Prestressed CFST Composite Trusses: Optimization Analysis and Practical Application in Coal Conveyor Galleries
Literature Overview and Core Findings
The paper by Song Can, Yao Jitao, Yan Lei, and Zhao Huajing, published in World Earthquake Engineering in 2016, presents an optimization analysis of prestressed concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) composite trusses used for large-span coal conveyor galleries. The study focuses on 70 m and 80 m span structures and introduces an "equivalent deflection ratio" as the objective function for optimization. The optimization variables include the web member configuration and the cable arrangement scheme.
This topic is particularly relevant to my experience because coal conveyor galleries are industrial structures that must balance structural performance with economic efficiency. The steel pipe truss members are typically fabricated from seamless or welded pipe, and the prestressing cables are installed to improve stiffness and reduce deflection.
Optimization Methodology and Key Findings
The authors employ an improved full-stress method, which iteratively adjusts member sizes until all members reach their allowable stress levels. The objective function is the equivalent deflection ratio, which combines the deflection-span ratio with a consideration of steel consumption. The table below summarises the key findings.
| Optimization Variable | Options Considered | Optimal Choice | Economic Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Web member configuration | Herringbone (人字形), Warren, Pratt, etc. | Herringbone | Best economic efficiency for both 70 m and 80 m spans. |
| Cable arrangement | Multi-point external prestressing, single-point, etc. | Multi-point external prestressing | Reduced mid-span deflection and equivalent deflection ratio. |
| Span length | 70 m and 80 m | Both analysed | The 80 m span showed greater benefits from prestressing due to higher initial deflection. |
The herringbone (人字形) web configuration proved most economical because it provides a favourable load path that minimises the number of members and reduces the total steel weight. The multi-point external prestressing arrangement, where cables are anchored at multiple points along the truss, was found to be more effective than single-point prestressing in controlling deflection.
Interpretation from a Fabrication and Erection Perspective
From my experience in steel pipe fabrication and erection, I can offer several practical insights that complement the paper's findings.
First, the herringbone web configuration has significant fabrication advantages. The diagonal members meet at a common node, which simplifies the joint design and reduces the number of gusset plates or node connections required. This is particularly beneficial when using tubular members, where the joint geometry can be complex. However, the herringbone configuration also concentrates stress at the node, and I have seen cases where inadequate weld sizing at these nodes led to cracking under fatigue loading.
Second, the multi-point external prestressing system requires careful coordination between the truss fabricator and the prestressing contractor. The cable anchor points must be accurately positioned, and the cable ducts must be properly aligned to avoid friction losses. In my experience, the most common problem with external prestressing is improper duct alignment, which can cause the cable to bear against the duct wall and lead to premature failure.
Third, the use of prestressing in CFST trusses introduces additional considerations for the concrete filling process. The prestressing cables are typically installed after the concrete has gained sufficient strength, which means the concrete must be designed to withstand the prestressing forces without cracking. This requires careful attention to the concrete mix design and curing regime.
Practical Recommendations and Lessons Learned
Based on my experience and the findings of this paper, I offer the following recommendations for engineers designing prestressed CFST composite trusses.
- Use the herringbone web configuration for spans in the 70–80 m range, as it provides the best balance of structural efficiency and fabrication simplicity.
- Adopt multi-point external prestressing with cable anchorages at approximately one-third and two-thirds of the span length, as this configuration provides the most effective deflection control.
- Pay particular attention to the design of the node connections where the herringbone diagonals meet. Use full-penetration welds and consider the use of internal stiffeners to prevent local buckling.
- Ensure that the concrete filling process is completed before prestressing is applied, and that the concrete has reached the required strength as verified by cube tests.
- During erection, use temporary supports at the prestressing anchor points to prevent excessive deflection before the cables are tensioned.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper makes a valuable contribution by introducing the equivalent deflection ratio as an optimization objective. This parameter effectively combines the two competing goals of structural performance and material economy, and it provides a clear basis for comparing different design alternatives.
The finding that the herringbone web configuration is most economical is consistent with my experience. In industrial structures such as conveyor galleries, the herringbone configuration is widely used because it provides a simple and efficient load path. However, I would caution that the optimal configuration may change for different span lengths or loading conditions, and the design should always be verified with a detailed finite element analysis.
The paper also highlights the importance of considering the construction sequence in the design. The prestressing cables are tensioned after the concrete has gained strength, which means the structure must be designed for both the construction phase (before prestressing) and the service phase (after prestressing). This dual-phase design is often overlooked, and I have seen cases where the construction phase governed the design of certain members.
Reference Value and Outlook
For engineers involved in the design of industrial structures such as coal conveyor galleries, this paper provides a practical optimization methodology that can be applied to a range of span lengths and loading conditions. The equivalent deflection ratio is a useful parameter that can be adopted in other types of prestressed steel structures.
Looking forward, I expect to see increased use of prestressed CFST composite trusses in industrial applications, driven by the need for longer spans and lighter structures. The optimization methodology presented in this paper will be valuable for preliminary design, but detailed analysis and field verification will remain essential for final design.
In conclusion, this paper is a practical reference that I would recommend to engineers working on prestressed steel structures. The optimization methodology is straightforward and effective, and the findings regarding web configuration and cable arrangement provide clear guidance for design. The lessons learned from my own experience reinforce the importance of careful attention to fabrication details and construction sequence in ensuring the successful implementation of these structures.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd