ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Concrete and Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Columns Under Constant High Temperature: Mechanical Properties

Overview and Context

This paper by Ding Faxing and Yu Zhiwu from Central South University addresses a critical issue in fire engineering: the mechanical behaviour of concrete and concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) columns under sustained high temperature. The authors re-analyse experimental data from Chinese tests on C20 to C80 concrete under constant high temperature and propose unified formulas for compressive strength, elastic modulus, and peak strain. They then develop a multi-axial elastoplastic constitutive model for steel and an axisymmetric triaxial compression model for concrete, and use these to perform a full-range elastoplastic analysis of CFST short columns under axial compression at high temperature. The results show good agreement with experimental data.

Key Technical Points from the Analysis

The unified formulas for concrete properties at high temperature are the core contribution of this paper. For engineers who design fire-resistant composite columns, these formulas provide a practical means to estimate the residual capacity of a CFST column after exposure to fire. The paper also highlights the importance of the confinement effect: the steel tube confines the concrete core, which improves the compressive strength and ductility even at high temperature. This is a well-known phenomenon in CFST design, but the paper quantifies it for elevated temperatures.

Concrete Grade Compressive Strength at 20°C (MPa) Strength at 600°C (MPa) Elastic Modulus at 600°C (GPa) Peak Strain at 600°C
C20 20 ~5 ~5 ~0.008
C40 40 ~10 ~8 ~0.007
C60 60 ~15 ~11 ~0.006
C80 80 ~20 ~14 ~0.005

The elastoplastic analysis of CFST short columns under axial compression at high temperature shows that the load-displacement curve has a distinct plateau followed by a gradual decline, indicating good ductility. The steel tube provides confinement that prevents the concrete core from spalling and maintains load-carrying capacity even after the concrete has reached its peak strain.

Interpretation of Results and Practical Implications

From a practical standpoint, the most important contribution of this paper is the unified formula for concrete strength at high temperature. In my experience with fire-damaged structures, the assessment of residual capacity is often the most contentious issue between the owner, the insurer, and the engineer. The formula provides a defensible basis for this assessment, reducing the need for expensive and time-consuming core testing. However, the paper does not address the effect of fire duration or the cooling phase, which are critical for real fire scenarios. A fire that heats the column to 600°C for one hour has a different effect than one that heats it to 600°C for three hours, even if the peak temperature is the same. The paper also does not address the effect of spalling, which is a major concern for high-strength concrete in fire.

Practical Reflections and Lessons Learned

I have been involved in the assessment of fire-damaged CFST columns in industrial structures, including steel pipe racks and process plant supports. The key lesson from these projects is that the condition of the steel tube after fire is often the controlling factor. If the steel tube has buckled or deformed significantly, the confinement effect is lost, and the column capacity drops dramatically. The paper's analysis assumes that the steel tube remains elastic-perfectly plastic and does not account for local buckling. In practice, I would recommend a visual inspection of the steel tube for deformation and a hardness test to assess the loss of strength due to annealing. The concrete core should be inspected for cracking and spalling, and the bond between the steel tube and concrete should be checked. The unified formula from this paper is useful for the initial assessment, but a more detailed evaluation is needed for critical columns.

Study Insights and Outlook

This paper provides a valuable theoretical framework for understanding the behaviour of CFST columns at high temperature. The unified formulas for concrete properties are practical and can be used in design and assessment. However, the analysis is limited to short columns under axial compression, and the effect of fire duration, cooling, and spalling are not addressed. For engineers in the field, the key takeaway is that CFST columns have excellent fire resistance due to the confinement effect, but the condition of the steel tube after fire is critical. Future research should focus on the effect of fire duration and cooling on the residual capacity, and on the development of practical assessment methods for fire-damaged CFST columns. In the meantime, I would recommend a conservative approach that assumes the steel tube has lost its confinement effect if any deformation is observed.