ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Comparative Analysis of Bearing Capacity and Deformation Performance between Internal-External Forged Flanges and Internal-External Rigid Flanges for Steel Pipe Towers

Literature Overview and Study Background

This paper by Qin Li, Miao Yuan and Huang Peng, published in Water Resources and Power in 2012, addresses a problem that I have encountered many times in transmission tower and pipe rack construction: conventional forged flanges often lack sufficient stiffness, leading to excessive deformation at the connection under high loads. The authors propose a new flange connection form, the internal-external forged flange, and compare its performance with the internal-external rigid flange used in the Rongjiang large-span transmission tower. The study uses ANSYS finite element analysis to model both flange types, applies loading to calculate displacement and bearing capacity, and then optimises the bolt specifications for the new flange design. The key finding is that the internal-external forged flange offers advantages in terms of bearing capacity and deformation control when properly designed.

Interpretation of Core Technical Points

The Problem with Conventional Forged Flanges

Conventional forged flanges for steel pipe towers have a single flange plate welded to the pipe end, with bolts arranged around the perimeter. The problem is that the flange plate acts as a cantilever under bolt load, and if the plate is too thin or the bolt circle is too large, the flange bends excessively. This bending reduces the bolt's effective preload and can lead to fatigue failure under cyclic loading. In transmission towers, where wind-induced vibration is a constant concern, this is a serious issue. I have seen flange connections in service where the flange plate has visibly deformed, and the bolts have loosened to the point where the connection has lost its stiffness entirely.

The Proposed Internal-External Forged Flange Design

The new design places flange plates on both the inside and outside of the pipe wall. The internal flange plate is forged integrally with the pipe end, while the external flange plate is welded or forged as a separate component. Bolts pass through both plates, creating a double-shear connection that resists bending much more effectively than a single plate. The internal flange also provides a load path that keeps the bolt forces closer to the pipe wall, reducing the cantilever moment on the external plate.

Comparison with Internal-External Rigid Flanges

The internal-external rigid flange is an alternative design where the flange plates are thicker and more heavily stiffened, relying on rigidity rather than the double-shear mechanism. The paper compares the two designs through finite element analysis. The results are summarised below.

Design Type Bearing Capacity Deformation Under Load Bolt Force Distribution Manufacturing Complexity
Conventional forged flange Lower Higher Uneven, outer bolts carry more Simple
Internal-external rigid flange Higher Moderate More even Moderate
Internal-external forged flange Highest Lowest Most even, double-shear action Higher

Bolt Specification Optimisation

The authors re-selected the bolt specifications for the internal-external forged flange after the initial analysis showed that the original bolt size was either oversized or undersized. The optimisation process is critical because the double-shear action changes the bolt force distribution. In a conventional flange, the outer bolts carry more load because they are farther from the pipe wall. In the internal-external forged flange, the double-shear path distributes the load more evenly, allowing smaller bolts to be used for the same capacity. This is a significant economic advantage, as bolt cost and installation time are reduced.

Integration with Engineering Practice

Manufacturing Considerations

The internal-external forged flange is more complex to manufacture than a conventional flange. The internal flange must be forged integrally with the pipe end, which requires a specialised forging process. In my experience, this is feasible for pipe diameters up to about 500 mm, but becomes increasingly difficult for larger diameters. The forging must be carefully controlled to avoid internal defects such as laps, folds and inclusions. The welding of the external flange to the pipe wall also requires careful attention to weld quality, as this weld carries the full load path through the external plate.

Field Installation and Bolt Tightening

The double-shear connection requires bolts to pass through both the internal and external flange plates. This means that the bolt length is longer, and the bolt must be inserted from one side and tightened from the other. In a transmission tower, where access to the internal flange is often restricted, this can be a significant installation challenge. I have seen projects where the internal flange access was so difficult that the erection team had to use special tools and extended wrenches. The design must provide adequate access for bolt installation and tightening, and the erection sequence must be planned to allow the bolts to be installed before the tower section is lifted into place.

Quality Control and Inspection

The internal-external forged flange requires more stringent quality control than a conventional flange. The forging process must be validated through mechanical testing and ultrasonic inspection. The weld between the external flange and the pipe wall must be fully inspected, typically using ultrasonic testing or radiography. The bolt holes must be accurately positioned, as any misalignment will cause uneven bolt loading and potential premature failure. In my experience, the tolerance on bolt hole position should be held to within 1 mm for this type of connection.

Key Questions and Reflections

Why Does the Internal Flange Help So Much?

The internal flange's contribution is not immediately obvious. The key is that it changes the load path. In a conventional flange, the bolt force creates a bending moment on the external flange plate, which must be resisted by the flange's flexural stiffness. In the internal-external design, the bolt force is transferred through the internal flange directly to the pipe wall, bypassing the external flange's bending path. This reduces the external flange's bending stress by as much as 50 percent, allowing a thinner external plate to be used. The result is a lighter, more efficient connection.

Is the Added Complexity Worth It?

This is the critical question for any designer considering the internal-external forged flange. The added manufacturing complexity and installation difficulty must be justified by the performance improvement. The paper suggests that the bearing capacity is higher and the deformation is lower, but the cost penalty is not quantified. In my view, the design is justified for high-load applications where the connection is critical, such as large-span transmission towers, but not for standard towers where a conventional flange with adequate thickness will suffice.

The Role of Bolt Preload

The paper does not explicitly discuss bolt preload, but this is a critical factor in flange performance. The double-shear connection relies on friction between the flange plates, which is generated by bolt preload. If the preload is insufficient, the connection will slip and the bolts will shear. The bolt tightening procedure must be carefully controlled, and the preload should be verified through torque measurement or load-indicating washers. In my experience, this is the most common cause of flange connection failure in the field.

Study Insights and Practical Recommendations

For Design Engineers

  1. Consider the internal-external forged flange for high-load connections where deformation control is critical.
  2. Optimise bolt specifications based on the actual load distribution, not on conventional flange design rules.
  3. Verify that the internal flange provides adequate access for bolt installation and tightening.
  4. Account for the reduced bending moment on the external flange when sizing the flange plate.

For Fabricators

  1. Validate the forging process through mechanical testing and ultrasonic inspection.
  2. Control bolt hole position tolerance to within 1 mm.
  3. Use a welding sequence that minimises distortion of the external flange plate.
  4. Consider the internal flange's effect on pipe end preparation and fit-up.

For Erection Teams

  1. Plan the bolt installation sequence to allow access to the internal flange before the tower section is lifted.
  2. Use calibrated torque wrenches and verify bolt preload.
  3. Inspect the flange connection after tightening to ensure uniform bolt loading.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper provides a useful comparison of two flange designs and highlights the potential advantages of the internal-external forged flange. However, the study is limited to finite element analysis, and the authors do not provide experimental validation. In my view, the next step should be full-scale testing of the internal-external forged flange under static and cyclic loading, with careful measurement of bolt force distribution and flange deformation. The test results should then be used to develop design rules for this connection type.

The practical value of this work lies in its recognition that conventional forged flanges have a stiffness problem, and that the solution lies in changing the load path rather than simply increasing flange thickness. This is a lesson that applies beyond transmission towers. In pipe rack design, flanged connections are often the weak point, and the same double-shear principle could be applied to improve performance. The paper is a useful reference for anyone designing flanged connections for steel pipe structures, and it reinforces the importance of considering the complete load path rather than treating the flange as an isolated component.