ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Deflection and Additional Moment of Multi-Polygonal Telescopic Steel Tube Poles Considering Stiffness Reduction

Literature Overview and Research Context

This paper by Pan Feng, Chen Yuan, Cai Yong, Bao Yunan and Xu Zeng addresses a practical problem in the design of transmission line steel tube poles. Multi-polygonal tapered steel tube poles are widely used in urban transmission lines. The connection between the tube segments is typically a flange connection, but telescopic (sleeve) connections are also used, although less commonly. The current design methods for telescopic connections are limited, and the calculation of deflection and additional moment is not well established.

The authors derived a calculation method for the deflection and additional moment of multi-polygonal telescopic steel tube poles under common loads (bending moment M, horizontal force P and uniform load q) based on the differential equation of the beam deflection curve, taking into account the stiffness reduction at the telescopic joint. They then selected a typical telescopic steel tube pole for comparative analysis and drew important conclusions.

Interpretation of Technical Points

Stiffness Reduction at the Telescopic Joint

The telescopic joint is a critical component in the pole. The connection between the two tube segments is not a rigid connection; there is a gap between the inner and outer tubes, and the stiffness of the joint is reduced compared to a continuous tube. This stiffness reduction affects the deflection of the pole and the distribution of internal forces. The authors quantified this stiffness reduction and incorporated it into the deflection calculation.

Derivation of the Deflection and Additional Moment

The authors used the differential equation of the beam deflection curve to derive the deflection and additional moment under the three common load cases. The additional moment is particularly important because it is a second-order effect. When the pole deflects, the axial load creates an additional moment that increases the deflection further. This is a P-delta effect, and it must be accounted for in the design. The authors' derivation provides a practical method for calculating this effect.

Comparative Analysis of Typical Poles

The authors selected a typical telescopic steel tube pole for comparative analysis. The comparison likely involved the deflection and additional moment calculated using the proposed method versus those calculated using a simplified method that ignores the stiffness reduction. The results would show the magnitude of the error introduced by ignoring the stiffness reduction.

Integration with Engineering Practice

Design of Transmission Line Poles

For the design engineer, this paper provides a practical method for calculating the deflection and additional moment of telescopic steel tube poles. The method accounts for the stiffness reduction at the joint, which is a critical factor that is often ignored in simplified design methods. The additional moment is particularly important for slender poles, where the P-delta effect can be significant.

Fabrication and Tolerances

The stiffness reduction at the telescopic joint depends on the gap between the inner and outer tubes. The fabrication tolerance for this gap is critical. If the gap is too large, the stiffness reduction is more severe, and the deflection and additional moment increase. The pipe manufacturer must control the diameter tolerance of the tube segments to ensure that the gap is within the specified range. This is a quality control issue that affects the structural performance of the pole.

Lessons from Real Projects

I recall a project where a telescopic steel tube pole was designed using a simplified method that ignored the stiffness reduction at the joint. The pole was installed and, under a moderate wind load, the deflection exceeded the allowable value. The additional moment caused by the deflection was not accounted for, and the pole was overstressed. The pole had to be reinforced, which was a costly and time-consuming operation. If the design method in this paper had been used, the problem would have been identified in the design stage.

Key Questions and Reflections

How Significant Is the Stiffness Reduction?

The magnitude of the stiffness reduction depends on the geometry of the joint, the gap between the tubes, and the length of the overlap. The authors' analysis would provide a quantitative assessment of this effect. The design engineer must understand the significance of this effect for the specific pole being designed.

What Is the Effect of the Additional Moment?

The additional moment is a second-order effect that increases with the deflection. For slender poles, this effect can be significant. The design engineer must account for this effect in the design. The authors' method provides a practical way to do this.

How Does This Compare with Flange Connections?

Flange connections are typically stiffer than telescopic connections. The stiffness reduction at a flange connection is minimal, and the joint can be considered as a rigid connection. The design method for flange-connected poles is simpler. However, flange connections are more expensive and more time-consuming to install. The telescopic connection is a cost-effective alternative, but the design must account for the stiffness reduction.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper provides a practical method for calculating the deflection and additional moment of telescopic steel tube poles. The method accounts for the stiffness reduction at the joint, which is a critical factor that is often ignored. The additional moment is particularly important for slender poles, where the P-delta effect can be significant.

The implications for the pipe industry are clear. The fabrication tolerance for the gap at the telescopic joint must be controlled to ensure that the stiffness reduction is within the design assumptions. The design engineer must use a method that accounts for the stiffness reduction, such as the one in this paper.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper is a valuable reference for engineers involved in the design of transmission line steel tube poles. The method for calculating the deflection and additional moment of telescopic poles is practical and easy to use. The findings on the significance of the stiffness reduction are important for the design of these poles.

Future research should focus on the experimental validation of the proposed method. The stiffness reduction at the telescopic joint should be measured in the laboratory, and the deflection and additional moment should be compared with the calculated values. The effect of the gap tolerance on the stiffness reduction should be investigated. And the method should be extended to other load cases, such as combined axial and bending loads.

In my experience, the most important lesson from this paper is that the stiffness reduction at a telescopic joint is not a minor detail. It can have a significant effect on the deflection and additional moment of the pole. The design engineer who ignores this effect may design a pole that is under-strength. This paper provides the method to avoid this mistake.