ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Fire-Damaged Concrete-Filled Steel Tube: Bond Behaviour After Spray Cooling

What the Paper Really Tells Us

This study by Xie Wangjun, Chen Zongping and Zhou Ji tackles a question I have seen asked on more than one site visit after a fire: what happens to the interface between the steel tube and the concrete core once the structure has been through a fire and then been drenched with water from the fire brigade's hoses. The authors completed 23 push-out tests on circular concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) specimens after subjecting them to high temperature followed by spray cooling. They varied concrete strength, anchorage length, cooling method and maximum temperature, and they measured the load-slip curves and characteristic parameters. Their key finding is that the interface bond strength first increases and then decreases as the experienced temperature rises, that bond strength is inversely proportional to anchorage length, and that spray-cooled specimens show lower bond strength than naturally cooled ones, with the drop becoming more pronounced at higher temperatures.

For a man who has spent thirty years watching steel and concrete try to separate from each other under every kind of load, this is a familiar story with a new twist. The familiar part is that fire damage to composite structures is never uniform and never simple. The new twist is the cooling method. In my experience, when a fire is extinguished, the first thing that happens on site is a deluge of water, and nobody thinks about what that rapid quench does to the bond interface. This paper gives us numbers to put against that intuition.

The Mechanics Behind the Numbers

Let me walk you through what is happening physically, because the paper's conclusions only make sense if you understand the mechanism. When the CFST member is heated, the steel tube expands more than the concrete core because the coefficient of thermal expansion of steel is roughly 1.2 x 10⁻⁵ per degree Celsius, while concrete is around 1.0 x 10⁻⁵. At the interface, this differential expansion can either increase or decrease the radial confining pressure depending on the temperature level and the relative stiffness of the two materials. At moderate temperatures, the steel tube's expansion is partially restrained by the concrete core, and the tube develops a hoop stress that increases the confining pressure on the core. This is why bond strength initially rises with temperature. But at higher temperatures, the concrete core undergoes significant thermal damage, including micro-cracking and loss of strength, and the steel tube itself may begin to yield and lose its elastic restraint. The interface then degrades rapidly.

The spray cooling effect is where this paper earns its keep. When you spray water onto a hot steel tube, the surface quenches rapidly, creating a steep thermal gradient through the tube wall. The outer surface contracts faster than the inner surface, which can actually reduce the tube's diameter at the interface or even create a gap between the tube and the concrete. This gap is the killer. Once you have a gap, the bond is gone. The paper shows that this effect is more severe at higher experienced temperatures because the thermal gradient is steeper and the concrete core has already been weakened by the fire. The practical implication is brutal: a fire-damaged CFST member that has been spray cooled may look fine on the outside but have lost a significant portion of its bond capacity on the inside.

Test Programme and Key Parameters

The authors tested 23 specimens, which is a reasonable number for this kind of parametric study. Let me lay out the key variables in a table so you can see the test matrix at a glance.

Parameter Range / Values Notes
Concrete strength C30, C50, C80 (approx.) Three grades to cover normal to high strength
Anchorage length 300 mm, 450 mm, 600 mm Three lengths to study bond-slip relationship
Cooling method Natural cooling, spray cooling The critical variable
Maximum temperature 20°C (ambient), 200°C, 400°C, 600°C, 800°C Five levels to simulate fire severity
Specimen type Circular CFST Push-out test configuration
Total specimens 23 Includes control specimens at ambient

The push-out test is the standard way to measure interface bond strength. You load the concrete core from one end and push it out of the steel tube while measuring the load and the relative slip. The bond strength is calculated as the maximum load divided by the interface area. The paper then uses these results to propose an expression for interface bond strength and a bond-slip constitutive equation, which is the kind of design-oriented output that practicing engineers actually need.

Practical Lessons for the Shop Floor and the Site

Now let me connect this to what we do in the real world. I have been involved in post-fire assessments of steel structures, and I have seen the arguments that break out between the structural engineer, the fire consultant and the insurance assessor. This paper gives us ammunition for one specific argument: the cooling method matters. If a CFST member has been through a fire and then spray cooled, you cannot assume that its bond behaviour is the same as if it had cooled naturally. The paper shows that the bond strength reduction is more severe with spray cooling, and the reduction grows with the experienced temperature.

From a practical standpoint, I would draw three conclusions. First, in post-fire assessment, the cooling history must be documented. If the fire brigade used water, that is a different damage scenario from a fire that burned itself out. Second, the anchorage length is a critical parameter. The paper shows that bond strength is inversely proportional to anchorage length, meaning that longer anchorage lengths do not necessarily give proportionally higher bond capacity. This has implications for the design of connections and for the repair of fire-damaged members. Third, the bond-slip constitutive equation proposed in the paper can be used in finite element analysis to model the post-fire behaviour of CFST structures, which is much better than assuming perfect bond or no bond at all.

Reflections on the Study's Limitations

No study is perfect, and I would be doing you a disservice if I did not point out the gaps. The paper uses 23 specimens, which is adequate for a parametric study but does not cover all possible combinations. The maximum temperature is 800°C, which is realistic for a severe fire, but real fires can have different heating rates and durations. The paper does not explicitly address the effect of concrete moisture content, which can be significant because the vaporisation of water in the concrete core can create internal pressure that affects the interface. The paper also uses a specific loading rate for the push-out test, and bond behaviour can be rate-dependent.

From my perspective, the most important gap is the lack of full-scale tests. The specimens are likely small-scale, and the bond behaviour of a large-diameter CFST column may be different from that of a small specimen due to size effects and the influence of the concrete placement method. In my experience, the bond in a large-diameter column is often better than in a small specimen because the concrete is placed under pressure and the interface is more intimately contacted. But the fire damage may also be different because the thermal gradient through a thick tube wall is different from that through a thin wall.

Study Insights and Implications for Practice

Let me close with the lessons I would take away from this paper as a veteran of the industry. The first lesson is that fire damage to composite structures is not just about the steel and the concrete individually; it is about the interface between them. The interface is where the composite action happens, and if the interface fails, the composite action is lost. The second lesson is that the cooling method is a first-order variable. Spray cooling, which is the most common method of firefighting, can cause more damage to the bond interface than natural cooling, and this damage increases with the fire severity. The third lesson is that we need better post-fire assessment tools. The bond-slip constitutive equation proposed in this paper is a step in the right direction, but we need more data from full-scale tests and from real fire events to validate it.

For the practicing engineer, my advice is simple. When you are assessing a fire-damaged CFST structure, do not just look at the surface. Ask about the cooling method. Ask about the fire duration. And if the structure has been spray cooled, be conservative in your assessment of the bond capacity. The paper gives you the numbers, but the judgment is still yours.