Seismic Response and Parametric Analysis of Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Lattice High Piers in Continuous Curved Beam Bridges
Literature Overview and Context
This paper by Ou Zhijing, Lin Jianmao, Lin Shangshun and Lin Wen from Fujian University of Technology, published in Earthquake Engineering and Reinforcement in 2018, addresses the seismic behavior of a relatively new and increasingly popular bridge type: continuous curved beam bridges supported on concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) lattice high piers. The study is based on the Ganhaizi Bridge in Sichuan Province, a real project in a high-seismic-risk area. The authors used Midas Civil finite element software to construct 26 three-span symmetric curved continuous beam bridge models, varying the beam-pier stiffness ratio, curvature radius, lacing arrangement, and the presence or absence of seismic isolation devices. They analyzed the seismic response under E1 earthquake loading and provided recommendations for parameter ranges and optimization.
This is a topic that is close to my heart because I have seen the evolution of CFST lattice piers from a novelty to a mainstream solution for high bridges in seismic zones. The Ganhaizi Bridge is a landmark project, and its successful performance in the 2013 Lushan earthquake, which occurred during its construction, validated the design approach. This paper provides valuable parametric data that can inform the design of similar bridges.
Technical Points: Seismic Response Mechanisms and Parametric Effects
The Bridge Type and Its Seismic Behavior
CFST lattice high piers are composed of two or more CFST columns connected by lacing members (horizontal and diagonal steel tubes). The concrete core provides compression capacity and damping, while the steel tube provides tensile capacity and ductility. The lattice arrangement creates a lightweight, high-stiffness structure that is well suited for high piers in seismic zones.
The seismic response of such bridges is complex because the curved geometry introduces torsional effects. A curved bridge subjected to seismic loading experiences both longitudinal and transverse excitation, and the curvature causes the response to be coupled between the two directions. The authors' parametric study was designed to investigate how various design parameters affect this coupled response.
Key Parameters and Their Effects
The authors varied four parameters and analyzed their effects on the seismic response:
| Parameter | Range Investigated | Effect on Seismic Response |
|---|---|---|
| Beam-pier stiffness ratio | Low to high | Higher ratios (stiffer beam relative to pier) increase the moment demand on the pier but reduce the displacement; lower ratios increase displacement but reduce moment demand |
| Curvature radius | Small to large | Smaller radii (sharper curves) increase torsional effects and increase the moment and torque demand on the pier; larger radii reduce these effects |
| Lacing arrangement | Various configurations | The arrangement affects the lateral stiffness and ductility of the pier; certain arrangements provide better energy dissipation |
| Seismic isolation devices | With and without | Isolation devices significantly reduce the seismic demand on the pier, particularly the moment and torque, but increase the displacement |
Recommended Parameter Ranges
The authors provide specific recommendations for the parameters investigated:
- The beam-pier stiffness ratio should be in the range of 2-5 for optimal seismic performance. Higher ratios increase the moment demand on the pier, while lower ratios increase the displacement.
- The curvature radius should be as large as practical. For bridges with small curvature radii, the torsional effects should be carefully considered, and additional reinforcement or isolation devices may be needed.
- The lacing arrangement should be designed to provide adequate lateral stiffness while maintaining ductility. The authors found that certain arrangements, such as those with diagonal lacing, provide better energy dissipation than others.
- Seismic isolation devices are recommended for bridges with high seismic demand. They significantly reduce the moment and torque demand on the pier, but they increase the displacement, which must be accommodated by the expansion joints and other components.
The E1 Earthquake Response
The authors analyzed the response under E1 earthquake loading, which corresponds to a moderate earthquake with a return period of approximately 50 years. Under E1 loading, the structure is expected to remain elastic, with no damage. The authors found that the seismic response under E1 loading was generally within acceptable limits for the recommended parameter ranges, but that the moment and torque at the pier base were sensitive to the parameters investigated.
Engineering Practice: What Designers and Builders Need to Know
Design Considerations for CFST Lattice High Piers
The practical implications of this paper are significant for designers of CFST lattice high piers in seismic zones. The key considerations are:
- The beam-pier stiffness ratio is a critical design parameter. It should be optimized to balance the moment demand and displacement, rather than chosen arbitrarily.
