ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Structural Performance of Circular Stainless Steel Tube Concrete Curved Members Under Compression

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper by Zheng Lianqiong and colleagues from Fujian University of Technology addresses a gap in the knowledge base for concrete-filled stainless steel tubes (CFSST) used as curved compression members. The research is timely because curved members are increasingly common in modern architectural and bridge structures, yet most design guidance is derived from straight member testing. The experimental program consisted of 12 CFSST curved specimens, 3 straight CFSST specimens, and 1 empty stainless steel tube curved specimen as a control. The primary test parameters were nominal slenderness ratio (λn = 24, 48, and 72) and initial curvature (u0 = 0 to 140 mm). The test setup involved two-end central compression for curved specimens and eccentric compression for straight specimens.

The key experimental observations were that as both nominal slenderness ratio and initial curvature increased, the initial stiffness and ultimate bearing capacity of the curved members decreased. The failure modes of the curved specimens were generally similar to those of eccentrically loaded straight specimens, with local buckling of the stainless steel tube and crushing of the core concrete at the mid-height region being the dominant mechanisms. Importantly, the curved members exhibited slightly higher bearing capacity and stiffness than their straight eccentric counterparts, which is an interesting finding that challenges conservative design assumptions.

Technical Interpretation and Design Implications

The finite element analysis using ABAQUS showed excellent agreement with experimental results, validating the numerical model for parametric studies. The parameter analysis revealed that the bearing capacity of CFSST curved members was within 5% of corresponding straight eccentrically loaded members. This is a critical finding because it suggests that current design codes for ordinary concrete-filled steel tubes (CFST) can be applied to CFSST curved members with a conservative margin.

From a practical standpoint, this 5% difference is within the typical safety factors used in structural design (typically 1.2 to 1.5 for ultimate limit states). However, I would caution that the test specimens were relatively small-scale, and the effects of concrete creep, shrinkage, and long-term loading were not addressed. In real bridge applications, curved members are often subjected to sustained dead loads for decades, and the long-term behavior of the concrete core under sustained compression can significantly affect the composite action and overall stiffness.

Engineering Practice Integration and Lessons Learned

In my experience with steel-concrete composite structures, the interface between the steel tube and concrete core is critical. The stainless steel tube provides excellent corrosion resistance and ductility, but the smooth inner surface of stainless steel tubes can reduce the bond strength with the concrete core compared to carbon steel tubes. This bond is essential for load transfer in the elastic range and for ensuring composite action.

For curved members, the fabrication process introduces additional challenges. The bending of stainless steel tubes requires careful control of the bending radius to avoid excessive ovalization and wall thinning. In practice, I have seen curved members fail prematurely due to local buckling at the intrados (inner curve) of the bend, particularly when the bend radius is less than 3 times the tube diameter. The paper does not address this fabrication-induced imperfection, which could be a significant factor in real structures.

The recommendation to use existing CFST design methods for CFSST curved members is sound but should be applied with engineering judgment. I would suggest an additional safety factor of 1.1 to 1.15 for curved members with significant initial curvature (u0/D > 0.5) to account for the combined effects of fabrication tolerances, residual stresses from bending, and the reduced bond strength of stainless steel surfaces.

Key Questions and Reflections

One question that arises from this research is whether the initial curvature parameter u0 should be normalized by the member length or the tube diameter. The paper uses absolute values (0-140 mm), but for design purposes, a dimensionless parameter such as u0/L or u0/D would be more universally applicable. This is a minor point but reflects the need for standardized parameter definitions in composite structure research.

Another consideration is the applicability of these findings to large-diameter tubes used in bridge arches. The test specimens appear to be relatively small (likely 100-200 mm diameter based on typical laboratory specimens), whereas bridge arches typically use tubes of 500-1500 mm diameter. The size effect on concrete core behavior and local buckling of the steel tube is significant and may not be captured in small-scale tests.

Study Insights and Outlook

This research makes a valuable contribution to the understanding of CFSST curved members, particularly the finding that current design methods are conservative for this application. The combination of experimental testing and validated finite element analysis provides a solid foundation for future code development. However, I would recommend that designers treat the 5% capacity increase with caution and not rely on it for economic optimization, as the long-term behavior and fabrication effects may negate this advantage.

The practical takeaway for engineers is that curved CFSST members can be designed using existing CFST provisions, but with careful attention to the fabrication process and the bond quality between the stainless steel tube and concrete core. In my experience, the most common field issues with these members are inadequate concrete compaction in curved sections and premature local buckling at the intrados due to excessive ovalization during bending.