ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Calculation Method for Equivalent Slenderness Ratio of Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Lattice Columns with Flat Lacing Tubes

Overview and Research Context

This paper by Yan Qiaoling, Chen Baochun, and Xue Jianyang addresses a fundamental design issue for a specific type of structural member: the concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) lattice column with flat lacing tubes. Lattice columns are used in bridges, transmission towers, and other structures where a large load-bearing capacity is required with a relatively small cross-section. The column consists of two or more main chords (in this case, CFST members) that are connected by lacing elements (in this case, flat lacing tubes). The lacing tubes provide lateral stability and ensure that the chords act together as a single column.

The key design parameter for a lattice column is the equivalent slenderness ratio, which accounts for the additional flexibility of the column due to the shear deformation of the lacing system. The existing calculation methods for the equivalent slenderness ratio are based on assumptions that may not be valid for all configurations. The authors analyze the existing methods, compare their predictions with test results, and propose a new method that is more accurate and simpler to use.

Key Technical Findings and Interpretation

Analysis of Existing Calculation Methods

The authors first analyze the assumptions and formulas of the existing calculation methods for the equivalent slenderness ratio of CFST lattice columns with flat lacing tubes. They find that the existing methods have some unreasonable assumptions, particularly regarding the contribution of the lacing tubes to the shear stiffness of the column. The existing methods typically treat the lacing system as a continuous shear member, which is a reasonable approximation for columns with many lacing panels, but not for columns with few lacing panels or with lacing tubes that are not rigidly connected to the chords.

Comparison with Test Results

The authors compare the ultimate bearing capacities calculated using the existing methods with the results of experimental tests. They find that the existing methods can be either conservative or unconservative, depending on the configuration of the column. This is a significant finding because it means that the existing methods may not be reliable for all cases. For a veteran like me, this is a red flag. If a design method can be unconservative, it means that the structure may be under-designed, which could lead to failure. The authors correctly identify this as a problem and set out to develop a better method.

Development of a New Calculation Method

The authors propose a new calculation method that is based on the shear flexibility theory of lattice columns. They analyze the deformation of the column and identify the contributions of the different components to the total shear deformation. They find that the existing methods overestimate the contribution of the lacing tubes to the shear stiffness, which leads to an underestimation of the equivalent slenderness ratio and, consequently, an overestimation of the ultimate bearing capacity. The new method uses a simplified formula for the shear flexibility of the lacing system that takes into account the joint configuration parameters. The authors then fit a relationship between the amplification factor and the shear coefficient, which allows the equivalent slenderness ratio to be calculated directly.

Validation of the New Method

The authors validate the new method by comparing its predictions with the test results. They find that the new method, when used with the stability coefficient calculation method from GB 50923-2013, gives results that agree well with the test results. The new method is simple, practical, and has sufficient accuracy. This is a significant improvement over the existing methods, which were either too conservative or too unconservative.

Engineering Practice Implications

Design of Lattice Columns

The new method provides a reliable way to calculate the equivalent slenderness ratio of CFST lattice columns with flat lacing tubes. This is important for the design of these columns because the equivalent slenderness ratio determines the stability coefficient, which in turn determines the ultimate bearing capacity. An accurate calculation method ensures that the column is neither over-designed (wasting material) nor under-designed (risking failure).

Fabrication and Construction Considerations

The paper highlights the importance of the joint configuration parameters in the shear flexibility of the lacing system. This means that the fabrication of the lacing tubes and their connection to the chords must be done to tight tolerances. If the lacing tubes are not properly aligned or if the joints are not rigid, the shear stiffness of the lacing system will be reduced, and the column will be more flexible than designed. This could lead to a reduction in the ultimate bearing capacity. For those of us who fabricate these columns, this means that the welding of the lacing tubes to the chords must be done carefully, with proper fit-up and weld quality.

Inspection and Quality Control

The paper also implies that the inspection of the lacing system is important. The lacing tubes must be inspected for weld quality, alignment, and dimensional accuracy. If a lacing tube is missing or damaged, the shear stiffness of the column will be reduced, and the column may not perform as designed. This is particularly important for columns in structures where the lacing system is not accessible for inspection after construction.

Critical Assessment and Reflections

What the Paper Does Well

The paper does a good job of identifying the shortcomings of the existing calculation methods and developing a new method that is more accurate. The comparison with test results is thorough, and the new method is validated against a range of configurations. The new method is also simpler to use than the existing methods, which is a practical advantage for designers.

What the Paper Does Not Address

The paper does not address the effect of the lacing tube spacing on the shear stiffness of the column. In practice, the lacing tubes are spaced at regular intervals, and the spacing can affect the shear deformation. The paper assumes that the lacing system is continuous, which may not be accurate for columns with large lacing spacing. The paper also does not address the effect of the lacing tube diameter on the shear stiffness. A larger diameter lacing tube will provide more shear stiffness, but the paper does not provide a formula for this effect.

Practical Lessons from the Shop Floor

I have seen the importance of the lacing system in practice. In one project, a lattice column for a transmission tower was fabricated with lacing tubes that were not properly aligned with the chords. The lacing tubes were welded with a gap between the tube and the chord, which reduced the shear stiffness of the column. The column was found to be more flexible than designed, and the ultimate bearing capacity was reduced. The fix was to re-fabricate the column with proper alignment and fit-up. This is exactly the kind of problem that the paper addresses, and it shows that the lacing system must be fabricated with care.

Study Insights and Implications for Pipe Manufacturing

For those of us who manufacture the CFST chords and the lacing tubes for these columns, the paper has several implications:

In summary, this paper is a valuable contribution to the design of CFST lattice columns with flat lacing tubes. It identifies the shortcomings of the existing calculation methods and proposes a new method that is more accurate and simpler to use. The new method is validated against test results and is shown to be reliable. For the pipe industry, the paper reinforces the importance of fabrication quality and the need to consider the lacing system in the design of lattice columns.

The practical takeaway for a veteran like me is simple: always use a calculation method that has been validated against test results, and always fabricate the lacing system with care. A lattice column is only as strong as its weakest link, and the lacing system is often the weakest link if not properly designed and fabricated.