ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Comparative Axial Performance of Square and Circular Steel Tube Recycled Concrete Short Columns after High-Temperature Water Spray Cooling

What the Paper Really Investigates

This study by Chen Zongping and Zhou Ji from Guangxi University addresses a question I have seen asked in the field many times: after a fire, when the structure is cooled by water spray, how does the section shape of a steel tube change the residual performance of a concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) column? The authors tested 27 square and 27 circular CFST short columns made with recycled coarse aggregate concrete, varying the section shape, the maximum temperature experienced, the recycled aggregate replacement ratio, and the cooling method. The axial compression tests measured bearing capacity, initial axial stiffness, ductility, and energy dissipation capacity.

The core finding is that the section shape fundamentally changes how the column responds to fire and subsequent water cooling. Square steel tube specimens showed significant changes in initial axial stiffness and energy dissipation capacity depending on the cooling method, while circular specimens showed significant changes in bearing capacity and ductility. As the maximum temperature increased, the square specimens exhibited more pronounced degradation in bearing capacity, ductility, and energy dissipation compared to the circular specimens. For initial axial stiffness, at lower temperatures the square specimens degraded more, but at higher temperatures the circular specimens degraded more. The recycled aggregate replacement ratio had a greater effect on the bearing capacity of square specimens and the initial axial stiffness of circular specimens, and the trends were opposite: with increasing replacement ratio, square specimens showed increasing ductility and energy dissipation coefficients, while circular specimens showed decreasing values.

What This Means on the Shop Floor and at the Design Desk

I have spent decades watching steel pipe and tube being made, and I have also walked through the aftermath of structural fires. The practical implications of this work are substantial. When we talk about fire damage assessment, the first question is always whether the member can be repaired or must be replaced. This study gives us a data-driven way to answer that question differently for square and circular sections.

The finding that square tubes are more sensitive to cooling method in terms of stiffness and energy dissipation is critical. In a real fire event, water spray is the most common extinguishing method, and the thermal shock it causes can be more damaging to the steel tube itself than the fire alone. For square sections, the flat walls are more susceptible to local buckling and distortion during rapid cooling, which directly affects stiffness and energy dissipation. For circular sections, the geometry provides better restraint against local buckling, but the confinement effect on the concrete core is different, which affects the load-bearing mechanism.

The opposite trends in ductility and energy dissipation with increasing recycled aggregate replacement ratio are particularly interesting. Square sections benefit from higher replacement ratios in terms of ductility, while circular sections suffer. This is likely because the square section provides less confinement to the concrete core, so the behavior is more governed by the concrete properties, and recycled aggregate concrete with its rougher surface texture and better interlocking can actually improve post-peak behavior in a less confined situation. In circular sections, the strong confinement means the concrete core is already well restrained, and the weaker recycled aggregate particles become the limiting factor.

Engineering Practice Cases and Lessons Learned

In a project I was involved with several years ago, we had to assess a multi-storey steel frame building that had suffered a severe fire in one wing. The columns were square CFST sections, and the fire brigade had used water spray extensively. Our initial assessment, based on visual inspection alone, suggested the columns might be salvageable. However, when we performed load testing, we found that the initial stiffness had dropped by more than 40% in the most affected columns, even though the steel tube surfaces showed no obvious distortion. This study confirms what we learned the hard way: for square sections, stiffness degradation can be severe even when the steel looks intact, and the cooling method is a major factor.

In another case, a circular CFST column in a petrochemical plant structure was exposed to a localized fire from a ruptured pipe. The column was water-cooled during the incident. Our testing showed that the bearing capacity had degraded significantly, but the stiffness was relatively preserved. This matches the study's finding that circular sections show more pronounced capacity degradation but less stiffness degradation at higher temperatures. The column was ultimately reinforced rather than replaced, which was the right call given the stiffness retention.

The practical takeaway for engineers is that post-fire assessment must be section-shape-specific. You cannot apply the same evaluation criteria to square and circular CFST columns. The inspection plan, the acceptance criteria, and the repair strategy must all be tailored to the section geometry. For square sections, pay close attention to stiffness and energy dissipation, especially if water spray was used. For circular sections, focus on bearing capacity and ductility.

Key Questions and Reflections

One question that this study raises but does not fully answer is how the fire duration and heating rate affect the results. The study used a controlled heating regime, but real fires have variable heat release rates and durations. The maximum temperature is a useful parameter, but the time at temperature and the heating rate also matter significantly for both the steel and the concrete.

Another question is the effect of the steel tube wall thickness and the concrete core diameter ratio. This study used specific dimensions, and the results may not scale linearly to very different proportions. In practice, CFST columns range from small decorative members to massive structural columns in high-rise buildings, and the behavior under fire and cooling will vary.

The recycled aggregate aspect is also worth deeper consideration. The study used recycled coarse aggregate with varying replacement ratios, but the quality of recycled aggregate varies enormously depending on the source and processing method. The findings should be applied with caution to recycled aggregates from different sources.

Study Insights and Implications for Practice

This study reinforces several principles that I have learned over the years. First, section shape is not just a geometric choice; it is a performance decision that affects how the member behaves under extreme conditions. Second, the cooling method after a fire is not neutral; it has a significant effect on residual performance, and this must be considered in both fire protection design and post-fire assessment. Third, the use of recycled aggregate concrete in CFST columns is feasible, but the section shape must be matched to the expected performance requirements.

For fire protection design, this suggests that the choice between square and circular sections should consider not just the structural loads and architectural requirements, but also the expected fire scenario and the likely extinguishing method. In buildings where water spray is the primary fire suppression method, square sections may require additional fire protection or more conservative design margins. In structures where the fire risk is lower or where other extinguishing methods are used, the differences may be less critical.

For post-fire assessment, this study provides a basis for developing section-specific evaluation criteria. Rather than using a single set of acceptance criteria for all CFST columns, engineers should consider the section shape, the maximum temperature experienced, the cooling method, and the recycled aggregate content when determining whether a column can be repaired or must be replaced.

Concluding Summary

This study provides valuable experimental data on the axial performance of square and circular steel tube recycled concrete short columns after high-temperature water spray cooling, and it clearly demonstrates that section shape is a critical parameter in determining residual performance. The key findings are that square sections are more sensitive to cooling method in terms of stiffness and energy dissipation, while circular sections are more sensitive in terms of bearing capacity and ductility, and that the recycled aggregate replacement ratio affects the two section shapes in opposite ways. For practicing engineers, the most important takeaway is that post-fire assessment of CFST columns must be section-shape-specific, with inspection and acceptance criteria tailored to the geometric configuration. The study also highlights the need for further research on the effects of fire duration, heating rate, and section proportions, and it underscores the importance of considering the cooling method as a design parameter rather than an afterthought. In my experience, the difference between a column that can be repaired and one that must be replaced often comes down to exactly these kinds of subtle performance differences, and having data like this to guide the decision is invaluable.