ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Shield Tunnel Built-in Semi-Embedded Large Diameter Water Conveyance Steel Pipe: Key Technology Review

Overview of the Engineering Challenge

The paper by Zhang Yongjin and He Wei from Zhejiang Design Institute of Water Conservancy and Hydroelectric Power addresses a genuinely difficult interface problem: running a DN3200 steel pipe through a shield tunnel in the urban core of Hangzhou. The upstream section of the Jiaxing regional water diversion project had to cross Hangzhou city, and the design team chose a semi-embedded pipe configuration inside the tunnel rather than a conventional buried or exposed layout. From my years on large-diameter pipe installations, this is a smart move for urban space constraints, but it introduces thermal and restraint conditions that must be handled with care.

The fundamental problem is that a continuous steel pipe, restrained by friction along its length, will accumulate axial stress when the water temperature changes. If you do not provide a relief path, the pipe will either buckle, overstress the wall, or damage the supports. The paper's solution is elegant: a continuous concrete or cement mortar base under the pipe, three layers of SBS bitumen felt between the base and the tunnel lining segments, and a friction restraint that holds the middle section while allowing expansion at both ends through expansion joints installed within the first 0 to 450 m of each end.

Technical Interpretation of the Design Philosophy

The Semi-Embedded Configuration and Its Restraint System

The semi-embedded arrangement means the pipe sits in a shallow trough formed by the concrete base, with the lower portion of the pipe in contact with the base. This provides vertical support and lateral stability while allowing the pipe to slide axially when temperature changes occur. The three SBS bitumen felt layers serve as a slip interface, reducing the friction coefficient between the concrete base and the tunnel lining segments. This is a practical solution that I have seen used in various forms on pipeline projects, though the specific three-layer arrangement is worth noting for its redundancy.

The key design decision is the friction restraint in the middle of the tunnel. By allowing the middle section to be fully restrained, the design fixes the neutral point of thermal expansion. The pipe then expands or contracts symmetrically toward both ends, where the expansion joints absorb the movement. The 0 to 450 m range at each end is the zone where axial relative deformation between the pipe and the tunnel lining is accommodated.

Temperature Load Considerations

The paper highlights temperature load as the governing factor. For a DN3200 pipe, the cross-sectional area is substantial, and even a modest temperature change produces significant axial force. The design must consider both the operating temperature of the water and the ambient temperature within the tunnel. In a shield tunnel, the ambient temperature is relatively stable, but the water temperature can vary seasonally and with operating conditions.

From a practical standpoint, the design team needed to determine the friction coefficient between the steel pipe and the concrete base, the stiffness of the SBS felt layers, and the axial stiffness of the pipe itself. These parameters determine the distribution of axial stress along the pipe and the required travel of the expansion joints.

Engineering Practice Insights

What the Shop Floor and Site Crews Need to Know

The installation sequence for this type of configuration is critical. The pipe sections must be welded in the tunnel, which means the welding crew works in a confined space with limited access. For DN3200 pipe, the wall thickness is typically in the range of 16 to 20 mm, requiring multiple weld passes. The welding process must be carefully controlled to avoid distortion, and the pipe must be aligned precisely on the concrete base before welding.

The expansion joints at the ends are the most vulnerable components. They must be installed with the correct pre-compression or pre-extension to accommodate the expected thermal movement. If the installation temperature differs significantly from the design reference temperature, the expansion joints may not have sufficient travel to handle the full range of movement.

The Value of the Residual Space

One of the most practical aspects of this design is the use of the remaining space in the tunnel. After the pipe is installed, the annular space between the pipe and the tunnel lining can serve as a maintenance walkway and a conduit for low-voltage cables. This is a significant benefit in urban areas where underground space is at a premium. The paper notes this as an environmental and space-saving advantage, and I would add that it also simplifies future inspection and repair, as the pipe is accessible without excavation.

Critical Assessment and Lessons Learned

Potential Failure Modes and Mitigation

The friction restraint approach assumes that the friction coefficient is predictable and stable over the service life. In practice, the SBS felt layers may degrade over time, especially if water seeps between the layers. The design should include a factor of safety on the friction coefficient, and the installation should ensure that the felt layers are properly sealed at the edges to prevent water ingress.

The expansion joints are another concern. Large-diameter expansion joints are expensive and can be difficult to maintain in a tunnel environment. The design should specify accessible joint locations and provide a maintenance plan that includes periodic inspection and replacement of seals.

Comparison with Alternative Approaches

An alternative to the friction restraint approach would be to use anchor blocks at specific intervals along the pipe, creating a fully restrained pipeline with no expansion joints. However, this would require substantial thrust blocks at each anchor point, which is difficult in a tunnel environment. The semi-embedded configuration with friction restraint is a more practical solution for this application.

Another alternative is to use bellows expansion joints at the ends, which provide more flexibility but are more expensive and require more maintenance. The paper's choice of conventional expansion joints with the friction restraint system is a reasonable balance of cost and performance.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper provides a valuable reference for similar projects where large-diameter pipes must be installed in tunnels or other confined spaces. The key takeaway is that thermal expansion must be addressed systematically, considering the entire pipe-tunnel system as a coupled structure. The friction restraint approach is not new, but the specific application to a DN3200 pipe in a shield tunnel demonstrates its viability and provides design guidance.

For engineers involved in water conveyance projects, the paper offers a clear methodology for determining the neutral point, calculating axial forces, and sizing expansion joints. The use of the residual tunnel space for maintenance access is a bonus that should be considered in the economic evaluation of alternative designs.

Concluding Remarks

The semi-embedded large-diameter steel pipe in a shield tunnel is a robust and practical solution for urban water conveyance. The design effectively manages thermal expansion through a combination of friction restraint and end expansion joints, while maximizing the use of underground space. The key to success is careful installation, precise alignment, and a thorough understanding of the thermal and friction characteristics of the system. This paper is a useful reference for engineers facing similar challenges, and I would recommend it to anyone involved in large-diameter pipe installation in confined environments.