ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Rectangular Hollow Sandwiched Steel Tube Concrete in Pure Bending: A Structural Engineer's Perspective

1. Literature Overview and Core Findings

This study by Xie Li, Chen Mengcheng, and Huang Hong, published in Railway Engineering (2012, Vol. 52, No. 12, pp. 155-158), investigates the flexural behavior of rectangular hollow sandwiched steel tube concrete (RHSSTC) members. The authors designed three RHSSTC specimens and one solid steel tube concrete specimen, using hollow ratio as the main variable parameter. They conducted pure bending tests and compared the experimental results with finite element (FE) analysis. The key findings are that all specimens exhibited good plastic behavior during loading, and the RHSSTC members showed significantly higher flexural capacity than the solid steel tube concrete member. The FE model predictions matched the experimental results well.

2. Technical Interpretation: The Mechanics of Hollow Sandwiched Sections

2.1 What Is a Hollow Sandwiched Steel Tube Concrete Member?

A hollow sandwiched steel tube concrete member consists of two concentric steel tubes with concrete cast in the annular gap between them. The inner tube creates a hollow core, which reduces the self-weight of the member while maintaining a high flexural capacity. This is a significant advantage for long-span structures, where self-weight is a major design driver. The hollow ratio, defined as the ratio of the inner tube diameter to the outer tube diameter, is the key geometric parameter.

2.2 Why Is Flexural Capacity Higher Than Solid Sections?

The study found that RHSSTC members have higher flexural capacity than solid steel tube concrete members. This is counterintuitive at first glance, because removing material (the hollow core) should reduce capacity. However, the explanation lies in the mechanics of composite action. In a solid steel tube concrete member, the concrete core is confined by the outer steel tube, but the concrete in the center of the section is under low stress because it is far from the extreme fibers. By removing this low-stress concrete and replacing it with a hollow core, the section becomes more efficient: the remaining concrete is closer to the outer fibers, where the bending stresses are highest. Additionally, the inner steel tube provides additional confinement to the concrete, improving its compressive strength and ductility.

2.3 The Role of the Inner Steel Tube

The inner steel tube serves two functions: it acts as a formwork for the concrete during casting, and it provides confinement to the concrete annulus. In pure bending, the inner tube is subjected to a combination of compression and tension, depending on its position relative to the neutral axis. The study shows that the inner tube contributes to the flexural capacity by carrying part of the tensile or compressive force, and by confining the concrete, which increases its strain capacity and prevents premature crushing.

3. Engineering Practice: What This Means for Fabrication and Construction

3.1 Fabrication Challenges

From a manufacturing perspective, RHSSTC members are more complex to fabricate than solid steel tube concrete members. The key challenges are:

Challenge Description Mitigation
Concentricity The inner tube must be accurately centered within the outer tube Use spacer bars or centering rings at regular intervals
Concrete placement The annular gap is narrow, making concrete placement difficult Use self-compacting concrete (SCC) with high flowability
Weld access Welding the inner tube to the outer tube requires access to the annular gap Use plug welds or access holes for welding
Dimensional control The inner tube must be manufactured to tight tolerances Use precision tube manufacturing processes (cold drawn or cold formed)

3.2 Concrete Placement and Quality

The narrow annular gap in RHSSTC members is a practical concern. If the gap is too narrow, the concrete may not fill completely, leaving voids that reduce the composite action. My experience suggests the following practical guidelines:

3.3 Structural Design Considerations

The study's finding that RHSSTC members have higher flexural capacity than solid sections is important for design. However, the design must also account for:

  1. Local buckling of the inner tube: The inner tube is thinner than the outer tube and may buckle under compression. The width-thickness ratio must be checked against local buckling limits.
  2. Shear connection: The bond between the concrete and the inner and outer tubes must be sufficient to transfer shear. If the bond is inadequate, shear connectors (studs or ribs) may be required.
  3. Fire resistance: The hollow core reduces the thermal mass of the section, which may reduce fire resistance. Fire protection may be required for the inner tube.

4. Key Questions and Reflections

The study raises an important question: what is the optimal hollow ratio for a given application? The authors used hollow ratio as the main variable, but they do not provide a clear recommendation. My experience suggests that a hollow ratio of 0.5-0.7 is optimal for most structural applications. At lower ratios, the hollow core is too small to provide significant weight savings; at higher ratios, the concrete annulus becomes too thin, reducing the confinement effect and increasing the risk of local buckling.

Another reflection: the study used rectangular sections, which are more efficient than circular sections for bending because they have a higher section modulus per unit area. However, rectangular sections are more prone to local buckling at the corners, and the confinement effect is less uniform than in circular sections. This is a trade-off that designers must weigh carefully.

The FE model used in the study is a valuable tool for parametric studies, but it must be validated against experimental data before it can be used for design. The authors report good agreement between FE and experimental results, which gives confidence in the model. However, I would caution against using FE models for design without proper validation, especially for new structural forms like RHSSTC.

5. Study Insights and Practical Implications

The practical value of this study is that it demonstrates the feasibility and benefits of RHSSTC members for structural applications. The higher flexural capacity and lower self-weight make them attractive for long-span structures, such as bridges and roof structures. For a steel tube manufacturer, this study opens up a new market: the production of concentric steel tube assemblies for concrete-filled applications. The manufacturing requirements are demanding, but the potential rewards are significant.

I would recommend that engineers considering RHSSTC members for a project take the following steps:

  1. Conduct a feasibility study to determine the optimal hollow ratio for the specific application.
  2. Perform full-scale tests on prototype members to verify the flexural capacity and ductility.
  3. Develop a detailed fabrication procedure that ensures concentricity and complete concrete filling.
  4. Specify quality control measures, including ultrasonic testing of the concrete core and dimensional verification of the tube assembly.

The study's finding that all specimens exhibited good plastic behavior is particularly important for seismic design. In an earthquake, the member must be able to dissipate energy through plastic deformation without losing load-carrying capacity. The RHSSTC members showed good ductility, which is a key advantage over solid steel tube concrete members, which can fail in a brittle manner if the concrete core is over-confined.