Nonlinear Finite Element Analysis of Square Steel Tube Expansive Concrete Short Columns under Axial Load
The Role of Expansive Concrete
This paper by Lu Fangwei and colleagues from Wuhan Municipal Engineering Design and Research Institute addresses a clever idea: using expansive concrete to improve the bond between a steel tube and its concrete core. The concept is that expansive concrete, as it cures, expands and presses against the steel tube, creating an initial confinement pressure. This is different from ordinary concrete, which shrinks and creates a gap between the steel and the concrete.
The authors model the expansion effect by equating it to a temperature field. This is a common technique in finite element analysis. The expansive concrete is modelled as if it were subjected to a temperature increase, which causes it to expand. The steel tube, which has a much lower coefficient of thermal expansion, restrains the expansion, creating the confinement pressure.
Contact Pressure and Confinement Effects
The FE analysis shows that the contact pressure between the steel tube and the expansive concrete is not uniform. It is highest at the corners of the square section and lowest at the mid-point of the sides. This is consistent with the geometry of the square section. The corners are stiffer and provide more restraint, so the contact pressure is higher there. The flat sides are more flexible, so the contact pressure is lower.
The confinement effect is concentrated in the two diagonal regions of the section. This means that the concrete in the corners is highly confined, while the concrete in the centre of the sides is less confined. This is an important finding because it means that the confinement is not uniform across the section. The design engineer needs to account for this non-uniformity when calculating the ultimate capacity of the column.
The study also shows that the confinement effect only becomes significant when the axial load approaches the ultimate load. At lower loads, the steel tube and the concrete act independently, and the contact pressure is low. As the load increases, the concrete tries to expand laterally, and the steel tube restrains it, creating the confinement pressure. This is the classic mechanism of confinement in concrete-filled steel tubes.
Parametric Study and Design Implications
The authors discuss the effect of the Poisson's ratio of the concrete on the behaviour. The Poisson's ratio changes as the concrete cracks and crushes, which affects the lateral expansion and hence the confinement pressure. This is a subtle but important effect. The FE analysis captures it by using a nonlinear material model that accounts for the change in Poisson's ratio with strain.
The practical implication is that the design of square steel tube expansive concrete columns requires a nonlinear analysis. A simple linear elastic analysis will not capture the confinement effect, and it will underestimate the ultimate capacity. The proposed FE model is a useful tool for this purpose.
Practical Applications in Bridge Engineering
This type of column is used in bridge piers and columns where high strength and ductility are required. The expansive concrete improves the bond between the steel and the concrete, which increases the stiffness and the ultimate capacity of the column. This is particularly beneficial in seismic zones, where the column needs to absorb energy through plastic deformation.
From a construction standpoint, the use of expansive concrete requires careful quality control. The expansion must be controlled to avoid excessive pressure that could burst the steel tube. The mix design must be carefully calibrated, and the concrete must be placed and cured properly. I have seen cases where expansive concrete was over-expanded, and the steel tube bulged. The fix is to use a lower dosage of expansive agent and to monitor the expansion during curing.
The paper is a valuable contribution to the understanding of composite columns. The FE model provides insight into the mechanism of confinement, and the parametric study highlights the importance of the Poisson's ratio and the expansion effect. I would recommend this model for the design of square steel tube expansive concrete columns, provided that the expansion is properly controlled.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd