Experimental Study on the Rupture of Circular Steel Pipes Under Internal Explosion
1. Overview of the Study and Its Practical Context
This paper from the University of Science and Technology of China investigates the structural response of circular steel pipes subjected to internal explosion loading. The authors used a custom-made explosive charge (φ37 mm × 3.8 mm, 45# steel) with external grooves, placed inside a test pipe (φ180 mm × 9.6 mm, 1 m long, 45# steel). The test pipe was filled with either water or air, and the charge was detonated using a detonating cord. The objective was to achieve a "rupture but not complete fragmentation" of the test pipe. The authors compared the effects of different explosive charges, pressure transmission media, groove numbers, and groove lengths on the rupture behaviour.
This is not just a demolition study. The results have direct implications for the design of pipes that may be subjected to internal explosions, such as gas pipelines, chemical plant piping, and even shipboard piping in naval vessels. The key finding is that the shock wave, not the fragments of the explosive charge casing, is the primary cause of pipe rupture. This is a critical insight because it means that the pipe's response is governed by the shock wave propagation and the resulting hoop stress, not by the kinetic energy of the fragments.
2. Interpretation of the Experimental Findings
The authors conducted a series of tests with varying parameters. The results can be summarised as follows.
| Parameter | Variation | Effect on Pipe Rupture | Practical Implication |
|---|---|---|---|
| Explosive charge | 5 g to 20 g | Higher charge increases the shock wave intensity and the likelihood of rupture | The critical charge for rupture is proportional to the pipe wall thickness squared |
| Pressure medium | Water vs. Air | Water is significantly more effective than air in transmitting the shock wave | Water-filled pipes are more vulnerable to internal explosion |
| Groove number on charge casing | 1 to 4 | More grooves produce more fragments, but the fragments are not the primary rupture mechanism | Grooves can be used to direct the rupture pattern |
| Groove length | Various | Longer grooves produce more uniform fragmentation of the charge casing | The casing fragmentation is secondary to the shock wave |
The most important finding is that water as a pressure medium is much more effective than air. This is because water is nearly incompressible and transmits the shock wave with less attenuation. In a real scenario, a water-filled pipe (e.g., a fire suppression line or a cooling water line) is much more vulnerable to internal explosion than an empty pipe. This is a counter-intuitive result that many engineers would not expect.
The authors also found that the pipe ruptures in a ductile manner, with the tear propagating along the axial direction. The tear is typically initiated at the location of maximum hoop stress, which is the inner surface of the pipe. The pipe wall thickness of 9.6 mm is relatively thick for a 180 mm diameter pipe, but the explosive charge is sufficient to generate a shock wave that exceeds the dynamic yield strength of the steel.
3. Connection to Steel Pipe Manufacturing and Quality Control
Now let me connect this to the manufacturing and delivery of steel pipes. The 45# steel used in the test is a medium-carbon steel with a yield strength of approximately 355 MPa. In real pipelines, the steel grade is usually API 5L X52 to X70, which has a higher yield strength but lower ductility. The behaviour under internal explosion is governed by the dynamic properties of the steel, which are not always the same as the static properties. The strain rate effect is significant: at high strain rates, the yield strength increases, but the ductility decreases. This means that a high-strength pipe may actually be more susceptible to brittle rupture under internal explosion than a lower-strength pipe.
The manufacturing process also plays a role. A seamless pipe has no longitudinal weld, so the rupture will propagate through the parent material. A welded pipe (ERW or LSAW) has a longitudinal weld seam that may be a weak point. The weld seam has a different microstructure, and it may contain defects such as lack of fusion, porosity, or slag inclusions. Under the high strain rate of an internal explosion, these defects can act as crack initiation sites. I have seen weld defects in LSAW pipes that were barely detectable by UT but were clearly visible in a metallographic examination. If such a pipe is subjected to an internal explosion, the weld seam is the most likely location for the rupture to initiate.
On the delivery side, the pipe must be properly inspected and tested. The paper's test pipe was 45# steel, which is not a pipe steel grade. In practice, we would use API 5L or ASTM A106. The Charpy impact test is the standard method for assessing the toughness of pipe steel. For internal explosion applications, the Charpy energy should be at least 27 J at the minimum design temperature. The drop-weight tear test (DWTT) is also recommended for assessing the resistance to unstable fracture.
4. Study Insights and Recommendations
This paper is a valuable contribution to the understanding of pipe rupture under internal explosion, but it is limited by the small scale of the tests. The test pipe was only 1 m long and 180 mm in diameter. In a real pipeline, the pipe is much longer, and the shock wave propagation is different. The end conditions of the pipe (whether it is fixed, free, or connected to other equipment) also affect the response. The authors did not study these effects.
My recommendations for engineers dealing with potential internal explosion scenarios are:
- Always consider the shock wave as the primary loading mechanism, not the fragments. The shock wave pressure can be estimated using the Chapman-Jouguet theory or empirical correlations.
- For water-filled pipes, increase the wall thickness or use a higher toughness steel grade. Water transmits the shock wave more effectively than air.
- For welded pipes, ensure that the weld seam is inspected with 100% UT and that the weld quality meets the requirements of API 5L or ASME B31.3.
- Conduct a full-scale or at least sub-scale explosion test on a representative pipe, including the actual weld seam, before commissioning a critical pipeline.
- Consider the use of rupture discs or pressure relief devices to mitigate the effect of an internal explosion.
In conclusion, this paper provides a solid experimental basis for understanding the rupture of circular steel pipes under internal explosion, but the real lesson is that the pipe's response is governed by the shock wave, not the fragments, and that water is a much more effective pressure medium than air. This has direct implications for the design of pipes in chemical plants, water supply systems, and naval vessels. We must design for the shock wave, not for the fragments, and we must select the steel grade and wall thickness accordingly.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd