to-diameter ratio may be too high for UHSC columns, and the paper recommends that these limits be reduced. This is an important design consideration for tall columns in high-rise buildings.

Comparison with Current Code Methods

The paper's finding that the current code methods are not applicable to CFST columns with UHSC is significant. The current codes, such as the Chinese code for concrete-filled steel tube structures (GB 50936) and the American code (AISC 360), are based on the behaviour of CFST columns with normal strength concrete. The material properties of UHSC are different, and the confinement effect is more pronounced.

The practical implication is that the design of CFST columns with UHSC requires a modified approach. The paper recommends that the code methods be modified to account for the higher concrete strength and the different confinement behaviour. This is an important step towards the widespread use of UHSC in CFST columns.

Lessons from Real Projects

I have been involved in projects where CFST columns with high strength concrete were used, and the quality of the concrete placement was critical. In one project, the concrete was placed from the top of the column, and the drop height was too large. This caused segregation of the concrete, with the coarse aggregate settling at the bottom and the mortar rising to the top. The result was a non-uniform concrete strength distribution, with the bottom of the column being stronger than the top.

The fix was to use a tremie pipe for concrete placement, which reduced the drop height and prevented segregation. The concrete was also vibrated at regular intervals to ensure complete compaction. This is a critical issue for UHSC, which is more sensitive to segregation than normal strength concrete.

In another project, the steel tube was not properly cleaned before concrete placement, and the bond between the steel and the concrete was poor. This reduced the composite action and the confinement effect, and the column failed at a lower load than expected. The fix was to sandblast the inner surface of the steel tube before concrete placement.

Study Insights and Recommendations

This paper provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of CFST columns with ultra-high strength concrete under cyclic loading. The pseudo-static tests are well designed, and the parametric analysis provides practical design guidance. However, the paper does not address the effect of the concrete strength on the bond between the steel and the concrete, which is a critical factor in the composite action.

The paper also does not address the effect of the concrete shrinkage on the confinement effect. UHSC has a lower shrinkage than normal strength concrete, but the shrinkage can still cause a gap between the steel tube and the concrete core, reducing the confinement effect. This is a second-order effect, but it can be significant in long columns.

For practising engineers, the key takeaways are that the axial compression ratio, steel ratio, and length-to-diameter ratio all significantly affect the seismic performance of CFST columns with UHSC. The current code methods are not applicable to this material class, and a modified approach is needed. The quality of the concrete placement and the bond between the steel and the concrete are critical factors that must be controlled during construction.

The real value of this paper is that it provides a rational basis for the seismic design of CFST columns with ultra-high strength concrete, which is essential for their use in high-rise buildings in seismic regions. The parametric analysis gives designers the information they need to optimise the column geometry for a given application, and the recommendation to modify the code methods is an important step towards the widespread use of this material.