ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Finite Element Analysis of Axial Compression Performance of Plastic-Lined Steel Pipe Filled with Seawater Sea-Sand Concrete Short Columns

1. Literature Overview and Research Scope

This study by Ye Yong, Xue Yuxuan and colleagues from Huaqiao University's College of Civil Engineering and the Fujian Provincial Key Laboratory of Structural Engineering and Disaster Prevention addresses a novel and increasingly relevant topic: the structural performance of a composite column consisting of a plastic-lined steel pipe filled with seawater sea-sand concrete. The motivation for this research is clear. The construction industry is facing a shortage of freshwater and river sand in many coastal regions, and the use of seawater and sea-sand concrete offers a sustainable alternative. However, seawater and sea-sand concrete is highly corrosive to steel, and the conventional solution of using a steel pipe to confine the concrete is compromised by the corrosion risk. The plastic lining provides a barrier between the concrete and the steel pipe, preventing the corrosive ions in the seawater and sea-sand from attacking the steel. The paper uses finite element analysis (FEA) to model the axial compression behavior of these composite short columns, investigating the failure mode, the axial load-deformation relationship, and the internal force distribution between the steel pipe and the plastic liner. The key output is a simplified calculation formula for the ultimate bearing capacity, expressed in terms of a capacity reduction factor that accounts for the presence of the plastic liner.

This is a structural engineering paper rather than a steel pipe manufacturing paper, but it is directly relevant to the steel pipe industry because it addresses a growing application for lined steel pipe. The plastic-lined steel pipe, which is typically manufactured by inserting a polyethylene or polypropylene liner into a steel pipe and then expanding it to fit, is already used in water supply, drainage and chemical processing applications. The extension of this product to structural applications, such as concrete-filled steel tube columns in marine environments, is a logical progression, and this paper provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of the structural behavior of such composite elements.

2. Technical Interpretation and Finite Element Analysis

2.1 Modeling Approach and Material Constitutive Models

The paper adopts a careful approach to modeling the composite column. The steel pipe is modeled using a bilinear or multi-linear elastic-plastic constitutive model, which is appropriate for carbon steel. The concrete is modeled using a concrete damaged plasticity model, which captures the nonlinear behavior of concrete under compression, including the post-peak softening and the confinement effect provided by the steel pipe. The plastic liner is modeled as an elastic-plastic material with a low modulus of elasticity and a high Poisson's ratio, which reflects the behavior of polyethylene or polypropylene. The interaction between the steel pipe, the plastic liner and the concrete is modeled using surface-to-surface contact, with a friction coefficient that accounts for the bond between the layers. The paper validates the model against experimental data from the literature, which is a critical step in ensuring that the FEA results are reliable.

2.2 Failure Modes and Load-Deformation Behavior

The paper identifies three types of axial load-deformation curves, which are determined by the confinement effect coefficient, defined as the ratio of the steel pipe's yield force to the concrete's compressive force. When the confinement effect coefficient is low, the concrete fails before the steel pipe reaches its yield strength, and the load-deformation curve exhibits a peak followed by a rapid drop. When the confinement effect coefficient is moderate, the steel pipe yields at approximately the same time as the concrete reaches its peak stress, and the load-deformation curve shows a plateau. When the confinement effect coefficient is high, the steel pipe yields first, and the concrete is fully confined, resulting in a load-deformation curve that continues to increase after the initial yield. This classification is consistent with the behavior of conventional concrete-filled steel tube columns, which confirms that the plastic liner does not fundamentally alter the failure mechanism.

2.3 Effect of Plastic Liner Thickness on Bearing Capacity

The paper's most important finding is that the plastic liner thickness has a significant effect on the ultimate bearing capacity. As the thickness-to-diameter ratio of the plastic liner increases, the ultimate bearing capacity decreases approximately linearly. This is because the plastic liner has a much lower stiffness and strength than the steel pipe, and it effectively reduces the cross-sectional area of the steel pipe and the concrete. The plastic liner also introduces a compliance between the steel pipe and the concrete, which reduces the confinement effect. The paper proposes a capacity reduction factor that accounts for this effect, and the simplified calculation formula is a practical tool for design engineers. The reduction factor is a function of the plastic liner thickness-to-diameter ratio, and it can be used to adjust the bearing capacity of a conventional concrete-filled steel tube column to account for the presence of the plastic liner.

3. Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

3.1 The Role of Plastic-Lined Steel Pipe in Marine Construction

The use of seawater sea-sand concrete in structural applications is a growing trend, particularly in coastal and island construction where freshwater and river sand are scarce. However, the corrosion of steel reinforcement and steel pipe by the chloride ions in seawater is a major concern. The plastic-lined steel pipe offers a solution by providing a barrier between the concrete and the steel. The paper demonstrates that the plastic liner does not compromise the structural performance of the composite column significantly, provided that the liner thickness is kept within reasonable limits. This is an important finding for the steel pipe industry, because it opens up a new market for lined pipe in structural applications. The manufacturer of plastic-lined steel pipe should be aware of the structural requirements and should work with structural engineers to ensure that the liner thickness is optimized for both corrosion protection and structural performance.

3.2 Manufacturing Considerations for Plastic-Lined Steel Pipe

From a manufacturing perspective, the production of plastic-lined steel pipe for structural applications requires careful control of the liner thickness and the bond between the liner and the steel pipe. The liner is typically inserted into the steel pipe and then expanded using a mandrel or a hydraulic pressure process. The expansion process must ensure that the liner is in intimate contact with the steel pipe, with no gaps or wrinkles. The liner thickness must be uniform, because variations in thickness will affect the structural performance. The paper's finding that the bearing capacity decreases linearly with increasing liner thickness means that the manufacturer must control the liner thickness within tight tolerances to ensure consistent structural performance. The end connections of the lined pipe must also be designed to prevent the liner from being damaged during welding or flanging.

3.3 Design Implications and the Capacity Reduction Factor

The simplified calculation formula proposed in the paper is a practical tool for design engineers. It allows them to calculate the ultimate bearing capacity of a plastic-lined steel pipe concrete-filled short column using a capacity reduction factor that accounts for the liner thickness. This is a significant contribution, because it eliminates the need for complex finite element analysis in the design phase. However, the design engineer should be aware of the limitations of the formula. It is based on the results of short columns under axial compression, and it may not be directly applicable to long columns, eccentric loading or cyclic loading. The paper's focus on short columns is appropriate for the initial investigation, but further research is needed to extend the findings to other loading conditions.

4. Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises several questions that warrant further investigation. First, what is the long-term durability of the plastic liner in a seawater environment? The liner is designed to be corrosion-resistant, but it may degrade over time due to UV exposure, temperature cycling or chemical attack. Second, what is the bond behavior between the plastic liner and the concrete? The paper models the interaction using a friction coefficient, but the actual bond strength may vary depending on the surface texture of the liner. Third, what is the behavior of the composite column under eccentric loading or bending? The paper only considers axial compression, but real structural elements are often subjected to combined axial and bending loads. Fourth, what is the effect of the plastic liner on the fire resistance of the composite column? The plastic liner will melt at relatively low temperatures, which could compromise the structural integrity of the column in a fire.

5. Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a valuable contribution to the field of structural engineering and to the application of plastic-lined steel pipe in marine construction. It demonstrates that the plastic-lined steel pipe can be used as a structural element in concrete-filled steel tube columns, and it provides a practical design formula that accounts for the effect of the plastic liner on the bearing capacity. The findings are directly relevant to the steel pipe industry, because they open up a new application for lined pipe that goes beyond the traditional use in fluid transport. The manufacturer of plastic-lined steel pipe should take note of this research and consider the structural market as a potential growth area. The design engineer should use the proposed formula with caution, recognizing its limitations and ensuring that it is validated against experimental data for the specific liner material and thickness being used.

In my experience, the steel pipe industry is constantly evolving, and the development of new applications for existing products is a key driver of growth. The use of plastic-lined steel pipe in concrete-filled steel tube columns is a prime example of this evolution. The paper provides a solid foundation for further research and development, and I would encourage the steel pipe industry to collaborate with structural engineers to develop the product and the design guidelines further. The key takeaway is that the plastic liner, while primarily a corrosion barrier, has a measurable effect on the structural performance of the composite column, and this effect must be accounted for in design. The paper's capacity reduction factor is a simple and effective tool for doing so.