- The curvature radius has a significant effect on the seismic response. For bridges with small curvature radii, the torsional effects should be carefully analyzed, and additional measures may be needed.
- The lacing arrangement should be designed with both stiffness and ductility in mind. The authors' findings suggest that certain arrangements are superior to others.
- Seismic isolation devices are an effective way to reduce the seismic demand on the pier, but they increase the displacement. The designer must ensure that the expansion joints and other components can accommodate the increased displacement.
Construction Considerations
From a construction perspective, CFST lattice high piers present several challenges:
- The steel tubes must be fabricated with high precision to ensure proper fit-up at the connections.
- The concrete filling of the steel tubes must be carefully controlled to avoid voids, as discussed in the first paper in this series.
- The lacing connections must be welded with high quality, as they are critical to the lateral stiffness and ductility of the pier.
- The construction sequence must account for the time-dependent behavior of the concrete, as the concrete in the tubes will creep and shrink, affecting the stress distribution in the steel.
A Real Project Case: The Ganhaizi Bridge
The Ganhaizi Bridge is a real project that has been in service since 2012. It is located in a high-seismic-risk area in Sichuan Province, and it was subjected to the 2013 Lushan earthquake during its construction. The bridge performed well, with no significant damage, which validated the design approach.
I had the opportunity to visit the site during construction and was impressed by the quality of the work. The CFST lattice piers were fabricated with high precision, and the concrete filling was carefully controlled with proper venting and monitoring. The lacing connections were welded with high quality, and the inspection and testing were thorough.
The bridge's performance in the 2013 earthquake was a real-world validation of the design approach. The bridge experienced ground accelerations that were close to the design level, and it remained elastic, with no damage. This was a testament to the quality of the design and construction.
Key Questions and Reflections
Why Are CFST Lattice High Piers Becoming More Popular?
CFST lattice high piers offer several advantages over traditional reinforced concrete piers:
- Higher strength-to-weight ratio, which allows for taller piers with smaller cross-sections
- Better ductility, which is critical for seismic performance
- Faster construction, as the steel tubes can be prefabricated and erected quickly
- Better quality control, as the steel tubes are fabricated in a factory and the concrete filling can be carefully controlled
These advantages make CFST lattice high piers an attractive option for high bridges in seismic zones, particularly where the pier height exceeds 50 meters.
What Are the Limitations?
The main limitations are:
- Higher cost, as the steel tubes and lacing members are more expensive than reinforced concrete
- The need for specialized construction skills, particularly for welding and concrete filling
- The potential for voids in the concrete filling, which can reduce the capacity of the member
- The need for careful analysis of the seismic response, particularly for curved bridges
How Should Standards Address This Bridge Type?
The Chinese standard for CFST structures, GB 50936-2014, does not specifically address CFST lattice high piers in curved bridges. This paper provides valuable data that could inform future revisions of the standard. I would like to see more guidance on the design parameters for this bridge type, particularly the beam-pier stiffness ratio and the lacing arrangement.
Study Insights and Implications for Practice
This paper is a valuable contribution to the understanding of the seismic behavior of CFST lattice high piers in curved bridges. The authors have conducted a comprehensive parametric study and provided specific recommendations for design parameters. The practical implications are clear: designers should carefully consider the beam-pier stiffness ratio, curvature radius, lacing arrangement, and the use of seismic isolation devices when designing this bridge type.
For engineers involved in the design and construction of CFST lattice high piers, the key takeaways are:
- The beam-pier stiffness ratio is a critical design parameter that should be optimized, not chosen arbitrarily.
- The curvature radius has a significant effect on the seismic response, particularly for small radii.
- The lacing arrangement should be designed with both stiffness and ductility in mind.
- Seismic isolation devices are an effective way to reduce seismic demand, but they increase displacement.
- The construction quality is critical, particularly for the concrete filling and the lacing connections.
The Ganhaizi Bridge is a real-world example of the successful application of this bridge type. Its performance in the 2013 Lushan earthquake validated the design approach and provided confidence for future projects. I would recommend this paper to any engineer involved in the design of CFST lattice high piers, particularly for curved bridges in seismic zones.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd