ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Finite Element Analysis of Axial Compression Bearing Capacity of Square Steel Tube Columns Filled with Coal Gangue Concrete

Literature Overview and Research Objectives

Zhang Yuzhuo, Ji Tingting, Liu Jinlong, Huang Yimeng and Lu Linhan, in their paper published in the Journal of Shenyang Jianzhu University (Natural Science) (Vol. 40, No. 2, 2024), present a finite element analysis of the axial compression bearing capacity of square steel tube columns filled with coal gangue concrete. The study is motivated by the need to find sustainable alternatives to natural aggregates in concrete, and coal gangue is a waste material from coal mining that can be used as a coarse aggregate. The paper investigates the effect of various design parameters on the axial compression bearing capacity of square steel tube columns filled with coal gangue concrete, and it proposes a calculation formula for the bearing capacity.

The use of coal gangue as a coarse aggregate in concrete is an environmentally beneficial practice, as it reduces the amount of waste material and conserves natural resources. However, the mechanical properties of coal gangue concrete differ from those of conventional concrete, and the effect of these differences on the behaviour of composite columns must be investigated. The paper uses the finite element method to model the behaviour of square steel tube columns filled with coal gangue concrete, and it validates the model against experimental results.

Finite Element Model Development and Validation

The finite element model was developed using ABAQUS, a widely used commercial finite element software. The model accounted for the nonlinear behaviour of the concrete, including the confinement effect provided by the steel tube, and the elastoplastic behaviour of the steel tube. The interface between the steel tube and the concrete was modelled using a suitable contact formulation, which allowed for the transfer of normal and shear forces between the two materials.

The model was validated against experimental results, and the comparison showed good agreement between the predicted and measured bearing capacities. The validation of the model is a critical step, as it ensures that the model can accurately predict the behaviour of the composite column. The validated model was then used to conduct a parametric study, investigating the effect of various design parameters on the axial compression bearing capacity.

The parametric study considered five coal gangue coarse aggregate replacement rates, and it analysed the effect of the steel ratio, the concrete strength, and the column dimensions on the bearing capacity. The control variable method was used, which means that one parameter was varied while the others were held constant. This approach allows the effect of each parameter to be isolated and quantified.

Parametric Study Results and Analysis

The results of the parametric study showed that the axial compression bearing capacity of the square steel tube column filled with coal gangue concrete decreases as the coal gangue coarse aggregate replacement rate increases. The maximum decrease was less than 14%, which indicates that the use of coal gangue as a coarse aggregate does not significantly degrade the bearing capacity of the column. This is an important finding, as it suggests that coal gangue concrete can be used in composite columns without a significant loss of structural performance.

The study also found that the steel ratio has the most significant effect on the axial compression bearing capacity when the cross-section dimension of the column is fixed. Increasing the steel ratio from 7.4% to 20.3% resulted in an average increase in the bearing capacity of 68.85% across the different replacement rates. This finding is consistent with the behaviour of conventional concrete-filled steel tube columns, where the steel tube provides significant confinement and contributes substantially to the bearing capacity.

The stress distribution and load sharing between the steel tube and the concrete were also analysed. The results showed that the steel tube carries a significant portion of the axial load, and the concrete carries the remainder. The confinement effect provided by the steel tube enhances the strength and ductility of the concrete, and this effect is more pronounced at higher steel ratios.

Design Formula and Code Implications

Based on the results of the parametric study, the paper proposed a calculation formula for the axial compression bearing capacity of square steel tube columns filled with coal gangue concrete. The formula is based on the provisions of the Technical Code for Concrete Filled Steel Tubular Structures (GB 50936-2014), and it introduces a coal gangue coarse aggregate replacement rate influence coefficient. The proposed formula was found to have a calculation error of less than 5%, which is acceptable for design purposes.

The introduction of the replacement rate influence coefficient is a practical approach that allows the existing design code to be used for coal gangue concrete-filled steel tube columns. The coefficient accounts for the reduction in bearing capacity due to the use of coal gangue as a coarse aggregate, and it can be used to adjust the design capacity accordingly. This approach is simple and practical, and it allows designers to use the existing code provisions with a minor modification.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

From my experience in the steel fabrication and construction industry, the use of coal gangue concrete in composite columns is an innovative and sustainable approach that has the potential to reduce the environmental impact of construction. However, the practical application of this material requires careful attention to the mix design and the quality control of the concrete. The mechanical properties of coal gangue concrete can vary significantly depending on the source and processing of the coal gangue, and the design must account for this variability.

The finite element analysis provides a valuable tool for understanding the behaviour of coal gangue concrete-filled steel tube columns, and it can be used to optimise the design parameters. The study shows that the steel ratio is the most significant parameter affecting the bearing capacity, and this should be considered in the design. The proposed calculation formula provides a practical method for design, and it can be used to determine the bearing capacity of columns with different coal gangue replacement rates.

Study Insights and Recommendations

This paper is a valuable contribution to the field of composite structures, and it provides a comprehensive analysis of the axial compression bearing capacity of square steel tube columns filled with coal gangue concrete. The key takeaways for the practising engineer are straightforward. First, the use of coal gangue as a coarse aggregate in concrete-filled steel tube columns is a viable and sustainable option, and it does not significantly degrade the bearing capacity of the column. Second, the steel ratio is the most significant parameter affecting the bearing capacity, and it should be carefully considered in the design. Third, the proposed calculation formula, which introduces a coal gangue coarse aggregate replacement rate influence coefficient, provides a practical and accurate method for design. Fourth, the finite element model can be used to investigate the behaviour of these columns under various loading conditions, and it can be used to optimise the design parameters.

The study also highlights the importance of sustainable construction practices, and it demonstrates that waste materials can be effectively used in structural applications without compromising performance. The use of coal gangue concrete in composite columns is a promising approach, and it has the potential to be widely adopted in the construction industry. The proposed design formula provides a reliable basis for design, and it can be incorporated into design codes and standards to facilitate the use of this sustainable material. The results of this study contribute to the advancement of composite structure technology and to the promotion of sustainable construction practices.