Seismic Performance of Square Steel Tube Recycled Concrete Frames with Recycled Hollow Block Infill Walls
Literature Overview and Research Context
This study by Yu Yalin, Meng Ercong, and Su Yisheng, published in World Earthquake Engineering (Vol. 39, No. 3, 2023), addresses a pressing issue in modern construction: the seismic behavior of composite frames incorporating recycled materials. The research focuses on square steel tube recycled concrete frames (RAC frames) infilled with recycled hollow block masonry walls, a configuration that aligns with the growing demand for sustainable construction practices.
The experimental program involved two full-scale frame specimens subjected to low-cycle reversed loading, with the presence or absence of infill walls as the primary variable. This is a well-designed parametric study that isolates the contribution of the infill wall to the overall seismic performance of the frame system.
Key Technical Findings and Interpretation
The failure mechanisms observed in the tests provide valuable insight into the interaction between the frame and the infill wall. For the bare frame, the failure sequence was RAC beam failure followed by column base local buckling. When the infill wall was present, the sequence shifted to wall failure first, then RAC beam failure, and finally column base buckling. This change in failure sequence is critical for design engineers because it indicates that the infill wall acts as a sacrificial element that protects the primary frame during early stages of seismic loading.
The hysteresis curves for the infilled frame specimens were described as full spindle-shaped, indicating stable energy dissipation and good plastic deformation capacity. The specimens exhibited three distinct phases: elastic, elastoplastic, and failure, which is consistent with typical composite frame behavior.
The quantitative results are particularly noteworthy. Compared to the bare frame, the infilled frame showed a 9.0% increase in positive bearing capacity but a 7.8% decrease in negative bearing capacity. This asymmetry is a crucial observation that practicing engineers must account for in design. The ductility coefficients increased by 15.6% in the positive direction and 35.7% in the negative direction, demonstrating the significant contribution of the infill wall to overall ductility.
The initial stiffness of the frame was enhanced by a factor of 1.06 due to the presence of the wall, while the residual stiffness was relatively unaffected. This suggests that the infill wall primarily contributes to the elastic range behavior but does not significantly alter the post-yield stiffness characteristics.
Practical Implications for Fabrication and Construction
From my decades of experience in steel pipe fabrication and structural steel construction, several practical considerations emerge from this research.
Welding and Fabrication Considerations
Square steel tubes used in composite frames require careful attention to welding quality, particularly at the column-beam connections. The corner regions of square tubes are susceptible to stress concentration, and the weld quality at these locations directly influences the failure mode observed in the tests. In practice, I have seen numerous cases where inadequate weld penetration at column base connections led to premature failure that was not predicted by design calculations.
Material Variability and Quality Control
The use of recycled concrete aggregate introduces additional variability in material properties that must be managed through rigorous quality control. In my experience with recycled aggregate concrete, the variability in compressive strength can be 15-20% higher than that of natural aggregate concrete. This variability must be accounted for in the design strength, and the concrete supplier must be held to strict grading and contamination limits.
Infill Wall Construction Practice
The test results confirm that infill walls contribute positively to seismic performance, but only when properly constructed with adequate connection to the frame. In practice, I have observed that infill walls are often constructed without proper ties to the steel frame, leading to premature separation and loss of the beneficial effects described in this study. The construction specification must require positive anchorage between the wall and the frame members.
Lessons Learned and Engineering Insights
The finding that the infill wall suppresses energy dissipation after wall failure is particularly important for performance-based seismic design. Once the wall fails, the frame must be able to absorb the remaining seismic energy without relying on the wall. This means that the frame itself must have adequate ductility and energy dissipation capacity independent of the infill wall.
The asymmetric bearing capacity response (positive vs. negative) highlights the need for symmetric detailing in composite frames. In practice, this means that the column-to-beam connections should be designed to provide similar capacity in both directions, and the infill wall construction should be symmetric about the frame axis.
For construction sites, the practical takeaway is that recycled concrete frames with infill walls can meet the deformation requirements for normal service conditions and have good collapse resistance. However, the contractor must ensure that the recycled concrete mix design is properly developed and tested before placement, and that the infill wall construction follows the design intent.
Summary and Outlook
This research provides valuable experimental evidence supporting the use of recycled concrete in square steel tube frames with infill walls for seismic applications. The key contributions are the identification of the failure sequence modification due to infill walls, the quantification of capacity and ductility improvements, and the confirmation that the system can satisfy normal service deformation requirements. For practicing engineers, the critical takeaway is that infill walls should be treated as sacrificial elements in seismic design, and the frame must be detailed to perform independently after wall failure. The asymmetric capacity response warrants careful consideration in design, and construction quality control must address both the recycled concrete variability and the infill wall-to-frame connection details. Future research should investigate the long-term durability of recycled concrete in composite frames and the effects of multiple seismic events on the cumulative damage behavior.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd