ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Study Note on Comparative Analysis of Axial Compression Behaviour of Circular and Square Steel Tube High-Strength Concrete Short Columns After High Temperature

Literature Overview and Core Findings

Chen Zongping, Chen Jianjia, and Zhang Yaqi from Guangxi University conducted an experimental study on the axial compression behaviour of circular and square steel tube high-strength concrete (HSC) short columns after exposure to high temperatures. The study involved 30 specimens, considering three variables: cross-sectional shape (circular versus square), the maximum temperature experienced (presumably 200, 400, 600, or 800 degrees Celsius), and concrete strength grade. The specimens were heated, allowed to cool, and then tested to failure in axial compression.

The key findings are: as the experienced temperature and concrete strength grade increase, the peak load, peak displacement, stiffness, displacement ductility, and energy dissipation of both types of specimens follow broadly similar trends; however, the circular steel tube HSC specimens are more sensitive to the effects of temperature and concrete strength grade than the square steel tube HSC specimens. The paper also observed the appearance changes before and after heating and compared the mass loss rates of the circular and square specimens.

Technical Interpretation and Engineering Implications

This paper addresses a critical issue in fire engineering: the residual capacity of steel tube concrete columns after a fire. The steel tube provides confinement to the concrete core, which enhances the concrete's compressive strength and ductility. The confinement effect is more pronounced in circular tubes than in square tubes, because the circular shape provides uniform confinement around the entire circumference, while the square shape has corners where the confinement is less effective. This is a well-known principle in concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) design.

After high temperature exposure, the steel tube loses strength and stiffness due to the degradation of the steel properties, and the concrete also loses strength due to the thermal damage. The confinement effect is reduced because the steel tube can no longer provide the same lateral restraint. The paper's finding that circular specimens are more sensitive to temperature and concrete strength grade suggests that the confinement effect in circular tubes is more dependent on the steel tube's properties, which degrade significantly at high temperatures.

The mass loss rate is an interesting parameter. When concrete is heated, the free water evaporates, and at higher temperatures, the chemically bound water is released. The mass loss is an indicator of the degree of thermal damage. The paper compared the mass loss rates of circular and square specimens, which would show whether the cross-sectional shape affects the heat transfer and the resulting thermal damage.

Practical Cases and Lessons from the Field

I have seen the aftermath of fires in steel-framed buildings, and the damage to steel tube concrete columns can be severe. In one case, a fire in a warehouse caused the concrete in a steel tube column to spall, and the steel tube was visibly buckled. The column had to be replaced, even though the fire was relatively short-lived. This paper provides quantitative data on how much capacity is lost at different temperatures, which is essential for assessing the residual capacity of fire-damaged structures.

The finding that circular columns are more sensitive to temperature is counterintuitive at first glance, because circular columns are generally considered to have better fire performance due to the uniform confinement. However, the paper's explanation makes sense: the confinement effect in circular columns is more dependent on the steel tube's ability to provide lateral restraint, and when the steel tube degrades, the confinement is lost more dramatically. In square columns, the confinement is already less effective, so the degradation of the steel tube has a smaller relative impact.

From a design perspective, this means that the fire protection of circular steel tube concrete columns is more critical than for square columns. The circular columns have a higher initial capacity, but they lose more of it in a fire. This is a subtle but important distinction that designers should be aware of.

Standards and Judgement

The design of concrete-filled steel tube columns is covered by several standards, including the Chinese code for concrete-filled steel tube structures, GB 50936, and the European code, EN 1994-1-2, which covers the fire design of composite steel and concrete structures. The fire design provisions typically use the concept of the fire resistance rating, which is the time for which the structure can withstand a standard fire without failing.

This paper provides data that can be used to calibrate the fire design models for high-strength concrete-filled steel tube columns. The current codes are based on tests with normal-strength concrete, and the behaviour of high-strength concrete after fire is different. High-strength concrete is more brittle and more prone to spalling, which can expose the steel tube to direct fire and accelerate the damage.

Reflections and Study Insights

This paper is a good example of the kind of experimental study that is needed to improve our understanding of the fire behaviour of composite structures. The comparison between circular and square sections is particularly valuable, because it highlights the different mechanisms of confinement and the different sensitivity to temperature.

The practical implication is that fire protection design should consider the cross-sectional shape as a parameter, not just the overall dimensions. Circular columns may require more fire protection than square columns of the same size, even though they have a higher initial capacity. This is a counterintuitive finding that should be communicated to designers and fire engineers.

Reference Value and Outlook

The paper provides valuable experimental data on the residual capacity of circular and square steel tube high-strength concrete short columns after high temperature exposure. The data can be used to develop and validate analytical models for the fire design of these structures. Future research should extend the study to longer columns, to columns under eccentric loading, and to columns with different steel tube wall thicknesses.

In my experience, fire is one of the most destructive forces that a steel structure can face, and the residual capacity after a fire is often the deciding factor in whether a structure can be repaired or must be demolished. This paper contributes to our ability to make that assessment with confidence.