ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Hot Topics in Natural Gas Transmission Steel Pipe Research and Application

Introduction and Historical Context

This paper by Li Helin, written in 2001, is a classic overview of the key issues in natural gas transmission steel pipe research and application. Li Helin is one of the most respected figures in the Chinese steel pipe industry, and this paper reflects his deep understanding of the field. The paper covers eight hot topics: high-pressure transmission and high-grade pipeline steel development, HIC-resistant line pipe and its technical specifications, rich gas transmission and its requirements for pipe performance, the comparison and selection of longitudinal submerged-arc welded (LSAW) pipe and spiral submerged-arc welded (SSAW) pipe, ductile fracture arrest in gas transmission pipes, stress corrosion cracking (SCC) in near-neutral pH soil environments, residual stress in line pipe and its control, and the yield-to-tensile ratio of high-strength pipeline steel.

Even though this paper was written over two decades ago, its content is still highly relevant today. Many of the issues it raises are still being debated in the industry, and some of them have become even more critical as we move to higher pressures and higher grades of steel. Let me go through each topic and give you my perspective as someone who has been in the industry for thirty years.

High-Pressure Transmission and High-Grade Pipeline Steel

The first topic is the development of high-grade pipeline steel for high-pressure transmission. In 2001, the industry was moving from X60 and X65 to X70 and X80, and there was a lot of debate about whether X80 was ready for widespread use. Today, X80 is standard in many parts of the world, and X100 and X120 are being researched. The driving force is economics: higher pressure and higher grade steel mean smaller diameter pipes, less steel, and lower cost for the same gas throughput.

But there are significant technical challenges. High-grade pipeline steel has higher strength but lower toughness, and the weldability becomes more difficult. The heat-affected zone (HAZ) of high-grade steel is more susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking (HIC) and stress corrosion cracking (SCC). The yield-to-tensile ratio (Y/T ratio) increases with grade, which means that the pipe has less capacity for plastic deformation before failure. This is a concern for ductile fracture arrest, which I will discuss later.

From my perspective, the key to successful use of high-grade pipeline steel is the control of the entire production chain, from steelmaking to pipe manufacturing to welding. The steel must be clean, with low sulphur and phosphorus content. The pipe must be manufactured with precise control of the forming and welding parameters. And the field welding must be done by qualified welders using approved procedures. Any weakness in the chain can lead to catastrophic failure.

HIC-Resistant Line Pipe and Technical Specifications

The second topic is HIC-resistant line pipe and its technical specifications. HIC is a form of hydrogen damage that occurs when hydrogen atoms diffuse into the steel and combine to form molecular hydrogen at internal defects such as inclusions or voids. The pressure builds up and causes cracks, which can lead to failure. HIC is a particular problem in sour service, where the gas contains hydrogen sulphide (H₂S).

The paper discusses the technical specifications for HIC-resistant line pipe, which typically include limits on hardness, inclusion content, and the results of HIC tests. The HIC test is a standard test where a specimen is exposed to a hydrogen-charging environment for a specified time, and the crack length ratio (CLR), crack thickness ratio (CTR) and crack area ratio (CAR) are measured. The specifications typically require CLR, CTR and CAR to be below certain values.

From my experience, the key to HIC resistance is steel cleanliness. The steel must be produced with low sulphur content, typically below 10 ppm, and the inclusions must be controlled. Calcium treatment is often used to modify the inclusion shape, making them more spherical and less likely to initiate cracks. The steel must also have a uniform microstructure, with no hard bands or segregated regions that can trap hydrogen.

Rich Gas Transmission and Its Requirements for Pipe Performance

The third topic is rich gas transmission, which means transmitting gas that contains heavier hydrocarbons, such as propane, butane and pentane, in addition to methane. Rich gas has a higher heating value but also a higher tendency to form liquids, which can cause problems in the pipeline. The paper discusses the requirements for pipe performance in rich gas service, which include higher toughness to resist ductile fracture, and better corrosion resistance.

From my perspective, the main challenge with rich gas is the potential for liquid accumulation in low points of the pipeline. This can cause slug flow, which can lead to erosion and corrosion. The pipe must have sufficient wall thickness to withstand the pressure and the dynamic loads from slug flow. The toughness must be high enough to arrest a ductile fracture, which is more likely in rich gas because of the higher energy content.

Comparison and Selection of LSAW and SSAW Pipe

The fourth topic is the comparison and selection of LSAW and SSAW pipe. This is a topic that I have strong opinions about, having manufactured both types of pipe. LSAW pipe is made by forming a steel plate into a U shape, then an O shape, and then welding the longitudinal seam using submerged arc welding. SSAW pipe is made by forming a steel strip into a spiral and welding the seam. Both have their advantages and disadvantages.

Let me put the comparison in a table.

