Comparison and Application of Calculation Methods for the External Pressure Stability of Stiffening Rings in Buried Steel Penstocks
Overview of the Study
This paper by Lu Zhihang, Peng Yueyao, Wu Hegao and Shi Changzheng, published in Water Resources and Hydropower Engineering in 2020, compares three commonly used methods for calculating the external pressure stability of stiffening rings in buried steel penstocks: the Amstutz method, the Jacobsen method, and the strength formula specified in the Chinese code NB/T 35056-2015. The study finds that the critical external pressure calculated by the Amstutz and Jacobsen methods decreases as the gap value increases, while the code strength formula does not consider the gap value and gives a result that is independent of it. All three methods show that the critical external pressure increases with increasing stiffening ring height, pipe wall thickness, and steel yield strength, and decreases with increasing stiffening ring spacing. The code strength formula gives a smaller critical external pressure than the Amstutz and Jacobsen methods, and it is significantly conservative for external water heads below 130 m. The study recommends that the Jacobsen method be adopted as one of the main calculation methods for the external pressure stability of stiffening rings in buried steel penstocks in the Chinese design code.
Comparison of Calculation Methods
The comparison of the three methods is a valuable contribution to the design of buried steel penstocks. In my experience, the design of stiffening rings for external pressure is a critical aspect of penstock design, and the choice of calculation method can have a significant impact on the required stiffening ring dimensions. The Amstutz method is a classic approach that is widely used in Europe and North America. It is based on the theory of elastic-plastic buckling of a cylindrical shell with stiffening rings, and it accounts for the gap between the penstock and the surrounding concrete or rock. The Jacobsen method is a more recent approach that is based on a more refined model of the stiffening ring behaviour. It accounts for the gap value, the stiffening ring dimensions, and the material properties in a more comprehensive manner. The code strength formula is a simplified approach that is based on the strength of the stiffening ring under external pressure, and it does not consider the gap value.
| Method | Considers Gap Value | Critical External Pressure | Conservatism |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amstutz | Yes | Decreases with increasing gap | Moderate |
| Jacobsen | Yes | Decreases with increasing gap | Moderate |
| Code strength formula (NB/T 35056-2015) | No | Independent of gap | Conservative for H < 130 m |
The study's finding that the code strength formula is significantly conservative for external water heads below 130 m is important. In practice, this means that the code formula will result in larger stiffening rings than necessary for penstocks operating under moderate external water heads. This can lead to increased material costs and fabrication complexity. The recommendation to adopt the Jacobsen method as a main calculation method is sound, as it provides a more accurate prediction of the critical external pressure while still being conservative enough for design purposes.
Manufacturing and Design Implications
From a manufacturing perspective, the stiffening rings are typically fabricated from steel plate, and they are welded to the penstock pipe using fillet welds. The weld quality at the stiffening ring-to-pipe connection is critical for the transfer of the external pressure load from the pipe to the stiffening ring. In my experience, the most common defect at these connections is lack of fusion, which can occur if the weld preparation is inadequate or if the welding parameters are not properly controlled. This can lead to premature failure of the stiffening ring under external pressure, which can cause the penstock to collapse. The study's finding that the critical external pressure increases with increasing stiffening ring height and pipe wall thickness is consistent with my experience. However, the study also finds that the critical external pressure decreases with increasing stiffening ring spacing. This is an important design consideration, as the stiffening ring spacing is often determined by practical constraints, such as the need to provide access for welding and inspection.
The gap value between the penstock and the surrounding concrete or rock is a critical parameter that is often difficult to determine accurately. In practice, the gap value depends on the construction method, the quality of the backfill, and the thermal expansion of the penstock. The study's finding that the Amstutz and Jacobsen methods account for the gap value, while the code formula does not, highlights the importance of accurately determining the gap value in design. In my experience, the gap value is often assumed to be zero in design, but in reality, it can be significant, particularly if the backfill is not properly compacted or if the penstock is installed in a rock tunnel with a large overbreak. This can lead to a lower critical external pressure than calculated, which can result in the collapse of the penstock.
Key Questions and Reflections
This study raises several important questions. First, the study compares the three methods for a specific set of parameters, but it does not provide a comprehensive parametric study. A more detailed parametric study would be valuable to determine the range of validity of each method and to identify the conditions under which each method is most accurate. Second, the study does not consider the effect of the initial imperfection of the penstock, which can significantly affect the critical external pressure. In practice, penstocks are never perfectly round, and the initial imperfection can reduce the critical external pressure by 10–20%. Third, the study does not consider the effect of the welding residual stress on the critical external pressure. The welding of the stiffening rings to the penstock introduces residual stresses that can affect the buckling behaviour of the penstock.
Study Insights and Implications
The practical implications of this study are clear. For the design of buried steel penstocks, the Jacobsen method should be considered as a viable alternative to the code strength formula, particularly for external water heads below 130 m, where the code formula is overly conservative. The gap value should be accurately determined in design, as it can have a significant impact on the critical external pressure. The stiffening ring dimensions and spacing should be optimised to achieve the required critical external pressure while minimising material costs and fabrication complexity. From a manufacturing perspective, the weld quality at the stiffening ring-to-pipe connection is critical, and it should be inspected using appropriate non-destructive testing methods. In my experience, the most successful penstock projects are those where the design, fabrication, and installation teams work closely together to ensure that the design assumptions are consistent with the actual construction conditions.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd