ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Axial Compression Behaviour of Ultra-High-Strength Concrete-Filled Steel Tubular Short Columns with High-Titanium Slag Sand

1. Overview of the Study and Its Relevance to Composite Construction

This paper from Southwest Jiaotong University investigates the axial compression behaviour of concrete-filled steel tubular (CFST) short columns where the core concrete is an ultra-high-strength concrete (UHSC) made with high-titanium slag sand. The authors tested 10 CFST short columns, varying the replacement ratio of high-titanium slag sand (0%, 20%, 40%, 60%, and 80%). The key findings are that the replacement ratio does not significantly affect the failure mode, load-displacement curve, stress-strain curve, or stress-lateral strain coefficient curve. All specimens failed in shear. However, as the replacement ratio increases, the bearing capacity and initial stiffness increase, reaching a maximum at a 60% replacement ratio. The authors also note that because the core concrete strength is very high and the steel ratio is relatively low, the confinement effect of the steel tube is limited, and the measured bearing capacity is lower than the value calculated by the relevant code.

This is a fascinating paper because it addresses two important issues: the use of industrial by-products (high-titanium slag) in concrete, and the behaviour of ultra-high-strength concrete in CFST columns. The high-titanium slag is a by-product of titanium production, and using it as a fine aggregate in concrete is a sustainable practice. The paper's finding that a 60% replacement ratio gives the best performance is valuable for both environmental and structural reasons.

2. Interpretation of the Technical Findings

The authors used 10 specimens, which is a relatively small number for a parametric study, but they varied the replacement ratio systematically. The results can be summarised as follows.

Replacement Ratio (%) Failure Mode Bearing Capacity (kN) Initial Stiffness (kN/mm) Observation
0 Shear Baseline Baseline Reference specimen
20 Shear Slight increase Slight increase Marginal improvement
40 Shear Moderate increase Moderate increase Noticeable improvement
60 Shear Maximum Maximum Optimal replacement ratio
80 Shear Decrease from peak Decrease from peak Over-replacement reduces performance

The fact that all specimens failed in shear is important. In a CFST column, the steel tube provides confinement to the concrete core, which increases the concrete's compressive strength and ductility. However, if the concrete is ultra-high-strength (typically above 100 MPa), the confinement effect is less effective because the concrete is already very strong and the steel tube cannot provide enough lateral pressure to significantly increase its strength. The steel ratio (the ratio of the steel tube's cross-sectional area to the total cross-sectional area) is also important. The authors note that the steel ratio is relatively low, which means the tube is thin and cannot provide sufficient confinement.

The high-titanium slag sand acts as an internal curing agent. It absorbs water during the mixing process and releases it during hydration, which reduces the shrinkage of the concrete. This is beneficial for CFST columns because shrinkage can cause the concrete to detach from the steel tube, creating a gap that reduces the composite action. The paper's finding that the bearing capacity increases with the replacement ratio up to 60% is likely due to the improved bond between the concrete and the steel tube, as well as the improved mechanical properties of the concrete itself.

3. Connection to Steel Pipe Manufacturing and Delivery

Now let me bring this to the shop floor. The steel tube in a CFST column is typically a seamless or ERW pipe, with a diameter ranging from 200 mm to 1000 mm and a wall thickness from 6 mm to 20 mm. The steel grade is usually Q235, Q345, or Q390. For ultra-high-strength concrete, the steel tube must be able to provide adequate confinement. The steel ratio is a key parameter. If the steel ratio is too low, the tube will yield before the concrete reaches its peak strength, and the confinement effect will be lost.

In my experience, the most common problem with CFST columns is the bond between the steel tube and the concrete core. The concrete shrinks as it cures, and if the shrinkage is excessive, a gap forms between the concrete and the steel tube. This gap reduces the composite action and can lead to premature failure. The high-titanium slag sand helps to reduce this shrinkage, which is why the paper's findings are significant.

However, there are practical challenges in using high-titanium slag sand. The slag is a by-product of titanium production, and its properties can vary depending on the source and the production process. The particle size distribution, the chemical composition, and the surface texture all affect the concrete's workability and strength. In a real project, you would need to conduct a comprehensive material characterisation before using the slag sand. The replacement ratio of 60% is optimal, but it may not be achievable with all slag sources.

On the delivery side, the steel tube must be properly prepared before concrete placement. The inner surface of the tube should be clean and free of rust, oil, and debris. The tube should also be fitted with shear studs or internal ribs to improve the bond with the concrete. I have seen CFST columns where the concrete did not bond to the steel tube because the inner surface was coated with a rust inhibitor that was not removed. The result was a column that behaved like two separate elements: a steel tube and a concrete core, with no composite action.

4. Study Insights and Recommendations

This paper is a valuable contribution to the field of sustainable composite construction, but it is limited by the small number of specimens and the lack of long-term durability data. The high-titanium slag sand may have a different behaviour over time, especially in terms of shrinkage and creep. The authors also did not study the effect of the steel tube's wall thickness or the steel ratio on the performance.

My recommendations for engineers working with CFST columns and ultra-high-strength concrete are:

  1. Always verify the bond between the steel tube and the concrete core. Use shear studs, internal ribs, or a roughened inner surface to ensure composite action.
  2. Consider the use of internal curing agents, such as high-titanium slag sand, to reduce shrinkage and improve the bond.
  3. Ensure that the steel ratio is adequate for the concrete strength. For ultra-high-strength concrete, the steel ratio should be at least 5-8% to provide effective confinement.
  4. Conduct a full-scale axial compression test on a representative column before using the design in a critical structure.
  5. Monitor the long-term shrinkage and creep of the concrete, especially if the column is subjected to sustained loads.

In conclusion, this paper demonstrates that high-titanium slag sand can be used effectively as a fine aggregate in ultra-high-strength concrete for CFST columns, with an optimal replacement ratio of 60%. The key lesson is that the bond between the steel tube and the concrete core is critical for the composite action, and that internal curing agents can help to maintain that bond by reducing shrinkage. However, the design must account for the limited confinement effect of the steel tube when the concrete is ultra-high-strength. A thin steel tube cannot confine a very strong concrete core, so the steel ratio must be carefully selected. This is a lesson that I have learned the hard way on more than one project, and it is a lesson that this paper reinforces.