Parameter LSAW Pipe SSAW Pipe
Manufacturing process UOE or JCOE forming Spiral forming
Wall thickness range Typically up to 40 mm Typically up to 25 mm
Diameter range Typically 400 mm to 1,500 mm Typically 200 mm to 3,000 mm
Residual stress Lower Higher
Dimensional accuracy Better Good
Weld quality Excellent, single longitudinal weld Good, but spiral weld is longer
Toughness Generally higher Generally lower
Cost Higher for small diameters Lower for small diameters
Application High-pressure, long-distance pipelines Low-pressure, distribution pipelines

The key difference is the residual stress. LSAW pipe has lower residual stress because the forming process is more controlled, and the weld is straight. SSAW pipe has higher residual stress because of the spiral forming, and the weld is longer, which means more potential for defects. However, SSAW pipe is cheaper for small diameters because the manufacturing process is more efficient.

In my experience, the choice between LSAW and SSAW pipe depends on the application. For high-pressure, long-distance pipelines, LSAW pipe is preferred because of its better toughness and lower residual stress. For low-pressure, distribution pipelines, SSAW pipe is often used because of its lower cost. However, there are exceptions, and the final choice should be based on a thorough technical and economic analysis.

Ductile Fracture Arrest

The fifth topic is ductile fracture arrest in gas transmission pipes. This is a critical safety issue. If a ductile fracture initiates in a gas pipeline, it can propagate at high speed along the pipe, driven by the gas pressure. The fracture will continue until the pressure drops below a critical level or until the pipe's toughness is high enough to arrest the fracture.

The paper discusses the methods for predicting fracture arrest, including the Battelle two-curve method, which compares the fracture propagation resistance with the driving force. The driving force is a function of the gas pressure, the pipe diameter, the wall thickness, and the gas properties. The fracture propagation resistance is a function of the pipe's toughness, which is typically measured by the Charpy impact energy or the drop-weight tear test (DWTT).

From my perspective, the key to ductile fracture arrest is to ensure that the pipe has sufficient toughness. The required toughness increases with the pipe diameter, the wall thickness, and the gas pressure. For rich gas, the required toughness is higher because the gas has more energy. The industry has developed specifications for the minimum Charpy impact energy and DWTT energy for different pipe grades and diameters.

Stress Corrosion Cracking in Near-Neutral pH Soil

The sixth topic is SCC in near-neutral pH soil environments. This is a form of cracking that occurs on the external surface of buried pipelines in certain soil conditions. The mechanism involves the dissolution of the steel at the crack tip, combined with hydrogen embrittlement. The crack grows slowly over time and can eventually lead to failure.

The paper discusses the conditions that promote SCC, including the soil pH, the presence of carbon dioxide, the coating type, and the stress level. The key factors are the soil chemistry and the coating. Some coatings, such as coal tar enamel, are more susceptible to SCC than others, such as fusion-bonded epoxy (FBE).

From my experience, the best defence against SCC is a combination of good coating, cathodic protection, and periodic inspection. The coating must be applied correctly, with no holidays or defects. The cathodic protection must be maintained at the correct level. And the pipeline must be inspected periodically using in-line inspection tools to detect any cracks before they grow to a critical size.

Residual Stress and Its Control

The seventh topic is residual stress in line pipe and its control. Residual stress is the stress that remains in the pipe after manufacturing, even when there is no external load. It can be tensile or compressive, and it can affect the pipe's performance in several ways. Tensile residual stress can promote SCC and fatigue, while compressive residual stress can be beneficial.

The paper discusses the sources of residual stress in line pipe, including the forming process, the welding process, and the straightening process. The control of residual stress is achieved through careful process control and, in some cases, through post-weld heat treatment or mechanical expansion.

From my perspective, the most important source of residual stress is the welding process. The weld and the HAZ have high tensile residual stress, which can be a problem in sour service. The industry has developed several methods to reduce weld residual stress, including the use of low heat input welding, the use of post-weld heat treatment, and the use of mechanical stress relief.

Yield-to-Tensile Ratio of High-Strength Pipeline Steel

The eighth topic is the yield-to-tensile ratio (Y/T ratio) of high-strength pipeline steel. The Y/T ratio is the ratio of the yield strength to the tensile strength. A high Y/T ratio means that the steel has a small difference between yield and tensile strength, which means less capacity for plastic deformation before failure. This is a concern for pipelines because it reduces the ability of the pipe to deform without fracturing.

The paper discusses the factors that affect the Y/T ratio, including the steel composition, the microstructure, and the processing. High-strength pipeline steel typically has a higher Y/T ratio than lower-strength steel. The industry has set limits on the Y/T ratio for different pipe grades, typically around 0.85 to 0.90 for X70 and X80.

From my perspective, the Y/T ratio is a critical parameter that must be controlled during steelmaking and pipe manufacturing. The steel must be produced with a microstructure that provides a good balance of strength and toughness, with a Y/T ratio that is within the specified limits. This requires careful control of the alloying elements, the rolling temperature, and the cooling rate.

Concluding Thoughts

This paper by Li Helin is a masterful overview of the key issues in natural gas transmission steel pipe. Even though it was written in 2001, its content is still highly relevant today, and many of the issues it raises are still being debated. The paper provides a comprehensive framework for understanding the technical challenges and the solutions that have been developed over the years. For the practicing engineer, the paper is a valuable reference that covers the full spectrum of issues from steelmaking to pipeline operation. My advice is to read this paper carefully and to keep it in mind when you are making decisions about pipe selection, quality control, and pipeline integrity management.