Seismic Performance of a Steel Pipe Arch Truss with Isolation Bearings
Overview of the Structural Challenge
The paper by Nan Lifei, Li Haiwang and Li Weiwei addresses a problem that is increasingly important in China's earthquake-prone regions: how do you design a large-span steel pipe arch truss that can survive a strong earthquake without catastrophic failure? The answer, as the authors demonstrate, is to use seismic isolation bearings at the supports, which significantly improve the seismic performance of the structure.
The context is important. Large-span arch trusses are used in stadiums, exhibition halls and transportation hubs. They are lightweight structures with long spans, and they are particularly vulnerable to seismic loading because of their low damping and high flexibility. A strong earthquake can cause large displacements and significant damage, even if the structure does not collapse.
The Arch Truss Model and Analysis Approach
The authors use a 60m span three-centred circular steel pipe arch truss as their study object. They create two models: one with conventional fixed hinges and one with lead-rubber isolation bearings. The analysis is performed using SAP2000 software with plastic hinge theory, considering both geometric and material nonlinearity.
| Parameter | Fixed Hinge Model | Isolation Bearing Model |
|---|---|---|
| Span | 60 m | 60 m |
| Rise | 15 m | 15 m |
| Steel grade | Q345 | Q345 |
| Pipe diameter (chord) | 219 mm | 219 mm |
| Pipe diameter (web) | 114 mm | 114 mm |
| Isolation bearing type | None | Lead-rubber, 400 mm diameter |
The analysis applies three earthquake waves with different frequency characteristics, and the response is evaluated in terms of nodal displacements, plastic hinge distribution, overall deformation and ductility coefficient.
The Key Finding: Isolation Bearings Improve Seismic Performance
The most important finding of the paper is that the isolation bearing model has a significantly higher failure limit than the fixed hinge model. The failure limit acceleration peak is 59.4% higher for the isolation bearing model, which means the structure can withstand a much stronger earthquake before failure.
| Model | Failure Limit Acceleration (g) | Failure Type | Ductility Coefficient |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed hinge | 0.32 | Elastic-plastic dynamic instability | 2.8 |
| Isolation bearing | 0.51 | Elastic-plastic dynamic instability | 3.5 |
The isolation bearings work by decoupling the structure from the ground motion. The lead-rubber bearings provide both energy dissipation and period shift, which reduces the seismic demand on the structure. The result is a 59.4% increase in the failure limit, which is a substantial improvement.
Plastic Hinge Distribution and Failure Mechanism
The authors also analyse the distribution of plastic hinges at the failure limit. They find that both models exhibit a similar failure mechanism: elastic-plastic dynamic instability, with a relatively small number of plastic hinges distributed evenly throughout the structure.
| Model | Number of Plastic Hinges at Failure | Distribution | Failure Mode |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed hinge | 12 | Evenly distributed | Elastic-plastic dynamic instability |
| Isolation bearing | 10 | Evenly distributed | Elastic-plastic dynamic instability |
The even distribution of plastic hinges is a positive finding. It means that the structure does not have a single weak point that fails first. Instead, the structure yields gradually, dissipating energy throughout the entire frame. This is a ductile failure mode, which gives warning before collapse.
However, the authors note that the absolute deformation before failure is small, and the warning signs are not obvious. This is a concern because it means the structure could fail suddenly, without significant visual warning. This is a characteristic of dynamic instability, which is a brittle failure mode in terms of the load-displacement relationship.
Practical Implications for Design and Construction
From my perspective as someone who has supplied steel pipe for arch trusses, this paper raises several practical points.
- The quality of the steel pipe is critical. The design assumes a certain yield strength and ductility. If the pipe supplier delivers material with lower yield strength or poor ductility, the plastic hinge behaviour will be different, and the failure mechanism could change.
- The connections must be designed for ductility. The plastic hinges form at the connections between the chord and web members. These connections must be designed to allow rotation without fracture. This requires careful attention to welding quality and connection geometry.
- The isolation bearings must be properly installed. The performance of the isolation system depends on the correct installation of the bearings. If the bearings are misaligned or improperly anchored, the isolation effect is reduced.
- The structure must be inspected after a strong earthquake. Even if the structure does not collapse, the plastic hinges may have formed, and the structure may have residual damage. A thorough inspection is required to assess the condition of the structure.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper raises several questions that deserve further consideration.
- What is the effect of the isolation bearings on the serviceability of the structure? The isolation bearings allow larger displacements, which could affect the performance of the roof cladding and other non-structural elements. This is not addressed in the paper, but it is an important consideration for design.
- What is the cost of the isolation bearings? The lead-rubber bearings are expensive, and the cost must be weighed against the improved seismic performance. The authors do not provide a cost comparison, but this is an important consideration for practical design.
- How does the structure behave under wind loading? The paper focuses on seismic loading
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd